RMC No. 64-2009 revoked DACODECO’s cooperative tax exemption after profit-oriented non-member construction transactions and confirmed LGU withholding tax treatment.
Cooperatives that expand into profit-oriented business with non-members risk losing their tax-exempt status and becoming subject to regular internal revenue taxes. RMC No. 64-2009 is a warning to cooperatives, LGUs, government contractors, accountants, and withholding agents: a tax exemption certificate will not protect transactions that no longer satisfy the conditions for cooperative tax exemption, especially where the cooperative is effectively operating like a taxable construction, manpower, or materials-supply business.
What Changed Under RMC No. 64-2009
RMC No. 64-2009, dated November 25, 2009, published the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s revocation of the tax exemption status of Davao Contractors Development Cooperative, or DACODECO. The ruling revoked BIR Ruling No. ECCP-063-2008 after the BIR re-studied the facts and determined that the ruling had no factual basis in light of findings from Revenue Region No. 19, Davao City.
The key point is that DACODECO was originally treated as a tax-exempt credit cooperative, but later amended its articles to engage in engineering construction, manpower services, and distribution of construction materials. It then transacted with non-members, including local government units such as the City Government of Davao. The BIR found that these activities were profit-oriented and were similar to the activities of a taxable partnership or corporation engaged in construction.
The tax exemption privilege originally granted on June 25, 2001 under BIR RDA-RR No. 19 Ruling No. 23-01 had already been revoked by the Regional Director through a letter dated August 23, 2007. Despite this prior revocation, DACODECO later requested another tax exemption certificate through a letter dated May 12, 2008 without declaring the previous revocation. BIR Ruling No. ECCP-063-2008 was issued based on the facts represented, but was later revoked by the Commissioner through the June 1, 2009 letter published in RMC No. 64-2009.
Who Is Affected
The most directly affected taxpayers are cooperatives that hold or rely on BIR tax exemption rulings, especially those that have expanded beyond their original cooperative purpose. Credit cooperatives, construction cooperatives, manpower service cooperatives, and cooperatives supplying materials to government or private clients should review whether their actual operations still comply with the conditions of exemption.
Local government units and other government agencies dealing with cooperatives are also affected. RMC No. 64-2009 expressly confirmed that LGUs may be required to withhold taxes on government money payments to DACODECO after revocation of its tax exemption privilege. For accountants and disbursing officers, the practical issue is whether a cooperative payee remains a valid tax-exempt entity or whether government withholding tax must already be imposed.
Corporate accountants, CFOs, tax managers, procurement heads, and in-house counsel should also take note. Search phrases such as RMC No. 64-2009 cooperative tax exemption revoked, DACODECO tax exemption, BIR cooperative exemption non-members, government withholding tax cooperative contractor, and 2% income tax 5% VAT withholding LGU payments are all tied to the same compliance issue: whether a cooperative’s tax-exempt status still applies when it earns revenue from non-member commercial transactions.
Key Facts and Compliance Requirements
The BIR’s findings were specific. DACODECO was originally registered as a credit cooperative, but amended its articles to engage in engineering construction and manpower services and in the distribution of construction materials to LGUs and other non-members. Its total revenues in 2005 alone from construction business reached Php169.5 million.
The BIR considered these construction-related transactions with non-members to be profit-oriented and outside the objectives and purpose of a cooperative. This was a decisive factor in treating the activities as subject to the regular taxes imposed under the Tax Code.
The BIR also noted that DACODECO’s 2005 report to the Cooperative Development Authority showed an original membership of fifteen co-operators, later reflected as twenty-one co-operators and sixty-one associate members listed as contractors. This membership structure, together with business dealings with LGUs and other non-members, supported the BIR’s conclusion that DACODECO had deviated from the essence of cooperativism.
Another important finding was operational. DACODECO’s 2005 financial statement showed that it had no construction equipment and assets. The BIR viewed the use of subcontractors for construction services as indicative of lack of self-reliance, a fact that undermined the cooperative character claimed for tax exemption purposes.
The BIR further found that DACODECO’s financial statements for 2004, 2005, and 2006 disclosed that net surplus, in excess of statutory reserves, was not distributed to members but reverted to a liability account of DACODECO. The revocation letter stated that, to be exempted, at least twenty-five percent (25%) of net income must be returned to members in the form of interest and/or patronage refund.
Deadlines, Effective Dates, and Withholding Consequences
RMC No. 64-2009 is dated November 25, 2009, but the underlying revocation history is important. The tax exemption privilege granted on June 25, 2001 was revoked by the Regional Director through a letter dated August 23, 2007. The Commissioner’s revocation of BIR Ruling No. ECCP-063-2008 was issued through a letter dated June 1, 2009.
The revocation had a direct withholding consequence. The BIR stated that DACODECO shall no longer be exempted from any and all fees imposed under the internal revenue laws and other tax laws. The revocation also served as authority to LGUs to withhold taxes on government money payments to DACODECO at the rate of two percent (2%) income tax and five percent (5%) final value-added tax on gross receipts.
For LGUs and other government payors, the practical compliance point is clear: once the cooperative’s tax exemption is revoked, payments cannot be processed as tax-exempt merely because the payee is a cooperative or previously held a tax exemption ruling. The payor must examine whether the BIR has revoked, limited, or invalidated the cooperative’s exemption and must apply the applicable withholding taxes on government money payments.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 64-2009 does not state a separate special penalty table. However, the practical risk is substantial. Once a cooperative loses its exemption, its income and transactions may be subject to the regular taxes imposed under the Tax Code. Government payors that fail to withhold may also face withholding tax exposure under ordinary BIR rules.
For cooperatives, the greater risk is not merely the loss of exemption going forward. The BIR’s findings may invite further examination of prior taxable years, especially where the cooperative conducted large-scale commercial transactions, dealt with non-members, failed to distribute the required portion of net income to members, or used tax-exempt status in bidding and contracting with government agencies.
RMC No. 64-2009 also shows that incomplete disclosure in requesting a new tax exemption certificate can be fatal. DACODECO requested another tax exemption certificate without declaring the previous revocation. When the BIR later re-studied the matter, it revoked BIR Ruling No. ECCP-063-2008 for lack of factual basis.
Practical Steps for Cooperatives, LGUs, and Business Counterparties
Cooperatives should immediately review whether their current activities match the purpose and limitations under which tax exemption was granted. A cooperative registered as a credit cooperative should be especially careful before entering construction, manpower, supply, distribution, or other commercial activities with non-members. A business expansion that changes the real character of the cooperative may make the exemption vulnerable.
Cooperatives should also examine their dealings with non-members, including LGUs and government agencies. Transactions with non-members are not automatically prohibited in all contexts, but RMC No. 64-2009 makes clear that profit-oriented business with non-members can be used as evidence that the organization no longer serves the objectives and purpose of a cooperative.
Accounting teams should verify surplus distribution practices. The ruling specifically referred to the requirement that at least twenty-five percent (25%) of net income must be returned to members in the form of interest and/or patronage refund. If surpluses are instead retained, reclassified, or booked as liabilities without proper distribution, the tax exemption position becomes exposed.
LGUs and government agencies should not rely solely on the cooperative label. Before treating a cooperative contractor as tax-exempt, they should verify the status of its BIR exemption and confirm that no revocation has been issued. Where exemption has been revoked, the RMC No. 64-2009 treatment points to withholding at two percent (2%) income tax and five percent (5%) final VAT on gross receipts for government money payments to DACODECO.
Private companies dealing with cooperatives should also conduct tax due diligence. If a contractor, manpower supplier, or materials supplier claims cooperative tax exemption, the counterparty should request the current BIR ruling or certificate, review whether the transaction falls within the exempt activity, and determine whether withholding obligations still apply.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 64-2009 is a practical reminder that tax exemption is conditional, fact-based, and vulnerable to revocation when the taxpayer’s actual operations no longer match the basis for exemption. For cooperatives, LGUs, government contractors, and corporate payors, the safest approach is to review the ruling, the transaction, the payee’s current operations, and the withholding treatment before payment or audit.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists cooperatives, government contractors, LGUs, corporate payors, CFOs, and tax teams in reviewing BIR rulings, tax exemption certificates, withholding tax exposure, cooperative compliance, and audit risk. For assistance on cooperative tax exemption, BIR revocation issues, government withholding tax, or tax compliance reviews, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.