RMC No. 57-2009 stops 2009 BIR assessments against CDA cooperatives based on the old cooperative law and shifts assessments to RA 9520 rules.

CDA-registered cooperatives facing taxable year 2009 assessments gained immediate protection from assessments based on the old cooperative law: revenue officers were directed to stop issuing such assessments and to await the rules implementing Republic Act No. 9520, the Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008. For cooperatives, accountants, and tax managers, the urgent action is to check whether any 2009 BIR assessment was anchored on the old cooperative law and to insist that any future assessment be evaluated under the new Cooperative Code, its IRR, and the BIR-CDA joint issuance on tax-related provisions.

What RMC No. 57-2009 Changed

RMC No. 57-2009 published the full text of the memorandum of Finance Secretary Margarito B. Teves directing the Bureau of Internal Revenue to stop issuing tax assessments for taxable year 2009 against cooperatives registered with the Cooperative Development Authority when those assessments are based on the old cooperative law.

The key change is not a new tax rate, exemption amount, or filing form. The key change is a limitation on the legal basis for cooperative tax assessments for taxable year 2009. BIR offices were told not to proceed with assessments against CDA-registered cooperatives if the basis was the old cooperative law, because the new Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008, Republic Act No. 9520, required implementing rules and a BIR-CDA joint issuance on its tax-related provisions.

This matters because tax assessments are not merely administrative notices. Once issued, they can trigger protest deadlines, collection risk, and financial statement exposure. RMC No. 57-2009 gives cooperatives a concrete basis to question 2009 assessments that relied on an outdated legal framework after the enactment of RA 9520.

Who Is Most Affected

The taxpayers most directly affected are cooperatives registered with the Cooperative Development Authority. These include credit cooperatives, consumer cooperatives, producer cooperatives, service cooperatives, multipurpose cooperatives, and other CDA-registered entities that may have been subject to BIR examination or assessment for taxable year 2009.

The issuance is also important for cooperative accountants, CFOs, in-house counsel, external tax advisers, and officers handling BIR audits. Search phrases such as BIR assessment against cooperatives, CDA registered cooperative tax exemption, RA 9520 tax rules, cooperative tax assessment 2009, and BIR-CDA joint issuance on cooperatives are directly relevant to this compliance issue.

Revenue officers and BIR employees are likewise affected because the instruction is directed to all internal revenue officers, employees, and others concerned. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue enjoined all revenue officials and employees to give the circular wide publicity, underscoring that the directive was meant for implementation across BIR offices.

Key Compliance Requirement and Deadline

The memorandum required the draft Implementing Rules and Regulations and the draft BIR-CDA joint issuance on the tax-related provisions of RA 9520 to be completed within thirty (30) days, or not later than 14 September 2009. The memorandum itself was dated 14 August 2009, while RMC No. 57-2009 was dated 05 October 2009.

The 14 September 2009 date is significant because it marked the deadline set by the Finance Secretary for completing the draft IRR and draft joint issuance. The memorandum further stated that the IRR and BIR-CDA joint issuance had to be immediately subjected to formal consultations with all stakeholders before submission to the Joint Congressional Oversight Committee on Cooperatives.

For affected cooperatives, the compliance point is practical: tax departments should distinguish between an assessment based on the old cooperative law and an assessment based on the new cooperative code, the IRR, and the BIR-CDA joint issuance. RMC No. 57-2009 expressly provides that, after completion of the BIR-CDA joint issuance, BIR officers may issue assessments, but these must be based on the new cooperative code, the IRR, and the BIR-CDA joint issuance on the tax-related provisions of the law.

What the BIR May and May Not Do After RMC No. 57-2009

For taxable year 2009, the BIR was directed to stop issuing tax assessments against CDA-registered cooperatives based on the old cooperative law. This is the central protective rule of the circular. It does not state that cooperatives are immune from all BIR audit or assessment activity. Instead, it limits the legal foundation for assessments after RA 9520.

The BIR may issue assessments after the BIR-CDA joint issuance is completed, but those assessments must be based on the new Cooperative Code, the IRR, and the BIR-CDA joint issuance. This means that a cooperative receiving a 2009 assessment should ask a basic threshold question: what law and issuance did the BIR rely on?

If the assessment cites or applies the old cooperative law despite the directive in RMC No. 57-2009, the cooperative should consider raising that point in its administrative response or protest. If the assessment relies on RA 9520 and its implementing issuances, the cooperative must then review whether the BIR correctly applied the new rules to its registration, transactions, income, exemptions, and documentation.

Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 57-2009 does not prescribe a new penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or compromise amount. It also does not create a new taxpayer filing deadline. Its risk lies in assessment handling: a cooperative that ignores a 2009 assessment may still face the usual consequences of failing to respond within applicable tax protest periods, even if the assessment may be vulnerable because it relied on the old cooperative law.

For cooperatives, the danger is not only whether tax is ultimately due. The immediate danger is procedural. If the cooperative does not timely evaluate, document, and contest an assessment, it may lose administrative remedies. Accountants and officers should therefore not treat RMC No. 57-2009 as a reason to disregard BIR correspondence. It should be used as a legal basis for a focused, timely, and well-documented response.

Practical Steps for Cooperatives and Their Tax Teams

First, confirm CDA registration. RMC No. 57-2009 applies to cooperatives registered with the Cooperative Development Authority. The cooperative should keep its CDA registration documents, certificates, and related filings organized in case the BIR questions its status.

Second, review all taxable year 2009 assessment notices, audit findings, and BIR correspondence. Identify whether the BIR relied on the old cooperative law or on RA 9520, the IRR, and the BIR-CDA joint issuance. The distinction is central to the directive.

Third, preserve the timeline. The memorandum was dated 14 August 2009, required completion of the draft IRR and joint issuance within thirty (30) days or not later than 14 September 2009, and was published under RMC No. 57-2009 dated 05 October 2009. These dates matter when assessing whether the BIR acted before or after the transition to the new Cooperative Code framework.

Fourth, prepare a technical response instead of a generic denial. A cooperative should explain its CDA registration, the taxable year involved, the legal basis cited by the BIR, and why an assessment under the old cooperative law is inconsistent with RMC No. 57-2009. Where needed, the cooperative should also address the substantive tax rules under RA 9520 and the applicable implementing issuances.

Fifth, coordinate legal and accounting review early. Cooperative tax treatment often involves registration status, member transactions, exempt and non-exempt income, withholding obligations, documentation, and audit strategy. A purely accounting response may miss legal arguments, while a purely legal response may fail to reconcile figures and records.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 57-2009 is a reminder that BIR assessments against cooperatives must rest on the correct law and the correct implementing issuances. For CDA-registered cooperatives, the difference between an assessment under the old cooperative law and one under RA 9520 can determine the proper defense strategy, protest theory, and documentation plan.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists cooperatives, business owners, CFOs, and corporate accountants in reviewing BIR assessments, preparing protest letters, evaluating tax exemption issues, and coordinating compliance under Philippine tax and business laws. If your cooperative received a BIR assessment for taxable year 2009 or needs guidance on cooperative tax compliance under RA 9520, consult ASG Law through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *