RR No. 9-2010 allowed temporary BIR abatement of surcharges and compromise penalties for voluntary filing, amendment, and payment by October 29, 2010.

Taxpayers who had unfiled returns, underdeclared taxes, or returns needing upward correction had only until October 29, 2010 to voluntarily file, amend, and pay the correct tax with interest while avoiding certain BIR surcharges and compromise penalties. RR No. 9-2010 created a limited abatement window for taxpayers who wanted to come forward before receiving an audit notice or becoming the subject of a criminal tax case. For businesses, CFOs, accountants, and withholding agents, the practical consequence was clear: voluntary correction before BIR enforcement could reduce exposure to add-on penalties, but only if the taxpayer strictly complied with the filing, payment, and documentation requirements.

What RR No. 9-2010 changed

RR No. 9-2010 provided policies and guidelines for the abatement of surcharges and/or compromise penalties in relation to the filing of tax returns and payment of taxes under certain conditions. The regulation was issued in the context of the BIR and Department of Finance Run After Tax Evaders, or RATE, Program, which was designed to investigate and prosecute individuals and entities engaged in tax evasion and other criminal violations of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended.

The regulation recognized that some taxpayers were willing to voluntarily file and pay taxes, or rectify returns previously filed, but requested relief from the corresponding surcharges and/or compromise penalties. RR No. 9-2010 therefore allowed a temporary abatement privilege from the effectivity of the regulations until October 29, 2010, subject to strict conditions.

For original tax returns, taxpayers who failed to file returns and/or failed to pay the correct taxes due could file the required returns and pay the deficiency taxes, inclusive of interest. If all conditions were met, no surcharges under Section 248 of the Tax Code and no compromise penalty under RMO No. 19-2007 would be imposed.

For amended tax returns, taxpayers who wanted to rectify their previously filed returns and pay the correct taxes due could file amended returns and pay the deficiency taxes, inclusive of interest on the upward adjustments. If all conditions were met, no compromise penalty under RMO No. 19-2007 would be imposed.

Who was affected by RR No. 9-2010

RR No. 9-2010 affected taxpayers with unfiled tax returns, unpaid or underpaid taxes, or previously filed returns requiring amendment that would result in additional tax payments. This included corporations, SMEs, individual taxpayers engaged in business, withholding agents, importers whose tax liabilities related to importation, and taxpayers registered with Revenue District Offices, Large Taxpayers District Offices, or Large Taxpayers Divisions.

The regulation was particularly important for business owners and corporate accountants conducting internal tax reviews. A taxpayer who discovered unreported gross sales, understated revenues or receipts, excessive deductions, overstated tax credits, or unpaid tax liabilities had a limited opportunity to correct the issue before a BIR audit or enforcement action removed the taxpayer from the abatement privilege.

However, RR No. 9-2010 was not available to every taxpayer. The relief was not available if the taxpayer had already been served a Letter of Authority, Tax Verification Notice, Audit Notice, Letter Notice, or discrepancy notice for the relevant tax period. It was also unavailable if the tax type involved was the subject of a pending criminal case for tax evasion or other criminal offenses under the Tax Code, whether filed in court or with the Department of Justice, or if the matter was already covered by a final and executory court judgment.

Deadline and key compliance requirements

The central deadline under RR No. 9-2010 was October 29, 2010. For original tax returns, the return had to be filed and full payment of the tax, inclusive of interest due, had to be received by the BIR not later than October 29, 2010. For amended returns, the amended return had to be filed and the full deficiency tax, inclusive of interest due, also had to be received by the BIR not later than October 29, 2010.

Original returns covered by the abatement privilege required the taxpayer to file the return, pay the full tax and interest, and execute a Declaration of Availment of Abatement. The taxpayer also had to attach a photocopy of the return filed, together with the attachments required under relevant revenue issuances, and proof of payment of taxes.

Amended returns had additional requirements. The amendment had to involve an upward adjustment of gross sales, revenues, or receipts; a downward adjustment of deductions from gross revenue or receipts; a reduction in tax credits; or upward adjustments involving both gross sales, revenues, receipts, and deductions, provided that the adjustment resulted in additional tax payment. The taxpayer also had to execute a Declaration of Availment of Abatement and attach the original return and proof of payment, the amended return and its required attachments, and proof of payment for the amended return.

For amended returns arising from or relating to importation, the taxpayer also had to attach proof of previous payments of duties and taxes paid to the Bureau of Customs. For original or amended returns involving importation-related taxes, the taxpayer was required to file the return or amended return and pay the tax to the BIR.

Where and how taxpayers had to file

Original and amended returns had to be filed with, and the corresponding tax paid to, an Authorized Agent Bank or Revenue Collection Officer within the revenue district where the taxpayer was registered or required to register. Taxpayers enrolled in eFPS were required to follow the specific eFPS regulations applicable to them.

The Declaration of Availment of Abatement had to be accomplished in three copies and filed on a per tax type and per taxable period basis. The original and duplicate copies were for the BIR, while the triplicate copy was for the taxpayer. After paying the tax and interest, the taxpayer had to submit the Declaration and all required attachments to the Revenue District Office, Large Taxpayers District Office, or Large Taxpayers Division where the taxpayer was registered or required to register.

The regulation also required BIR Officers-of-the-Day to receive and preliminarily evaluate the Declaration, returns, amended returns, and attachments. Their review included checking mathematical computations and determining the sufficiency of documentary requirements. If there was a deficiency tax or insufficient documentation, the taxpayer had to be notified in writing and required to make additional payment or submit missing documents within forty-eight hours from receipt of the notification. Failure to comply within that forty-eight-hour period meant that the taxpayer would be presumed not to have opted to avail of the privileges under RR No. 9-2010.

Processing time and deemed approval

RR No. 9-2010 imposed processing timelines within the BIR. The evaluating and processing Officers-of-the-Day, as well as the reviewing Revenue District Officers, LTDOs, or LT Division Chiefs, were required to act on the Declaration within two days from receipt. The RDOs, LTDOs, or LT Division Chiefs were required to endorse complete Declarations and attachments to the Office of the Commissioner not later than five working days from receipt from the taxpayer.

The Technical Working Committee and the Office of the Commissioner had thirty days to act on the Declaration. If the matter was not acted upon within thirty days, the abatement was deemed duly approved. For estate tax, donor’s tax, and capital gains tax returns, the Certificate Authorizing Registration would be issued only after approval of the Declaration by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

Penalties and limitations taxpayers had to watch

The primary benefit of RR No. 9-2010 was relief from specified add-on penalties, but only for compliant taxpayers. For original returns, the regulation allowed non-imposition of surcharges under Section 248 of the Tax Code and compromise penalties under RMO No. 19-2007. For amended returns, the regulation allowed non-imposition of compromise penalties under RMO No. 19-2007.

The regulation did not grant immunity from audit. Filing an original or amended return and paying deficiency taxes under RR No. 9-2010 presupposed full and accurate disclosure by the taxpayer. The BIR expressly retained the authority to investigate the correctness of the returns, the sufficiency of attachments, and to prosecute criminal violations in appropriate cases under the Tax Code.

This limitation mattered because RR No. 9-2010 was a compliance relief measure, not a tax amnesty. It did not erase the obligation to pay the correct tax and interest. It did not protect taxpayers who had already received audit or discrepancy notices for the relevant period. It did not cover pending criminal tax cases or matters already finally decided by the courts. It also did not prevent the BIR from examining whether the taxpayer’s disclosure was truthful and complete.

Practical steps for taxpayers and businesses

For taxpayers reviewing RR No. 9-2010, the compliance lesson remains useful: voluntary correction is most effective before enforcement begins. Businesses should maintain a process for periodic tax return review, especially for gross sales, receipts, revenue recognition, deductible expenses, input tax or tax credit claims, withholding tax compliance, and importation-related tax payments.

During an abatement window, the taxpayer should identify the tax type and taxable period, compute the basic tax and interest, confirm that no Letter of Authority, Tax Verification Notice, Audit Notice, Letter Notice, or discrepancy notice has been served for that period, verify that the matter is not the subject of a pending criminal tax case or final judgment, prepare the original or amended return, pay the tax and interest, and submit the required Declaration of Availment of Abatement with all attachments.

For corporate taxpayers, the CFO or accounting head should also preserve proof of payment, copies of original and amended returns, importation documents where applicable, and BIR receiving copies. Because the Declaration was required on a per tax type and per taxable period basis, taxpayers needed to avoid lumping different liabilities together in a way that could cause processing issues.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco can help

RR No. 9-2010 is a reminder that BIR compliance is not just about filing returns on time. It also requires identifying historical tax exposure, determining whether voluntary correction is still available, preparing accurate computations, and submitting complete documentation before the BIR begins enforcement action.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing tax compliance exposure, responding to BIR assessments, preparing voluntary disclosures, handling deficiency tax issues, and structuring documentation for audits and regulatory filings. For assistance with BIR compliance, tax assessments, compromise penalties, surcharge exposure, and business tax risk management, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *