RMO No. 18-2009 removes the prior BIR ruling requirement for qualified CAR/TCL applications on condominium land and common area transfers.

Real estate developers and condominium corporations no longer need to secure a prior BIR ruling before obtaining a Certificate Authorizing Registration or Tax Clearance for the transfer of land and common areas to a condominium corporation, provided the transaction falls within the facts covered by RMO No. 18-2009. This immediately shortens the BIR clearance process for qualified condominium projects organized under the Condominium Act and clarifies the tax treatment of transfers made without monetary consideration.

What RMO No. 18-2009 Changed

RMO No. 18-2009 dispensed with the previous requirement of securing a prior BIR ruling as a prerequisite for the issuance of a Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR) or Tax Clearance (TCL) covering the conveyance of land and common areas by a real estate developer to a condominium corporation.

Before this order, a real estate developer and the condominium corporation generally had to obtain a BIR ruling confirming the tax-exempt status of the transfer before the concerned Revenue District Office could issue the CAR/TCL. The BIR recognized that this additional step had protracted the process for transactions whose tax consequences had already been consistently resolved in prior BIR rulings.

The key change is procedural but highly practical: the concerned Revenue District Officer may now issue the CAR/TCL upon submission of the required documents, without waiting for a prior confirmatory ruling, if the facts and circumstances of the transfer are analogous to the facts covered by the BIR’s prior rulings on condominium land and common area transfers.

Who Is Affected by RMO No. 18-2009

The issuance is most relevant to real estate developers, condominium corporations, condominium unit owners, corporate accountants, tax compliance officers, property administrators, and lawyers handling real property transfers connected with condominium projects.

It particularly affects developers who remain the registered owners of the land on which a condominium project was constructed and who must convey the land and common areas to a condominium corporation organized under Republic Act No. 4726, otherwise known as the Condominium Act.

It also affects condominium corporations formed for the purpose of holding title to the land and common areas, managing and maintaining the same, and doing so for the benefit of the condominium unit owners. The order is important for condominium turnover and title processing because the CAR/TCL is needed before the transfer may proceed through the appropriate registration process.

Transactions Covered by the Streamlined CAR/TCL Process

The streamlined process applies only where the facts are analogous to the BIR’s previously promulgated rulings on the tax consequences of conveying condominium land and common areas to a condominium corporation.

The covered transaction involves a real estate developer that is the registered owner of a parcel of land and that developed a condominium building on that land in accordance with Republic Act No. 4726. A condominium corporation must have been formed to hold the land and common areas, whether in ownership or through another legally recognized interest in real property, and to manage the land and common areas for the benefit of the condominium unit owners.

The articles of incorporation and by-laws of the condominium corporation must not contain any provision contrary to or inconsistent with the Condominium Act, the enabling or master deed of conveyance, or the declaration of restrictions of the project. Membership in the condominium corporation, whether stock or non-stock, must not be transferable separately from the condominium unit to which it is appurtenant. When a member or stockholder ceases to own a unit in the project, that person must automatically cease to be a member or stockholder of the condominium corporation.

The condominium corporation, although it enjoys the power of ownership, must be prohibited by law from transacting the properties for gainful profit. The conveyance must be made through a Deed of Conveyance executed between the owner-developer and the condominium corporation, transferring title to the land, the common areas of the building, and the facilities of the project in favor of the condominium corporation, free from liens and encumbrances.

Most importantly, the Deed of Conveyance must be executed without monetary consideration and in pursuance of the requirements of the Condominium Act, which mandates that the condominium corporation hold title to the common areas, including the land.

Documentary Requirements Before CAR/TCL Issuance

RMO No. 18-2009 does not remove documentation requirements. Before issuing the CAR/TCL, the concerned RDO must require the taxpayer to submit a letter duly signed by the authorized representative requesting the issuance of the CAR/TCL for the transfer of the land and common areas from the real estate developer to the condominium corporation. The letter must state the reasons for the transfer and all facts and information necessary for the RDO to determine that the transaction falls within the type of transfer contemplated by the order.

The taxpayer must also submit a certified true copy of the notarized Master Deed of Conveyance of Land and Common Areas with Declaration of Restrictions. If there is an amendment to the Master Deed of Conveyance of Land and Common Areas with Declaration of Restrictions, a certified true copy of the notarized amendment must also be submitted.

The RDO must likewise require certified true copies of the Transfer Certificate of Title of the land being conveyed, the Tax Declaration of the land, and the Tax Declaration of the common areas. The condominium corporation’s corporate documents are also required, including a certified true copy of its SEC registration and Articles of Incorporation, as well as a certified true copy of its by-laws.

Tax Consequences: CWT, DST, VAT, and Notarial DST

RMO No. 18-2009 confirms the BIR’s consistent position that, where the Deed of Conveyance is made without consideration and is not connected with a sale to the condominium corporation, no taxable income is realized. Consequently, no creditable withholding tax is payable or collectible for this type of transfer.

The order also states that the Deed of Conveyance is exempt from documentary stamp tax under Section 196 of the Tax Code, as amended. This exemption is based on Section 185 of the Revised Documentary Stamp Tax Regulations, which provides that conveyances of realty not in connection with a sale, to trustees or other persons without consideration, are not taxable.

However, the notarial acknowledgment of the Deed of Conveyance remains subject to documentary stamp tax of P15.00 under Section 188 of the Tax Code, as amended. This P15.00 DST is a specific compliance detail that accountants and property administrators should not overlook when preparing the transfer documents.

The transfer of the land and common areas to the condominium corporation is also not subject to VAT under Title IV of the Tax Code, as amended. The BIR’s reasoning is that the transfer is not a sale, the developer receives no additional payment, the conveyance is without monetary consideration, and beneficial ownership is retained by the condominium unit owners through the condominium corporation. For VAT purposes, the transaction cannot be treated as a taxable sale under Section 105 of the Tax Code.

Effective Date and Practical Deadline

RMO No. 18-2009 took effect immediately on April 26, 2009. There is no separate future deadline stated in the order. The practical compliance point is that qualified taxpayers may proceed directly with the concerned RDO for CAR/TCL processing without first obtaining a prior BIR ruling, as long as the transaction satisfies the facts and documentation required by the order.

Although a prior BIR ruling is no longer mandatory, the order expressly allows the taxpayer, at its option, to still secure a prior ruling from the Bureau to confirm the tax-exempt status of the transfer. This may be useful where the facts are not clean, the condominium documents contain unusual provisions, the transfer involves consideration, or the RDO is not assured that the transaction is analogous to the BIR’s prior rulings.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RMO No. 18-2009 does not prescribe a new penalty for non-compliance. The risk is practical and transactional: the RDO may refuse to issue the CAR/TCL if the taxpayer cannot establish that the transfer is the same kind of transaction contemplated by the order or if the required documents are incomplete.

There is also substantive tax risk if the transfer is not truly without monetary consideration, if the condominium corporation is not properly organized under the Condominium Act, if the corporate documents allow transactions for gainful profit inconsistent with the contemplated condominium structure, or if the transfer is connected with a sale. In those cases, the taxpayer should not assume automatic exemption from creditable withholding tax, documentary stamp tax under Section 196, or VAT.

Practical Steps for Developers and Condominium Corporations

Developers and condominium corporations should first verify that the condominium corporation was organized for the proper statutory purpose: holding title to and managing the land and common areas for the benefit of the condominium unit owners. They should review the articles of incorporation and by-laws to ensure that membership is inseparable from ownership of the condominium unit and that the documents are not inconsistent with Republic Act No. 4726, the master deed, or the declaration of restrictions.

Second, the Deed of Conveyance should clearly state that the transfer is made without monetary consideration and in compliance with the Condominium Act. The deed should also reflect that the conveyance covers the land, common areas, and facilities of the condominium project, and that the property is conveyed free from liens and encumbrances, if that is the actual fact.

Third, the taxpayer should prepare a complete CAR/TCL package before filing with the RDO. The submission should include the request letter, certified true copies of the notarized master deed and amendments, the TCT, tax declarations for the land and common areas, SEC registration, articles of incorporation, and by-laws. The request letter should not be generic; it should explain why the transfer falls within the circumstances contemplated by RMO No. 18-2009.

Fourth, accountants should reflect the tax treatment carefully. For qualified transactions, the order provides that no creditable withholding tax is payable, no DST under Section 196 is due on the conveyance, and no VAT is imposed. However, the P15.00 DST on the notarial acknowledgment under Section 188 should still be accounted for.

Fifth, where the facts are unusual or incomplete, the parties should consider whether to voluntarily seek a ruling despite the streamlined procedure. The optional ruling mechanism remains available and may be prudent for projects with atypical structures, title complications, amendments to the master deed, or questions on whether the transfer is truly without consideration.

Search Terms Accountants and Property Developers Use for This Issue

Business owners, CFOs, corporate accountants, and real estate compliance teams typically search for this issue using phrases such as RMO No. 18-2009 CAR TCL condominium corporation, BIR ruling not required condominium common areas transfer, tax exemption transfer land to condominium corporation, DST VAT CWT condominium common areas conveyance, and CAR requirements for condominium land transfer Philippines.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMO No. 18-2009 can significantly speed up condominium land and common area transfers, but only when the transaction is properly structured and documented. A defective deed, incomplete corporate records, inconsistent by-laws, or an unclear statement on consideration can delay the CAR/TCL process or expose the parties to unnecessary tax issues.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists real estate developers, condominium corporations, property administrators, corporate accountants, and business owners in reviewing conveyance documents, preparing CAR/TCL submissions, assessing CWT, DST, and VAT exposure, and coordinating with the appropriate BIR office for tax-compliant property transfers.

For assistance with condominium land transfers, CAR/TCL requirements, BIR tax clearance issues, and real estate tax compliance in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *