RMC No. 26-2009 revokes a ruling allowing manpower services to exclude salaries and benefits from the 2% withholding tax base.
Manpower service providers and their payors must compute the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax on the gross income from the sale of services, without excluding amounts earmarked for salaries, wages, or employee benefits. RMC No. 26-2009 revokes BIR RR7 Ruling No. RR7-003-876 dated September 13, 2006, which had previously allowed Trendset Manpower Services to exclude amounts segregated for particular purposes, such as salaries and other benefits, when computing the income payment subject to withholding tax.
What RMC No. 26-2009 Changed
RMC No. 26-2009 cancelled and revoked BIR RR7 Ruling No. RR7-003-876, a regional ruling addressed to Trendset Manpower Services. The revoked ruling had stated that, for purposes of computing the income payment subject to the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax on the sale of services, the basis would be the gross receipts representing the contract price or service fee rendered by Trendset Manpower Services, excluding amounts segregated or earmarked for a particular purpose, such as salaries and other benefits.
The Commissioner of Internal Revenue rejected that treatment. RMC No. 26-2009 states that the prior ruling was a blatant disregard of the spirit of the law and regulations on the withholding tax system because the basis of withholding tax, whether creditable or final, is gross income without qualification. In practical terms, the BIR position is that a taxpayer cannot reduce the withholding tax base merely by labeling part of the billing as salaries, benefits, or reimbursable employee-related amounts.
The circular specifically refers to Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 17-2003, including Section 2.57.2(A), which refers to gross professional, promotional, and talent fees, or any other form of remuneration for services. The controlling concept is gross income or gross remuneration for services, not net service margin after excluding payroll-related components.
Who Is Affected by the Revocation
The most directly affected taxpayers are manpower agencies, staffing companies, service contractors, outsourcing providers, and businesses that structure their billings into service fees plus salary or benefit components. RMC No. 26-2009 is especially important for companies that provide personnel to clients and invoice the client for amounts that include both the agency’s service component and the compensation or benefits of assigned workers.
Payors and withholding agents are also affected. Businesses engaging manpower service providers should not rely on a supplier’s invoice classification alone if that classification attempts to exclude salaries or benefits from the amount subject to creditable withholding tax. For Philippine accountants and CFOs searching for guidance on manpower agency withholding tax, 2% creditable withholding tax on services, gross income withholding tax base, salaries and benefits exclusion from withholding tax, and Revenue Regulations No. 17-2003 service fees, the key compliance point is direct: withholding should be based on gross income from the service payment as required by the withholding tax regulations.
The Key Compliance Rule: Use Gross Income Without Unauthorized Exclusions
The most important compliance rule under RMC No. 26-2009 is that the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax on the sale of services must be computed on the proper gross income base, without an unauthorized deduction or exclusion for amounts segregated or earmarked for salaries and other benefits.
This matters because manpower and service arrangements often involve large pass-through amounts. A manpower provider may invoice a client for worker salaries, mandatory benefits, administrative charges, and a service fee. The revoked ruling would have allowed the exclusion of amounts earmarked for salaries and benefits from the computation of the income payment subject to the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax. RMC No. 26-2009 withdraws that position and makes clear that such exclusion has no legal basis under the cited withholding tax rules.
For accounting teams, this means the withholding tax review should not stop at the label used in the invoice. The substance of the payment must be examined against the applicable withholding tax regulations. Where the payment is for the sale of services, the relevant tax base is not reduced simply because part of the amount will later be used by the service provider to pay wages, salaries, or benefits.
Authority of Regional Rulings and Why the BIR Revoked the Prior Treatment
RMC No. 26-2009 also carries an important governance message: not every ruling issued at the regional level may validly settle issues beyond the delegated authority of the issuing official. The circular states that the then Regional Director acted beyond the scope of delegated authority because the issue settled was not one of those mentioned in Revenue Memorandum Order No. 75-99 and Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 3-2001, as amended by Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 39-2001.
This is a warning to taxpayers relying on old regional rulings, especially those granting favorable tax treatment. A ruling may be vulnerable if it conflicts with the law or regulations, or if the official who issued it had no authority to rule on that issue. For businesses, the practical lesson is to periodically review tax rulings, exemptions, and special treatments relied upon in withholding tax computations, particularly where the ruling allows a lower tax base or a narrower interpretation of gross income.
Effective Date and Scope of Revocation
RMC No. 26-2009 is dated May 11, 2009. It expressly revokes BIR RR7 Ruling No. RR7-003-876 dated September 13, 2006. It also states that all other existing rulings inconsistent with RMC No. 26-2009 are likewise considered revoked.
The scope is therefore not limited to Trendset Manpower Services alone. While the cancelled ruling was addressed to a specific taxpayer, the circular announces a broader BIR position: inconsistent rulings allowing exclusions from the withholding tax base contrary to the gross income rule are revoked. Taxpayers and withholding agents should treat this as a general compliance directive when dealing with payments for services subject to creditable withholding tax.
Penalties and Audit Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 26-2009 does not create a separate penalty table. However, under the withholding tax system, failure to withhold the correct amount can expose the withholding agent to deficiency withholding tax, surcharge, interest, and compromise penalties under the Tax Code and applicable regulations. The more immediate audit risk is that a payor may be assessed for under-withholding if it computed the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax only on a reduced service fee, instead of the proper gross income base.
For manpower service providers, there is also documentation risk. If invoices separate salaries, benefits, administrative charges, and service fees in a way that suggests only the service fee is taxable for withholding purposes, that presentation may attract BIR scrutiny. The accounting treatment should be aligned with the withholding tax position required by RMC No. 26-2009 and the applicable revenue regulations.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
Businesses engaging manpower agencies or service contractors should immediately review their vendor master files and withholding tax setup. If a manpower vendor is coded for two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax, the accounting team should verify whether the tax is being computed on the full proper gross income base for the service payment, and not merely on a net service fee after excluding salaries or benefits.
Service providers should review invoice templates, contracts, and tax clauses. If the agreement states that withholding tax applies only to the agency fee, management should reassess that clause in light of RMC No. 26-2009. Contract language cannot override the BIR’s position that the basis of withholding tax is gross income without unauthorized qualification.
For ongoing contracts, finance teams should reconcile historical withholding tax practices. The key question is whether the company has been excluding amounts earmarked for salaries and benefits when computing the two percent (2%) creditable withholding tax. If so, management should evaluate whether voluntary correction, contract amendment, supplier discussion, or tax advisory support is necessary.
For new manpower and outsourcing arrangements, the safest practice is to address withholding tax treatment clearly before payments begin. The contract should identify the nature of the services, the invoicing structure, the applicable withholding tax, and the party responsible for tax compliance. However, the tax base should still follow the BIR rules, not a private allocation intended to reduce withholding.
Why RMC No. 26-2009 Still Matters for Manpower and Outsourcing Arrangements
RMC No. 26-2009 remains relevant because the issue continues to arise in service contracts: can a service provider or client exclude pass-through costs, salaries, benefits, or earmarked amounts from the withholding tax base? For manpower services, the BIR’s answer in this circular is no, where the exclusion is unsupported by law or regulations and conflicts with the gross income basis for withholding tax.
This is especially significant for companies with high-volume outsourced labor arrangements. A small error in the withholding tax base can become material when applied across hundreds of workers, monthly invoices, and multiple years of BIR audit exposure. CFOs and corporate accountants should ensure that their expanded withholding tax computations are consistent with the gross income principle emphasized in RMC No. 26-2009.
ASG Law Can Help Review Manpower Service Tax Compliance
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises Philippine businesses, manpower agencies, outsourcing providers, CFOs, and in-house counsel on BIR compliance, withholding tax exposure, contract structuring, tax audit defense, and ruling risk. For companies that rely on manpower service contracts or that have historically computed withholding tax only on a reduced service fee, a legal and tax review can help identify exposure before a BIR audit does.
For assistance with RMC No. 26-2009, creditable withholding tax on services, manpower agency tax compliance, BIR audit readiness, and contract tax clauses, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.