RMO No. 38-2009 adopts revised BIR grievance rules, setting deadlines, appeal levels, committee duties, and supervisor accountability for inaction.

BIR officials and employees must now follow a revised step-by-step grievance process that requires prompt action at the lowest possible level, protects the complaining employee from coercion or reprisal, and imposes accountability on supervisors who refuse to act. RMO No. 38-2009 adopts the Bureau of Internal Revenue grievance machinery under the Civil Service Commission framework, making internal workplace grievances subject to defined reporting channels, appeal periods, committee action, documentation, and final review by the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office.

What RMO No. 38-2009 Changed

RMO No. 38-2009 adopted revised policies on the settlement of grievance in the Bureau of Internal Revenue. The issuance applies the Revised Policies on the Settlement of Grievance in the Public Sector under CSC Resolution No. 010113 dated January 10, 2001, implemented through CSC Memorandum Circular No. 02, series of 2001, to the BIRโ€™s internal grievance system.

The most important change is the formal adoption of a Bureau-wide grievance machinery that requires grievances to be resolved expeditiously at the lowest possible level. If the grievance is not settled there, the aggrieved party must proceed step by step through the hierarchy of positions, from the immediate supervisor, to the higher supervisor, to the National or Regional Grievance Committee, to the Management Committee, and finally to the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office.

The rule is not a taxpayer assessment, tax filing, withholding tax, VAT, income tax, or documentary stamp tax issuance. It does not impose a new tax rate, return deadline, or taxpayer filing obligation. Its importance lies in BIR governance: it regulates how internal revenue officials and employees must handle work-related dissatisfaction, personnel disputes, and other grievance matters inside the Bureau.

Who Is Affected by RMO No. 38-2009

RMO No. 38-2009 is addressed to all internal revenue officials and employees. Its grievance machinery applies to all levels of officials and employees in the Bureau of Internal Revenue. It may also apply to non-career employees whenever applicable.

The persons most directly affected are BIR employees, supervisors, regional officials, members of the National and Regional Grievance Committees, the Personnel Division, Bilis Aksyon Partners, and the Management Committee. Supervisors are particularly affected because the issuance expressly states that supervisors or officials who refuse to take action on a grievance brought to their attention shall be liable for neglect of duty under existing civil service law, rules, and regulations.

For businesses, CFOs, accountants, and tax practitioners, the issuance matters indirectly. It does not create a taxpayer defense to an assessment and does not change BIR audit procedures. However, companies dealing with BIR offices should understand that RMO No. 38-2009 concerns internal personnel grievances, not taxpayer protests, tax appeals, refund claims, or requests for reconsideration of assessments. Search terms such as BIR grievance procedure, RMO 38-2009 grievance machinery, BIR employee grievance rules, Civil Service Commission grievance BIR, and BIR supervisor neglect of duty are therefore more accurate than searches relating to tax assessment remedies.

Grievances Covered by the Revised BIR Machinery

RMO No. 38-2009 covers work-related discontentment or dissatisfaction that has been expressed verbally or in writing and, in the aggrieved employeeโ€™s opinion, has been ignored or dropped without due consideration.

The grievance machinery covers non-implementation of policies, practices, and procedures on economic and financial issues and other terms and conditions of employment fixed by law. The issuance specifically identifies examples such as salaries, incentives, working hours, leave benefits, delay in the processing of overtime pay, unreasonable withholding of salaries, and inaction on applications for leave.

It also covers non-implementation of policies, practices, and procedures affecting employees from recruitment to promotion, detail, transfer, retirement, termination, lay-offs, and related personnel issues. The issuance gives as examples the failure to observe the selection process in appointments and undue delay in the processing of retirement papers.

RMO No. 38-2009 further includes inadequate physical working conditions, such as lack of proper ventilation and insufficient facilities and equipment necessary for the safety and protection of employees whose work is classified as high risk or hazardous. It also covers poor interpersonal relationships and linkages, such as unreasonable refusal by one employee to give official information to another employee. Protests on appointments and other personnel actions are also included, together with all other matters giving rise to employee dissatisfaction and discontentment outside the listed examples.

Matters Excluded from the BIR Grievance Machinery

RMO No. 38-2009 is specific about matters that should not be handled through the grievance machinery. Disciplinary cases are excluded and must be resolved under the Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases. Sexual harassment cases are likewise excluded and must be handled under Republic Act No. 7877. Union-related issues and concerns are also outside the grievance machinery.

This distinction is important because an employee complaint may appear, at first glance, to involve workplace dissatisfaction but may actually be disciplinary, sexual harassment-related, or union-related. In those situations, the correct procedural track must be used. Misrouting a complaint can delay resolution and expose responsible officials to administrative issues.

Key Deadlines and Step-by-Step Compliance Requirements

The grievance process begins with discussion with the immediate supervisor. At the first instance, the grievance may be presented verbally or in writing using the prescribed form. The supervisor must inform the aggrieved party of the corresponding action within three working days from the date the grievance is presented. If the immediate supervisor is the object of the grievance, the aggrieved party may bring the matter to the next higher supervisor.

If the aggrieved party is not satisfied with the verbal decision, the grievance may be submitted in writing within five days to the next higher supervisor. That higher supervisor must render a decision within five working days from receipt of the grievance.

If the aggrieved party remains dissatisfied, the decision of the next higher supervisor may be elevated to the National or Regional Grievance Committee within five working days from receipt of that decision. A decision of the Regional Grievance Committee may be elevated to the National Grievance Committee.

Upon receipt, the National or Regional Grievance Committee may refer the matter to a mediator or conciliator who may use alternative modes of dispute resolution, including mediation, conciliation, and arbitration. The Committee may also conduct an investigation and hearing within ten working days from receipt of the grievance and render a decision within five working days after the investigation. If the grievance is against the Grievance Committee itself, the aggrieved party may submit it to the Management Committee.

If dissatisfied with the decision of the Grievance Committee, the aggrieved party may elevate the grievance within five working days from receipt of the decision to the Management Committee. The Management Committee must make a decision within ten working days after receipt of the grievance. If the grievance is against the Management Committee, the aggrieved party may bring the grievance directly to the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office.

If the aggrieved party is not satisfied with the decision of top management, the grievance may be appealed to the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office concerned within fifteen working days from receipt of the decision. The appeal must include a Certification on the Final Action on the Grievance, which must contain the history and final action taken by the Bureau on the grievance.

Composition and Duties of the BIR Grievance Committees

The National Grievance Committee is chaired by the Deputy Commissioner of Internal Revenue for the Resource Management Group, with the Assistant Commissioner of Internal Revenue for the Human Resource Development Service as Vice-Chairman. Its members include designated Assistant Commissioners from the Operations Group and Information Systems Group, the Assistant Commissioner of Legal Service, the concerned Assistant Commissioner, two rank-and-file representatives, and the duly designated Bilis Aksyon Partner. The two rank-and-file representatives consist of one member each from the first and second levels, serving for a term of two years.

The Regional Grievance Committee is chaired by the Assistant Regional Director, with the Chief of the Administrative Division as Vice-Chairman. Its members include the Chief of the Legal Division, the Head of the Human Resource Management Unit, two rank-and-file representatives, and the duly designated Bilis Aksyon Partner.

The Committees are required not only to resolve specific grievances but also to establish internal procedures and strategies, conduct continuing information drives, hold dialogues among the parties, document grievances, prepare and sign written agreements reached by the parties, issue the Certification on the Final Action on the Grievance, and submit quarterly reports on accomplishments and unresolved grievances to the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office concerned.

Penalties and Accountability for Non-Compliance

The most specific accountability rule in RMO No. 38-2009 is directed at supervisors and officials who refuse to act. A supervisor or official who refuses to take action on a grievance brought to his or her attention shall be liable for neglect of duty under existing civil service law, rules, and regulations.

The issuance also provides that an aggrieved party must be assured freedom from coercion, discrimination, reprisal, and biased action on the grievance. Grievance proceedings are not bound by legal rules and technicalities. Even verbal grievances must be acted upon expeditiously. The services of legal counsel are not allowed in the grievance proceedings.

Effectivity and Practical Steps

The grievance machinery takes effect immediately upon approval by the Civil Service Commission and repeals any BIR issuances, or provisions thereof, that are inconsistent with it. The Civil Service Commission approval appearing in the issuance is dated November 10, 2009.

For BIR officials and employees, the practical steps are clear. First, identify whether the matter is a grievance covered by RMO No. 38-2009 or whether it belongs to another process, such as disciplinary proceedings, sexual harassment proceedings, or union-related mechanisms. Second, raise the matter at the lowest possible level unless the immediate supervisor is the subject of the grievance. Third, observe the written appeal periods: five days to the higher supervisor, five working days to the National or Regional Grievance Committee, five working days to the Management Committee, and fifteen working days to the Civil Service Commission Field or Regional Office after top management action. Fourth, ensure that the Certification on the Final Action on the Grievance is prepared when the matter is elevated to the Civil Service Commission.

For businesses and tax practitioners searching for RMO No. 38-2009, the practical takeaway is equally important: this is an internal BIR personnel governance issuance, not a taxpayer compliance rule. It should not be confused with taxpayer remedies under the National Internal Revenue Code, assessment protest procedures, administrative claims for refund, or appeals to the Court of Tax Appeals.

ASG Law Guidance on BIR Issuances and Tax Compliance

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco helps businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel distinguish between BIR issuances that create taxpayer obligations and BIR issuances that govern internal administration. That distinction matters when companies are assessing whether a revenue memorandum order affects tax filings, audit strategy, withholding tax compliance, VAT reporting, refund claims, or BIR correspondence.

For guidance on BIR compliance, tax controversy, corporate governance, and regulatory risk, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco, a full-service law firm based in Makati City. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to coordinate with our tax and business law team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *