Mass leave during a pending labor dispute may be an illegal strike, but rank-and-file workers cannot be dismissed without proof of specific illegal acts.
A concerted mass leave or protest can legally become an illegal strike when it paralyzes business operations during a pending labor dispute already assumed by the Secretary of Labor, but employers still cannot dismiss rank-and-file union members by group accusation alone. The Court drew a sharp line: union officers who knowingly join an illegal strike may lose their employment, while ordinary members may be dismissed only if the employer proves their specific illegal acts during the strike.
Why This Ruling Matters to Employers, Unions, and Rank-and-File Employees
The decision is important because it rejects two extremes. On one hand, employees cannot avoid labor-law consequences simply by calling a strike a mass leave, protest rally, boycott, or exercise of free expression. If the real-world effect is a concerted work stoppage arising from a labor dispute, the law looks at substance, not labels.
On the other hand, employers cannot treat every participant in an illegal strike as automatically dismissible. The Labor Code distinguishes between union officers and ordinary union members. That distinction can determine whether dismissal is valid, whether reinstatement is proper, whether separation pay may be awarded, and whether backwages should be denied.
Background: A CBA Deadlock, a Labor Secretary Assumption Order, and a Three-Day Work Boycott
Solidbank and its employeesâ union were renegotiating the economic provisions of their collective bargaining agreement when negotiations broke down. The union declared a deadlock and filed a notice of strike. Because an actual strike appeared imminent, the Secretary of Labor assumed jurisdiction over the dispute and directed the parties to refrain from acts that could worsen the situation.
After the Secretary resolved the economic and non-economic issues, union officers and members protested the ruling. Employees joined a mass leave and protest action at the Department of Labor and Employment, while other branches followed with a boycott of regular work. The employees also picketed bank premises. Solidbankâs operations were paralyzed. The dispute later reached the Supreme Court in Solidbank Corporation v. Gamier and related parties (G.R. No. 159460 and 159461, November 15, 2010).
The Courtâs Core Doctrine: Substance Controls Over the Label Used by the Workers
The Court held that the employeesâ concerted actions constituted a strike. A strike under the Labor Code is not limited to a formal declaration or a picket line called by that name. It includes temporary stoppages of work by concerted employee action arising from a labor dispute, including mass leaves and similar activities.
This was the decisive point. The employeesâ protest was not viewed in isolation as a mere rally before a government office. The Court considered the full factual context: a bargaining deadlock, a pending labor dispute, a prior assumption of jurisdiction by the Secretary of Labor, a concerted absence from work, picketing, and paralysis of the bankâs operations. Because the mass action arose from the labor dispute and operated as a work stoppage, it fell within the legal concept of a strike.
Why the Strike Was Illegal
The Court emphasized that the right to strike is constitutionally recognized, but it is not absolute. Once the Secretary of Labor assumes jurisdiction over a labor dispute, the coercive processes of strike or lockout must yield to compulsory dispute resolution. A strike conducted after an assumption order, or while proceedings involving the same grounds remain pending, is a prohibited activity.
The timing mattered. When the employees conducted their mass actions, proceedings before the Secretary of Labor were still pending because motions for reconsideration had been filed. The Court therefore concluded that the employees knowingly held a strike in the guise of a protest action and work boycott while the labor dispute remained under the Secretaryâs jurisdiction.
Why Not All Employees Could Be Dismissed
The ruling becomes most useful for practical legal advice in its treatment of individual liability. The Court did not allow Solidbank to dismiss all participants in the same way. Under the Labor Code, a union officer who knowingly participates in an illegal strike may be declared to have lost employment status. A rank-and-file worker, however, is treated differently. Mere participation in an illegal strike is not enough to justify dismissal of an ordinary union member.
For rank-and-file members, the employer must prove that the individual employee committed specific illegal acts during the strike. These may include violence, coercion, intimidation, obstruction of ingress or egress, abusive or threatening conduct, or similar unlawful acts. The employee must be identified, and liability must be determined individually. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is not required in a labor case, but substantial evidence is necessary.
Solidbank failed on that point as to ordinary union members. The bank relied mainly on their admitted participation in the mass actions. The Court held that this was insufficient. Without proof that each rank-and-file respondent committed a specific illegal act, their dismissal could not be justified.
No Backwages, But Separation Pay in Lieu of Reinstatement
The Court also crafted a middle remedy. Because the strike itself was illegal, the ordinary union members whose dismissal was unjustified were not awarded backwages. The Court applied the principle of a fair dayâs wage for a fair dayâs labor. Since the employees participated in an illegal strike, backwages were not proper.
Ordinarily, unjustified dismissal of rank-and-file members who did not commit illegal acts could result in reinstatement without backwages. But reinstatement was no longer realistic because substantial time had passed and Solidbank had ceased its banking operations. The Court therefore ordered separation pay equivalent to one month salary for every year of service, in lieu of reinstatement, for the union members entitled to relief. Amounts already received under valid quitclaims were to be deducted.
Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable
The Court also addressed a point important to company directors, officers, and investors: corporate officers are not personally liable for employee monetary awards merely because they acted for the employer. Corporate personality remains separate. Personal or solidary liability of officers requires proof of malice, bad faith, gross negligence, or a basis under corporate law to disregard separate juridical personality.
Bad faith is not presumed. It requires more than a wrong decision, bad judgment, or negligence. It involves dishonest purpose, moral obliquity, conscious wrongdoing, or breach of a known duty motivated by interest or ill will. Because the employees failed to prove that the bank officers acted with malice or bad faith, the officers were not held personally liable for the separation pay.
Practical Lessons for Employers
For employers, the ruling confirms that a coordinated work boycott during a pending labor dispute can be treated as a strike even when employees describe it as a protest, rally, or mass leave. But employers must still build an individual evidence record before terminating rank-and-file employees. Photographs, incident reports, affidavits, security logs, police reports, notices, explanations, and specific identification of illegal acts matter.
The most dangerous mistake is assuming that illegality of the strike automatically validates dismissal of every participant. That is not the rule. Union officers and rank-and-file members face different legal standards. Employers who ignore that distinction risk losing the dismissal case, even if they successfully prove that the strike itself was illegal.
Practical Lessons for Employees and Unions
For employees and unions, the ruling is a warning that work stoppages cannot be insulated from labor law by changing the label. When a labor dispute is pending before the Secretary of Labor, especially after an assumption order, a mass leave or boycott can expose union officers to loss of employment.
At the same time, ordinary union members retain protection from collective punishment. If they did not commit violence, coercion, intimidation, obstruction, or other illegal acts, their mere participation in an illegal strike does not automatically justify dismissal. Their remedy, however, may be limited. If the strike was illegal, backwages may be denied even when dismissal is found unjustified.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Labor disputes involving strikes, mass leaves, union discipline, termination notices, and corporate officer liability require careful strategy before positions harden into litigation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, HR teams, management committees, employees, and business owners on strike legality, disciplinary proceedings, NLRC litigation, corporate liability exposure, and settlement options.
For representation in labor litigation, employee dismissal disputes, union-related conflicts, or corporate risk assessment arising from workplace actions, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.