RMC No. 39-2010 requires RDOs to monitor HMO VAT compliance and confirms that VAT must be computed on gross receipts without medical utilization deductions.
Health Maintenance Organizations must be ready for BIR monitoring of their monthly and quarterly VAT returns beginning with the month or quarter ending June 30, 2010 up to the month or quarter ending December 31, 2010, because RMC No. 39-2010 directs Revenue District Offices to verify whether HMOs are computing VAT on gross receipts without deducting medical utilization costs. For HMOs, CFOs, tax managers, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel, the key compliance point is clear: VAT must be based on gross receipts, not on net amounts after hospital bills, medical and dental fees, laboratory fees, professional fees, or similar utilization expenses.
What RMC No. 39-2010 Changed for HMO VAT Compliance
RMC No. 39-2010 confirms and operationalizes the BIR position that Health Maintenance Organizations are subject to VAT based on gross receipts. The circular does not merely restate a tax theory; it directs all Revenue District Officers to monitor the VAT returns of HMOs under their jurisdiction to determine whether those HMOs are paying VAT using the gross receipts basis required by the BIR.
The most important rule is that the taxable base of HMOs for VAT purposes is gross receipts without any deduction for medical utilization. The circular specifically refers to medical and dental fees, hospital bills, laboratory fees, professional fees, and similar charges as items that may not be deducted from gross receipts when determining the VAT base. This matters because many HMOs may have historically treated utilization costs as pass-through amounts or deductions before computing VAT. RMC No. 39-2010 rejects that approach.
The circular relies on the tax treatment clarified under Revenue Regulations No. 16-2005, as amended. Under that regulation, an HMO’s gross receipts refer to the total amount of money or its equivalent representing the service fee actually or constructively received during the taxable period for services performed or to be performed for another person, excluding VAT. For HMOs, the compensation for services, representing the service fee, is presumed to be the total amount received as enrollment from members plus other charges received.
Why the BIR Focused on Health Maintenance Organizations
RMC No. 39-2010 was issued after earlier BIR rulings favorable to certain HMOs were revoked. RMC No. 2-2009 revoked BIR Ruling No. DA (VAT-054) 529-2008 issued in favor of MEDICard Philippines, Inc. RMC No. 6-2009 likewise revoked BIR Rulings Nos. DA (VAT-019) 121 issued in favor of Health Maintenance, Inc., DA (C-032) 122-2008 issued in favor of Asalus Corporation, and DA (VAT-026) 375-2008 issued in favor of Maxicare Health Corporation.
The Department of Finance, through its Legal and Revenue Operations Group, also upheld the revocation of BIR Ruling No. DA (C-032) 122-2008 in its January 12, 2010 letter to Asalus Corporation. In practical terms, the BIR and DOF position was that HMOs could no longer rely on those revoked rulings to compute VAT on a basis other than gross receipts.
The circular expressly notes that a large number of HMOs continued not to comply with BIR rules and continued computing VAT based on a method different from gross receipts without deductions. This is why the BIR moved from clarification to monitoring. For searches such as HMO VAT gross receipts Philippines, VAT on HMO enrollment fees, BIR VAT monitoring HMO, and medical utilization deduction VAT, RMC No. 39-2010 is the key issuance.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 39-2010
The direct targets are Health Maintenance Organizations registered with Revenue District Offices. These include HMOs receiving enrollment fees from members, corporate clients, or other covered persons, and HMOs receiving other charges in connection with healthcare coverage arrangements.
The affected business functions are not limited to tax departments. CFOs, controllers, accounting heads, billing teams, compliance officers, and in-house counsel must ensure that the VAT treatment of HMO receipts matches the BIR’s gross receipts position. Corporate clients dealing with HMOs may also need to understand this rule because VAT treatment can affect billing, contract pricing, tax clauses, and invoice review.
For HMOs, the risk area is any VAT computation that deducts utilization costs before computing VAT. The circular identifies utilization costs broadly, including medical and dental fees, hospital bills, laboratory fees, professional fees, and similar items. A conservative compliance review should therefore examine all accounts where the HMO treats medical utilization as a deduction, offset, pass-through, reimbursement, or exclusion from the VAT base.
Key Monitoring Periods and Deadlines
The monitoring ordered by RMC No. 39-2010 applies to VAT returns filed beginning with the month or quarter ending June 30, 2010 and terminating with VAT returns filed for the month or quarter ending December 31, 2010. This gives the BIR a defined monitoring window covering the second half of 2010, while expressly preserving the BIR’s authority to verify prior years’ VAT returns.
The circular states that this monitoring is without prejudice to the BIR’s power to verify prior years’ VAT returns and impose VAT based on the gross receipts of HMOs. This language is important because the monitoring period does not mean that exposure is limited only to June 30, 2010 through December 31, 2010. HMOs with prior VAT computations using net-of-utilization methods may still face review for earlier taxable periods, subject to applicable assessment rules.
Revenue District Officers are required to submit monthly reports on the activities conducted to the Task Force on HMOs created under Revenue Special Order Nos. 186-2010 and 231-2010. The first report for June 2010 activities must be submitted on or before July 30, 2010. The last report for December 2010 activities must be submitted on or before January 28, 2011. These dates show that the BIR intended systematic monthly tracking, not a one-time review.
How the Verification Will Be Conducted
RMC No. 39-2010 authorizes Revenue District Officers to conduct verification of VAT returns without the need to issue Letters of Authority or Tax Verification Notices. This is a major procedural detail. The initial monitoring and verification of VAT returns may proceed at the RDO level without the formal issuance of an LOA or TVN.
However, the RDOs’ authority is limited. If an RDO ascertains that an HMO is not complying with the rule requiring VAT payment based on gross receipts, the RDO is authorized only to issue a reminder notice. Any further action, including issuance of an LOA, issuance of a TVN, or issuance of Assessment Notices against HMOs verified to have incorrectly complied with VAT obligations, must be referred to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue for approval.
This means HMOs should treat a reminder notice seriously. While the reminder notice itself may not be an assessment, it can signal that the RDO has identified a discrepancy in the HMO’s VAT computation. Affected taxpayers should promptly review the computation, reconcile returns with books and invoices, and prepare a legal and factual position before the matter escalates to formal audit or assessment.
Penalties and Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 39-2010 does not create a new penalty rate or a special surcharge. It does, however, direct verification and preserves the BIR’s authority to impose VAT based on gross receipts. The exposure therefore comes from deficiency VAT if the HMO computed VAT on a reduced base, particularly where medical utilization costs were deducted before computing output VAT.
Because the circular refers to possible issuance of LOA, TVN, or Assessment Notices with the Commissioner’s approval, non-compliant HMOs may face formal tax assessment proceedings. Depending on the results of audit and the applicable rules at the time, exposure may include deficiency VAT and statutory additions imposed under the Tax Code. The practical concern is not only the tax amount for the monitored periods, but also whether the BIR will review prior years where the same computation method was used.
Practical Steps for HMOs and Their Tax Teams
HMOs should immediately confirm whether VAT returns for the covered periods were prepared on gross receipts without deductions for medical utilization. The review should cover VAT returns, general ledger accounts, enrollment fee records, billing summaries, invoices, official receipts, contracts with members or corporate accounts, and any schedules showing deductions for hospital bills, laboratory fees, professional fees, medical and dental fees, or related costs.
Tax teams should map all HMO revenue streams and determine whether the amounts received as enrollment from members plus other charges received were included in the VAT base, excluding only VAT itself. If any internal policy treats utilization expenses as deductions from the VAT base, that policy should be reviewed against RMC No. 39-2010 and RR No. 16-2005, as amended.
Accounting teams should also prepare for RDO verification. Since the RDO may conduct verification without an LOA or TVN, HMOs should maintain organized VAT working papers showing how gross receipts were computed. If a reminder notice is received, management should avoid informal or inconsistent responses. A coordinated tax, accounting, and legal review is advisable before submitting explanations or amended computations.
For corporate clients and business owners searching for RMC 39-2010 HMO VAT, VAT compliance of Health Maintenance Organizations, BIR gross receipts HMO VAT, and medical utilization VAT deduction Philippines, the core lesson is that the BIR expects HMO VAT to be computed on gross receipts. The BIR’s monitoring instruction makes this a compliance and audit-readiness issue, not merely a technical interpretation.
ASG Law Can Assist with HMO VAT Compliance and BIR Verification
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, tax teams, healthcare-related companies, and regulated enterprises on BIR compliance, VAT exposure, tax assessments, and preventive documentation. For HMOs and companies dealing with HMO billing and VAT issues, the firm can assist in reviewing VAT computations, preparing responses to BIR notices, assessing exposure from prior-year filings, and building a defensible compliance file before a matter becomes a formal assessment.
For assistance with RMC No. 39-2010, HMO VAT compliance, gross receipts taxation, BIR verification, or tax assessment defense, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.