RMC No. 25-2009 sets eFPS transition rules for enhanced BIR forms under RA 9504 and RR No. 7-2008, including manual submission and amendment deadlines.
EFPS taxpayers using returns affected by RA No. 9504 and RR No. 7-2008 must temporarily file through the old online eFPS forms, manually compute the correct tax due using the enhanced forms, pay the manually computed amount, and submit the enhanced forms to their registered Revenue District Office or Large Taxpayers Office within fifteen (15) days after e-filing and e-payment. RMC No. 25-2009 matters immediately to withholding agents, corporations, self-employed taxpayers, and taxpayers covered by the gold and metallic mineral product rules because the enhanced forms were already available for use in BIR offices but were not yet available in eFPS.
What RMC No. 25-2009 Changed
RMC No. 25-2009 prescribed a transition procedure for all eFPS filers whose tax returns were affected by two developments: Republic Act No. 9504 and Revenue Regulations No. 7-2008. The practical problem addressed by the Circular was that the BIR had already enhanced several tax forms to reflect the new law and regulations, but those enhanced forms were not yet available in the electronic Filing and Payment System.
The most important rule is that eFPS filers could not simply rely on the old eFPS system-computed fields when the applicable enhanced form produced a different tax result. They were required to e-file using the available online form, disregard the system-computed fields where necessary, e-pay the manually computed tax due based on the applicable enhanced BIR form, and submit the Filing Reference Number Page together with the properly completed enhanced forms to the RDO or Large Taxpayers Office where they were registered.
This is a compliance bridge rule. It allowed taxpayers to continue using eFPS despite the system not yet reflecting the enhanced BIR forms, while still requiring the taxpayer to compute and pay the correct tax under the updated form.
Enhanced BIR Forms Covered Under RA No. 9504
For taxpayers affected by Republic Act No. 9504, the enhanced forms listed in RMC No. 25-2009 all carried a July 2008 ENCS version date. These included BIR Form No. 1601C, the Monthly Remittance Return of Income Taxes Withheld on Compensation; BIR Form No. 1604CF, the Annual Information Return of Income Taxes Withheld on Compensation and Final Withholding Taxes; BIR Form No. 1700, the Annual Income Tax Return for Individuals Earning Compensation Income and Marginal Income Earner, including non-business and non-profession related income; BIR Form No. 1701, the Annual Income Tax Return for Self-Employed Individuals, Estates and Trusts, including those with both business and compensation income; BIR Form No. 1701Q, the Quarterly Income Tax Return for Self-Employed Individuals, Estates and Trusts, including those with both business and compensation income; BIR Form No. 1702, the Annual Income Tax Return for Corporations, Partnerships and Other Non-Individual Taxpayers; and BIR Form No. 1702Q, the Quarterly Income Tax Return for Corporations, Partnerships and Other Non-Individual Taxpayers.
For businesses, the key takeaway is that the transition procedure did not apply only to individual taxpayers. It covered compensation withholding, annual withholding information returns, individual income tax returns, self-employed income tax returns, and corporate income tax returns. Corporate accountants and tax managers therefore had to review whether their eFPS filing involved any of the affected forms before relying on the old online form output.
Enhanced BIR Form Covered Under RR No. 7-2008
For Revenue Regulations No. 7-2008, RMC No. 25-2009 identified BIR Form No. 1601E, the Monthly Remittance Return of Creditable Income Taxes Withheld (Expanded), except for transactions involving onerous transfer of real property classified as ordinary asset. The applicable form version date was August 2008 ENCS.
This portion is relevant to taxpayers dealing with the taxation of the sale to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas of gold and other metallic mineral products extracted or produced by small scale miners. Businesses and withholding agents searching for RR No. 7-2008 eFPS filing, BSP gold withholding tax, small scale miners tax BIR Form 1601E, and expanded withholding tax eFPS transition rules should treat RMC No. 25-2009 as the operational filing instruction during the period before the enhanced form became available online.
Who Is Affected
RMC No. 25-2009 applies to all eFPS filers filing affected returns. The most directly affected taxpayers are employers and withholding agents filing BIR Form 1601C or 1604CF, individual compensation earners and marginal income earners filing BIR Form 1700, self-employed individuals, estates, and trusts filing BIR Form 1701 or 1701Q, corporations and other non-individual taxpayers filing BIR Form 1702 or 1702Q, and withholding agents filing BIR Form 1601E in relation to the RR No. 7-2008 rules.
Large taxpayers were specifically implicated because the required manual submission could be made to the Large Taxpayers Office where the taxpayer was registered. SMEs and other taxpayers registered with Revenue District Offices were likewise covered if they were eFPS filers using the affected forms.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
The transition procedure had four concrete steps. First, the eFPS filer had to fill up the necessary fields of the corresponding available BIR online form. Second, the taxpayer had to submit the completed online return and wait for the filing reference number. Third, the taxpayer had to e-pay the manually computed tax due based on the enhanced BIR form, not merely the tax due generated by the old eFPS form. Fourth, the taxpayer had to submit the Filing Reference Number Page together with the properly filled-up applicable enhanced forms to the RDO or Large Taxpayers Office where it was registered within fifteen (15) days after e-filing and e-payment.
The Circular also established a later amendment requirement. Once the enhanced forms became available in eFPS, e-filers were required to amend the previously filed old tax returns in eFPS within five (5) days from the date of announcement through the BIR website. The amendment had to encode the contents of the applicable enhanced forms that had previously been submitted to the Revenue District Office.
No additional e-payment was required if the tax due on the amended return was equal to the amount previously paid. However, if the tax due on the amended return was greater than the amount previously paid, the taxpayer had to e-pay the unpaid amount.
When Manual Submission Stops
Manual submission of the Filing Reference Number Page and enhanced forms was a temporary requirement. RMC No. 25-2009 expressly states that manual submission would no longer be required once the enhanced BIR forms became available in eFPS. Until that point, however, eFPS filing and payment alone did not complete the transition procedure for the affected returns.
Penalties and Compliance Risk
RMC No. 25-2009 does not state a separate penalty schedule for failure to follow the transition procedure. However, the compliance risk is clear. A taxpayer that relied only on the old eFPS form, ignored the manually computed tax due under the enhanced form, failed to submit the enhanced form within fifteen (15) days, failed to amend within five (5) days from the BIR website announcement, or failed to pay any additional unpaid amount could have an inaccurate or incomplete filing record for the affected return.
For CFOs, controllers, and accounting teams, the practical issue is not merely whether the return was electronically filed. The correct question is whether the taxpayer used the applicable July 2008 ENCS or August 2008 ENCS enhanced form, manually computed the correct tax, paid the correct amount, submitted the enhanced form to the correct office within the prescribed period, and later amended the old eFPS return within the five (5)-day window once the enhanced form became available online.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Accounting Teams
Taxpayers should identify whether their eFPS filings involved BIR Form Nos. 1601C, 1604CF, 1700, 1701, 1701Q, 1702, 1702Q, or 1601E. They should confirm whether the return was affected by RA No. 9504 or RR No. 7-2008. They should retain the filing reference number, the manually completed enhanced form, proof of e-payment, and proof of submission to the relevant RDO or Large Taxpayers Office.
For past filings made during the transition period, tax teams should check whether amended returns were encoded in eFPS within five (5) days from the relevant BIR website announcement. If the amended return showed a higher tax due than the amount previously paid, the unpaid amount should have been e-paid. This is particularly important in tax audits because the BIR may compare the old eFPS filing, the enhanced form submitted manually, and the amended eFPS return.
Useful search terms for this issuance include RMC No. 25-2009 eFPS transition procedure, RA 9504 enhanced BIR forms, RR No. 7-2008 BIR Form 1601E, eFPS amended return five days BIR website announcement, and BIR Form 1702Q July 2008 ENCS eFPS filing.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, withholding agents, and regulated taxpayers in reviewing BIR compliance procedures, reconstructing filing records, responding to tax assessments, and preparing defensible submissions before Revenue District Offices and Large Taxpayers Offices. For companies dealing with legacy eFPS issues, enhanced form discrepancies, withholding tax filings, or income tax return amendments, ASG Law can help determine what was required, what was filed, and how to address compliance gaps before they become assessment issues. For assistance with BIR compliance and tax controversy matters, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.