RMC No. 73-2007 taxes prearranged block sales of listed shares as capital gains transactions, even when routed through the stock exchange.
Prearranged sales of listed shares, including block sales where the buyer is predetermined, should not be treated as ordinary stock exchange trades merely because the transaction passes through the Philippine Stock Exchange. For companies, major shareholders, brokers, CFOs, and tax teams structuring large share transfers, RMC No. 73-2007 makes the tax treatment turn on the economic substance of the transaction: if the public is effectively excluded from participating in the trade, the sale is subject to the capital gains tax rules for shares not disposed of through the local stock exchange, not the 1/2 of 1% stock transaction tax treatment.
What Changed Under RMC No. 73-2007
RMC No. 73-2007 re-issues the BIR guidelines on the proper treatment of block sales of shares of stock disposed of in the Stock Exchange. The key rule is that a sale of shares of stock where the sale is prearranged or the buyer is predetermined is taxable under the capital gains tax provisions of the Tax Code, even if the transaction technically passed through the Exchange or used the Exchange facility.
The circular expressly states that the BIR will look at the economic and substantial aspect of the transaction, rather than only its formal appearance. In practical terms, the fact that a trade is entered into the Exchange system does not automatically qualify it for the preferential stock transaction tax treatment if the transaction was already arranged between identified parties and did not genuinely allow the investing public to participate.
This is especially important for block sales of listed shares. Under the Securities Regulation Code implementing rules cited in the circular, a block sale is a matched trade that does not go through the automated order matching system of an Exchange trading system, but is instead prearranged by and among the broker-dealer’s clients and then entered as a done deal directly into the trading system.
Why the Tax Treatment Matters
The Tax Code traditionally distinguishes between listed shares traded through the local stock exchange and shares not disposed of through the local stock exchange. Under Section 127 of the Tax Code of 1997, the sale, barter, exchange, or other disposition of shares of stock, other than a sale by a dealer in securities, is taxed at the rate of 1/2 of 1% of the gross selling price or gross value in money if the shares are listed and traded through the local stock exchange.
By contrast, for shares that are not disposed of through the local stock exchange, the applicable treatment is final tax on net capital gains at either 5% or 10%, under the relevant capital gains tax provisions cited in the circular, including Section 24(C), Section 25(A)(3), Section 25(B), Section 27(D)(2), Section 28(A)(7)(c), and Section 28(B)(5)(c) of the Tax Code of 1997, as amended.
The distinction is financially significant. A 1/2 of 1% tax on gross selling price can be materially different from a 5% or 10% final tax on net capital gains. For large share transfers, especially negotiated transfers of substantial corporate blocks, the difference may affect pricing, closing mechanics, tax indemnities, escrow arrangements, and board or shareholder approvals.
Who Is Most Affected
The parties most affected are major shareholders, corporations undergoing ownership changes, listed companies with significant share transfers, investment houses, broker-dealers, corporate finance teams, tax managers, and in-house counsel involved in negotiated transfers of listed shares.
Business owners and CFOs should pay close attention where the transaction involves a specific buyer, a negotiated price, a matched trade, or a block of shares that is not exposed to ordinary public trading through the automated order matching system. The relevant search phrases for affected taxpayers include block sale of shares tax Philippines, RMC 73-2007 block sale, capital gains tax on listed shares Philippines, stock transaction tax versus capital gains tax, and prearranged sale of shares through PSE.
The circular is also addressed to the Philippine Stock Exchange, internal revenue officers and employees, and all others concerned. This means the guidance is not limited to taxpayers alone. It also informs how BIR personnel may evaluate and assess transactions that are formally routed through the Exchange but are substantively prearranged private transfers.
Key Compliance Requirement: Substance Over Form
The central compliance requirement is to determine whether the sale was genuinely traded through the local stock exchange in a manner open to public participation, or whether the transaction was prearranged, matched, or made to a predetermined buyer.
If the sale was prearranged or the buyer was predetermined, the taxpayer should not rely solely on the fact that the Exchange facility was used. RMC No. 73-2007 provides that such sales are taxable under the capital gains tax provisions, notwithstanding the fact that the transaction passed through the Exchange or that the Exchange facility was used.
The circular further provides that any transaction which, in effect, excludes the public by any means from taking part in the trading shall be taxed under the relevant capital gains tax provisions. This wording is broad. It expressly covers block sales but is not limited to block sales. Other matched, negotiated, or prearranged trades may therefore be examined under the same principle if the structure effectively prevents public participation.
Effective Date and Deadline
RMC No. 73-2007 states that it shall take effect immediately. The circular is dated November 12, 2007. For transactions covered by the circular, taxpayers should treat the guidance as immediately operative from its issuance and should review any block sale or prearranged sale of listed shares accordingly.
No separate filing deadline is created by the circular itself. However, the tax classification of the transaction must be determined at the time the share sale is structured, documented, and closed. Waiting until after closing may create avoidable exposure if the parties used the 1/2 of 1% stock transaction tax framework when the BIR later determines that the transaction should have been treated as a capital gains tax transaction.
Penalties and Assessment Risk
RMC No. 73-2007 does not provide a separate penalty schedule. Its practical consequence is classification risk. If a taxpayer treats a prearranged block sale as a regular stock exchange transaction and pays only the tax applicable to listed shares traded through the Exchange, the BIR may take the position that the transaction should have been taxed under the capital gains tax rules for shares not disposed of through the local stock exchange.
The most immediate risk is a deficiency tax assessment based on the difference between the tax actually paid and the tax that the BIR believes should have been paid under the applicable capital gains tax provisions. For negotiated transfers of significant blocks of listed shares, this risk should be addressed before signing and closing, not after the tax position has already been reported.
Practical Steps for Companies, Shareholders, and Brokers
First, identify whether the trade is a true public market trade or a prearranged sale. If the buyer was already identified before execution, if the transaction was matched outside the automated order matching system, or if the Exchange entry merely recorded a done deal, the parties should analyze RMC No. 73-2007 before applying stock transaction tax treatment.
Second, document the commercial and tax characterization of the transaction. Sale agreements, board approvals, broker instructions, closing documents, and tax computations should be consistent. If the transaction is a block sale, the tax team should not assume that routing through the Exchange is enough to secure the 1/2 of 1% treatment.
Third, model the tax impact early. Compare the 1/2 of 1% tax on gross selling price or gross value in money with the 5% or 10% final tax on net capital gains, as applicable. The economics of the transaction may change depending on whether the sale is treated as a genuine exchange trade or as a capital gains tax transaction.
Fourth, address tax responsibility in the transaction documents. The parties should specify who bears the applicable taxes, who files and pays, what representations are made regarding the nature of the trade, and whether indemnities apply if the BIR later challenges the tax treatment.
Fifth, obtain tax advice before execution where the transaction involves a substantial block of listed shares, a predetermined buyer, or a negotiated transfer between known parties. These are precisely the structures that RMC No. 73-2007 targets.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 73-2007 is a reminder that BIR compliance for share transfers is not just a mechanical question of where the transaction is entered. It requires a careful review of the transaction’s substance, the parties’ arrangements, the tax provisions triggered, and the supporting documentation.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, shareholders, investors, brokers, and finance teams on Philippine tax compliance, share sale structuring, capital gains tax exposure, and BIR assessment risk. For assistance with block sales of listed shares, prearranged stock transfers, tax documentation, or BIR compliance strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.