Private clubs and non-stock corporations may face damages when membership denials rely on hidden rules, bad faith, or arbitrary board action.

Private clubs, associations, and non-stock corporations may have discretion to accept or reject members, but that discretion is not absolute. When a board relies on undisclosed rules, ignores reconsideration letters, and leaves an applicant without a fair explanation, the rejection can become an abuse of rights that exposes both the corporation and its directors to damages.

The Rule: Corporate Discretion Must Still Be Exercised in Good Faith

The doctrine at the heart of Cebu Country Club v. Elizagaque is simple but powerful: a legal right becomes actionable when exercised arbitrarily, unjustly, or in bad faith. The Supreme Court applied Articles 19 and 21 of the Civil Code, which require every person, including corporations and directors, to act with justice, give everyone his due, and observe honesty and good faith.

This matters beyond country clubs. Non-stock corporations, homeowners associations, professional societies, chambers, cooperatives, and membership-based organizations often rely on bylaws to screen applicants. The ruling confirms that even where bylaws give a board discretion, that discretion must be exercised with transparency, fairness, and basic civility.

Background: A Proprietary Share Did Not Guarantee Fair Treatment

Cebu Country Club, Inc. was a non-profit, non-stock private membership club in Cebu. Ricardo Elizagaque had been designated by San Miguel Corporation as a special non-proprietary member and later applied for proprietary membership. His application was endorsed by two proprietary members, and he acquired a proprietary ownership certificate after buying a share from another member.

The club’s board later disapproved his application. The decisive point was that the club had amended its bylaws in 1978 to require the unanimous vote of all directors present before an applicant could be included in the eligible-for-membership list. But the application form used by Elizagaque did not reflect that amendment. It still carried the older language, which did not state that unanimity was required. The dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court in Cebu Country Club, Inc. v. Elizagaque (G.R. No. 160273, January 18, 2008).

Why the Supreme Court Found Bad Faith

The Court recognized that Cebu Country Club had the right under its articles and bylaws to approve or disapprove membership applications. However, it rejected the idea that this right could be exercised in a manner that was opaque, misleading, or unfair.

The Court gave weight to several circumstances. First, the unanimity requirement was highly material to the application process, yet it was not printed on the form given to the applicant. Second, the amendment had existed for almost twenty years before the application, making the failure to update the form difficult to justify. Third, when the applicant sought reconsideration and asked whether any director had objected, the club did not answer. In the Court’s view, he was left groping in the dark as to why his application had been rejected.

The Court held that this conduct violated the Civil Code provisions on human relations. The corporation and its directors were not penalized merely for rejecting the application. They were held liable because the rejection was found to have been carried out with fraud, evident bad faith, and disregard of the applicant’s right to be treated fairly.

Damnum Absque Injuria Did Not Protect the Club

The club argued that even if Elizagaque suffered damage, there was no legal injury because the board had the right to reject applications. This is the doctrine of damnum absque injuria, or damage without legal injury.

The Supreme Court rejected that defense. The doctrine does not apply where a person or corporation abuses a right. In other words, a board cannot simply say, we had the power to do it, if the manner in which the power was exercised was arbitrary, unjust, excessive, or contrary to good faith.

Damages Were Awarded, But Reduced

The Supreme Court upheld the award of damages but substantially reduced the amounts. It recognized that moral damages were proper because the applicant suffered mental anguish, social humiliation, and wounded feelings from the arbitrary denial. However, it reduced the moral damages from P2,000,000.00 to P50,000.00, emphasizing that moral damages should not be excessive or used to enrich the claimant.

The Court also reduced exemplary damages from P1,000,000.00 to P25,000.00. Exemplary damages were allowed as a corrective measure for the public good, but the Court stressed that they should deter improper conduct, not impoverish one party or create a windfall for another. Attorney’s fees were reduced to P50,000.00, and litigation expenses were reduced to P25,000.00.

Directors Can Be Jointly and Severally Liable

One of the most important corporate law aspects of the ruling is the Court’s application of Section 31 of the Corporation Code. The directors argued that they could not be held jointly and severally liable because only one director effectively caused the disapproval through the black ball vote. The Court disagreed.

Under Section 31, directors or trustees who willfully and knowingly vote for or assent to patently unlawful acts of the corporation, or who are guilty of gross negligence or bad faith in directing corporate affairs, may be jointly and severally liable for resulting damages suffered by the corporation, its stockholders or members, or other persons. For boards of non-stock corporations, this is a serious reminder that personal exposure is possible when corporate powers are exercised in bad faith.

Practical Impact for Tax-Exempt and Membership-Based Organizations

For a tax, corporate, and compliance audience, the lesson is governance-driven. Many non-stock and non-profit organizations rely on carefully drafted articles, bylaws, membership rules, assessment policies, and tax-exemption representations. But written rules are not enough. The organization must also implement those rules fairly, consistently, and transparently.

Organizations should ensure that application forms, member notices, board resolutions, and published rules are aligned with the current bylaws. If a membership right, assessment, admission requirement, or internal approval threshold has been amended, the old documents should be withdrawn and replaced. An outdated form can become evidence of unfair dealing, especially where the missing rule is decisive.

Boards should also maintain proper minutes and communicate decisions in a manner consistent with due process and good faith. The Court did not require a private club to admit every applicant. What it required was that the applicant not be misled, ignored, or subjected to arbitrary treatment. For organizations that depend on member contributions, proprietary shares, dues, or tax-sensitive non-stock status, poor governance can quickly become litigation risk.

What This Means for Applicants, Members, and Boards

For rejected applicants, this ruling shows that not every denial is beyond challenge. A lawsuit may be possible where the rejection was based on hidden rules, discriminatory or bad-faith treatment, misleading forms, or a board’s refusal to explain material grounds despite repeated requests.

For directors and trustees, the ruling is a warning against treating corporate discretion as a shield for arbitrary conduct. A board may reject an application, but it should be able to show that the decision followed current bylaws, was properly documented, and was not made in bad faith.

For corporations and associations, the safest practice is to audit governance documents regularly. Application forms, membership manuals, website terms, bylaws, board policies, and secretariat templates should say the same thing. If the board wants broad discretion, the scope of that discretion should be clearly stated and exercised consistently.

Need Help with Membership, Corporate Governance, or Board Liability Issues?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, non-stock organizations, associations, property owners, and individuals in disputes involving corporate governance, board liability, membership rights, damages, and civil litigation. If your organization needs to review its bylaws, membership rules, board processes, or litigation exposure, or if you are challenging an arbitrary corporate or association decision, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our litigation and corporate law team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *