RMO No. 38-2010 sets BIR rules for publishing 2009 top individual and corporate income taxpayers by RDO and nationwide, with key filing cutoffs.
High-income taxpayers for taxable year 2009 may have their names and income tax due publicly posted or published by the BIR under RMO No. 38-2010. The order affects individuals and corporations that ranked among the highest income tax payers in their Revenue District Office or nationwide, and it gives businesses, employers, and tax departments a clear reason to check whether 2009 income tax filings and withholding records were accurately reported before publication lists were finalized.
What RMO No. 38-2010 Changed
RMO No. 38-2010 prescribed the BIR policies and guidelines for the posting and publication of the list of top taxpayers for taxable year 2009. The publication program was intended to recognize taxpayers who paid the highest income tax for taxable year 2009 and to present them as examples for other taxpayers to follow.
The most important rule is that the BIR would publish ranked lists of top income taxpayers, both at the Revenue District Office level and nationwide. For each RDO, the BIR would publish the top three hundred individual taxpayers and the top one hundred fifty corporate taxpayers based on income tax for taxable year 2009. Separately, the BIR would publish nationwide lists covering the top two thousand individual taxpayers and the top one thousand corporate taxpayers for the same taxable year.
This matters because the lists were not merely internal BIR monitoring documents. RMO No. 38-2010 expressly allowed posting and publication in the BIR website, newspapers, BIR offices, and other locations prescribed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. For prominent individuals, major employers, and corporations, inclusion in or omission from these lists could create reputational, investor relations, and tax compliance questions.
Who Is Affected by the Top Taxpayer Publication Rules
The issuance directly affects individual taxpayers and corporate taxpayers with high income tax due for taxable year 2009. At the individual level, the ranking may include taxpayers who filed BIR Form 1700, BIR Form 1701, or who were reported through BIR Form 2316. This means employees with significant compensation income, professionals, sole proprietors, and mixed-income earners could be included if their reported income tax due placed them among the highest taxpayers.
Employers are also affected because the RMO required Revenue District Officers to ensure that the list of top individual taxpayers included individuals appearing in the alphalist of employees subject to withholding tax on wages submitted by employers registered in the RDO jurisdiction. For corporate accountants and payroll teams, this makes the accuracy of compensation withholding reports and employee tax certificates especially important.
Corporate taxpayers are affected if their income tax due reported in BIR Form 1702 for taxable year 2009 placed them within the top one hundred fifty corporate taxpayers in their RDO or within the top one thousand corporate taxpayers nationwide. The RMO treated taxable year 2009, for corporate taxpayers, as the fiscal or calendar year period ending on a date falling from June 30, 2009 to June 30, 2010.
How the BIR Determined the Rankings
For individual taxpayers, the income tax used to establish the ranking was the income tax due reported in BIR Form 1700, BIR Form 1701, and BIR Form 2316 for calendar year 2009, filed with the BIR as of April 15, 2010. This filing cutoff is significant because it fixed the records to be used for identifying the top individual taxpayers.
For corporate taxpayers, the income tax used to establish the ranking was the income tax due reported in BIR Form 1702 for taxable year 2009, filed with the BIR as of October 15, 2010. The RMO therefore distinguished between individual and corporate taxpayers not only by tax form but also by the applicable filing cutoff used for preparing the lists.
The RDO-level lists were to contain the names of taxpayers arranged from the highest top taxpayer to the lowest top taxpayer, the amount of income tax due for taxable year 2009, and information on the average tax due from all taxpayers included in the lists. The nationwide lists were to contain the same categories of information.
Key Compliance Dates and Internal BIR Deadlines
RMO No. 38-2010 took effect immediately upon issuance on April 8, 2010. The order then set specific deadlines for BIR offices to prepare, validate, and elevate the taxpayer lists.
Revenue District Officers were required to submit the RDO lists in electronic format to the Information System Operations Service not later than May 15, 2010 for the top individual taxpayers and not later than November 15, 2010 for the top corporate taxpayers.
The Information System Operations Service was required to validate the lists submitted by the RDOs, prepare the nationwide lists of the top two thousand individual taxpayers and top one thousand corporate taxpayers, and compare those nationwide lists with the RDO lists to check correctness. These lists were to be submitted to the Commissioner not later than May 30, 2010 for the top individual taxpayers and not later than November 30, 2010 for the top corporate taxpayers.
Although these are internal BIR processing deadlines, taxpayers should understand their practical effect: the relevant income tax data had to be accurate before the BIR prepared and validated the lists. For businesses and employers, the searchable compliance phrases connected to this issuance include RMO No. 38-2010 top taxpayers, BIR top individual taxpayers 2009, BIR top corporate taxpayers 2009, BIR Form 1702 top taxpayers, and publication of income tax due Philippines.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RMO No. 38-2010 does not impose a new taxpayer penalty, surcharge, interest, or compromise penalty for failure to appear in the top taxpayer list or for being included in the list. Its operative provisions are directed mainly at BIR officers, particularly Revenue District Officers, the Information System Operations Service, and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
However, the absence of a new penalty does not mean the issuance is irrelevant to taxpayers. The publication of names and income tax due may draw attention to inconsistencies between a taxpayer’s public profile, financial statements, payroll records, income tax returns, and withholding tax reports. For corporations, the ranking may raise questions from shareholders, lenders, counterparties, auditors, or tax authorities. For employers, inaccurate employee withholding records may affect the completeness of the individual taxpayer lists.
Practical Steps for Businesses, Employers, and Tax Departments
Corporations that expected to be among the highest income taxpayers for taxable year 2009 should have reviewed their BIR Form 1702 filings, confirmed the reported income tax due, and reconciled the amount against audited financial statements and tax schedules. Where the taxable year ended between June 30, 2009 and June 30, 2010, the company should have treated that year as the taxable year covered by the corporate top taxpayer publication rules.
Employers should have verified the accuracy of the alphalist of employees subject to withholding tax on wages, particularly for highly compensated employees. Since the RMO specifically required the RDO to include individuals listed in employer-submitted alphalists, payroll teams had a practical compliance interest in ensuring that BIR Form 2316 information and withholding tax records were consistent.
Individual taxpayers, including professionals, executives, and business owners, should have checked whether their BIR Form 1700 or BIR Form 1701 filings for calendar year 2009 correctly reflected income tax due as of the April 15, 2010 cutoff. For taxpayers with public profiles, the possibility of publication made accuracy and consistency especially important.
For current tax governance, the lesson remains useful: whenever the BIR announces taxpayer ranking, publication, benchmarking, or disclosure programs, tax departments should immediately identify the tax form, taxable period, data cutoff, ranking basis, publication scope, and validation deadline. Those details determine whether the taxpayer needs to correct records, prepare explanations, or coordinate with the relevant RDO.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 38-2010 shows how BIR issuances can create practical business consequences even when they do not impose a new tax rate or penalty. Public posting of tax information can affect corporate reputation, investor confidence, payroll compliance, and the way tax records are reviewed by regulators and counterparties.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, employers, professionals, and corporate tax teams in reviewing BIR issuances, reconciling tax filings, managing RDO communications, and preparing compliance strategies for income tax, withholding tax, and corporate reporting concerns. For guidance on BIR compliance, taxpayer publication issues, and tax risk management in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.