RMO No. 28-2007 operationalizes BIR TRS matching for withholding tax returns, alphalists, MAP, and SAWT, with fast response deadlines for TRS notices.
Withholding agents and income recipients face tighter BIR matching of income, withholding tax credits, VAT, and percentage tax declarations because RMO No. 28-2007 puts the Tax Reconciliation System, or TRS, into operational use for computerized comparison of alphalists, MAP, SAWT, and tax returns. Businesses should treat withholding tax submissions as audit-triggering data, not mere attachments, because discrepancies may result in a TRS Letter Notice, deficiency tax payment, issue-based audit, PAN, and FAN.
What RMO No. 28-2007 Changed
RMO No. 28-2007 prescribes the BIR procedures for transmitting, processing, extracting, matching, analyzing, disseminating, and using withholding tax and income recipient data under the TRS. The system uses a centralized Data Warehouse to compare information submitted by withholding agents with tax returns filed by income recipients. The affected returns include BIR Form No. 1604-CF for annual information returns on income taxes withheld on compensation and final withholding taxes, BIR Form No. 1604-E for annual information returns of creditable taxes withheld and income payments exempt from withholding tax, and withholding tax remittance returns such as BIR Forms Nos. 1601C, 1601E, 1601F, 1600, 1602, 1603, and 1606.
The most important operational change is that the BIR may generate discrepancy reports by matching income payments and withholding taxes reported by payors against sales, revenues, receipts, income, and withholding tax credits reported by payees or income recipients in their income tax, VAT, and percentage tax returns. This is intended to uncover under-declaration of income, non-declaration of income, under-remittance or non-remittance of taxes withheld, over-withholding, under-withholding, and over-declaration of tax credits.
RMO No. 28-2007 also states that the sales, revenue, or income figure arrived at under the TRS matching procedure shall be compared with the sales, revenue, or income arrived at under the RELIEF System. The higher figure generated under the two matching systems shall be the presumed correct sales, revenue, or income of the payee or income recipient. For taxpayers, this makes consistency among alphalists, SAWT, VAT returns, percentage tax returns, and income tax returns a critical compliance issue.
Who Is Affected
The Order affects withholding agents, income recipients, taxpayers claiming withholding tax credits, VAT taxpayers, percentage tax taxpayers, Large Taxpayers, and non-large taxpayers registered with Revenue District Offices. It is especially relevant to corporations, SMEs, professional service providers, suppliers, contractors, employers, and businesses that receive income subject to expanded withholding tax or final withholding tax.
Large Taxpayer returns are processed by the Large Taxpayers Service. Non-large taxpayer returns are processed by the Withholding Tax Division during the pilot stage and, after the system becomes fully operational, by the concerned Revenue District Offices. Computerized RDOs in Metro Manila are no longer required to transmit the original hard copy of the 2006 and subsequent years BIR Form Nos. 1604-CF, 1604-E, and 1600 to the Withholding Tax Division under the earlier RMO 80-98 process. Instead, they must process, encode, or upload withholding tax returns and attachments under the existing procedures in RMO 5-2001 and RR No. 2-2006.
Coverage and Effective Date
RMO No. 28-2007 was issued on September 17, 2007 and takes effect immediately. Its coverage includes annual information returns filed in soft copy or hard copy that are encoded or uploaded for calendar year 2005 and subsequent years. It also covers withholding tax returns, including those with Monthly Alphalist of Payees, and tax returns of income recipients with electronic or hard copy Summary Alphalist of Withholding Agents, beginning January 2006.
For businesses searching for BIR TRS matching, RMO 28-2007 alphalist requirements, TRS Letter Notice Philippines, MAP and SAWT withholding tax, or BIR withholding tax discrepancy notice, the practical point is the same: withholding tax data must reconcile across the payor and payee sides. A mismatch may become the basis of a BIR notice and assessment process.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
All RDOs are required to encode or upload returns, including attached alphalists, into the Integrated Tax System within thirty days for monthly, quarterly, or transactional tax returns and within sixty days for annual returns from the date of receipt of the returns. Returns required to have SAWT or MAP must likewise be uploaded.
Taxpayers who receive a TRS Letter Notice must act quickly. If a taxpayer fails to respond within fifteen days from receipt of the TRS-LN, the investigating office must issue a follow-up letter. If the taxpayer still fails to respond within another fifteen days from receipt of the follow-up letter, the case may proceed to an issue-based Letter of Authority, Notice for Informal Conference, and, if there is still no response within fifteen days, transmittal of the docket for PAN and FAN preparation under RR No. 12-99. For TRS-LNs covering taxable year 2005, no follow-up letter is necessary; after the lapse of fifteen days from delivery of the TRS-LN without response, an issue-based Letter of Authority shall be issued.
If the taxpayer disputes the discrepancy, the taxpayer may be required to submit schedules and supporting documents, reconcile the figures against returns and source documents, and execute a sworn statement attesting to the veracity and authenticity of the documents presented. If the discrepancy is attributed to third-party data, the BIR may obtain sworn statements and confirmation certificates from the payor, payee, withholding agent, or third-party information source. If discrepancies remain unresolved at the end of the thirty-day period, the revenue officer may recommend conversion of the TRS-LN into an issue-based Letter of Authority.
Payment and Installment Rules
Deficiency income tax, VAT, and percentage tax arising from TRS-LN findings are computed using the formulas prescribed in the Order and are paid using BIR Form No. 0605. The settlement and payment of deficiency taxes under a TRS-LN or issue-based Letter of Authority does not prevent the BIR from issuing a separate Letter of Authority for a comprehensive audit if warranted. However, payments made under the TRS-LN may be credited against an assessment involving discrepancies of the same nature for the same taxable year.
Installment payment is not available if the amount payable is not more than P500,000.00. If the amount payable exceeds P500,000.00 but is not more than P3,000,000.00, payment may be made in two equal installments: the first on the deadline set in the TRS-LN, and the second within thirty days from the deadline of the first installment or upon approval by the concerned approving authority. If the amount payable exceeds P3,000,000.00, payment may be made in three equal monthly installments. Deviations from these schemes require approval: amounts over P500,000.00 up to P10,000,000.00 require approval by the HREA, ACIR-LTS, ACIR-CS, or RD, while amounts over P10,000,000.00 require approval by the DCIR-OG or CIR.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 28-2007 links withholding tax discrepancies to deficiency taxes, basic tax, and increments. It expressly covers deficiency tax and penalties for under-withholding, non-withholding, under-remittance, non-remittance, and late remittance. If a taxpayer ignores a TRS-LN, the matter may escalate from a notice to an issue-based Letter of Authority, Notice for Informal Conference, Preliminary Assessment Notice, and Final Assessment Notice.
The Order also creates a significant risk for taxpayers who attempt to amend returns after receiving a TRS-LN. TRS-LNs are considered as Letters of Authority for purposes of amending returns. Therefore, returns covering the periods or transactions referred to in the TRS-LN can no longer be amended. If no returns were initially filed or required schedules were not attached, the taxpayer may no longer file by way of late compliance once the Commissioner has made a computation of the tax base and tax due.
Where a tax case has already been closed and the TRS-LN discrepancy was not considered, additional deficiency assessments based on TRS-LNs may still be issued if the case is not yet prescribed. The Order further provides that even if a case is considered prescribed under the three-year prescription rule, assessment notices and demand letters shall still be issued where there was underreporting of over thirty percent of tax due.
Practical Steps for Businesses
Businesses should immediately reconcile their annual alphalists, MAP, SAWT, withholding tax remittance returns, income tax returns, VAT returns, and percentage tax returns. CFOs and accounting teams should compare amounts reported by customers or clients as income payments against the company’s reported sales, receipts, and withholding tax credits. Discrepancies should be documented and explained before a TRS-LN is received.
Employers and withholding agents should review BIR Form No. 1604-CF and BIR Form No. 1604-E submissions for completeness, correct TINs, accurate payee names, correct income payment classifications, and correct withholding tax rates. Income recipients should preserve certificates of withholding tax, payment forms, contracts, invoices, official receipts, VAT returns, income tax returns, percentage tax returns, and schedules supporting tax credits claimed.
Upon receipt of a TRS Letter Notice, the taxpayer should not wait. The response period is short, and inaction can quickly lead to a formal audit and assessment process. The taxpayer should identify the discrepancy, reconcile it against source documents, determine whether the issue arose from its own return, the withholding agent’s alphalist, third-party data, or BIR encoding, and prepare the necessary sworn statements and supporting documents.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 28-2007 shows that BIR withholding tax compliance is now a data-matching problem as much as a tax law problem. A technically correct tax position may still become an assessment risk if the taxpayer’s alphalists, SAWT, MAP, income tax returns, VAT returns, and withholding tax credit claims do not reconcile.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing withholding tax exposure, responding to TRS Letter Notices, preparing reconciliations and sworn statements, handling BIR audits, and contesting deficiency tax assessments. For assistance with RMO No. 28-2007 compliance, TRS-LN responses, withholding tax audits, or BIR assessment defense, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.