RMC No. 91-2010 clarifies when minimum wage earners remain income-tax exempt after wage hikes, commissions, multiple jobs, transfers, or promotions.
Employers must immediately review whether workers remain minimum wage earners after a statutory wage increase, because RMC No. 91-2010 clarifies that the income tax exemption under RA No. 9504 can apply only for the periods when the employee’s basic daily wage does not exceed the applicable statutory minimum wage and the employee earns no disqualifying income. For payroll teams, the key action is to reassess withholding tax, year-end adjustment, and BIR Form 2316 treatment whenever wages increase, an employee earns commission or allowance, works for more than one employer, transfers regions, or moves above the minimum wage.
What RMC No. 91-2010 Changed for Minimum Wage Earner Tax Exemption
RMC No. 91-2010 provides question-and-answer guidance on the income tax exemption of minimum wage earners under Republic Act No. 9504, as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 10-2008. The ruling was issued because several Regional Wages and Productivity Boards approved increases in the statutory minimum wage in 2010, creating practical payroll issues for employers and employees.
The most important clarification is that minimum wage earner status is not determined once for the entire year. It may change depending on the applicable statutory minimum wage, the employee’s actual wage rate, the employee’s region of assignment, and whether the employee receives income other than the statutory minimum wage, holiday pay, overtime pay, hazard pay, and night shift differential pay.
For Metro Manila, the circular discusses Wage Order No. NCR-15, effective July 1, 2010, which increased the statutory minimum wage from P383 per day to P404 per day, or an increase of P22 per day. The example shows that an employee previously earning P400 per day from January 1, 2010 to June 30, 2010 was above the old statutory minimum wage and was therefore not treated as a minimum wage earner for that period. If, beginning July 1, 2010, the employer increased her wage only to the mandated minimum wage of P404 per day, her compensation from July to December would not be subject to income tax, provided she earned purely compensation income from one employer.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 91-2010
This issuance primarily affects employers, payroll officers, accountants, HR managers, and employees who are paid at or near the statutory minimum wage. It is especially relevant to businesses in Metro Manila and other regions where wage orders changed the statutory minimum wage during the year.
SMEs with rank-and-file employees paid daily wages are directly affected because payroll withholding must follow the statutory minimum wage applicable to the worker’s region and period of work. Large corporations are also affected because year-end adjustment and BIR Form 2316 preparation must correctly separate exempt minimum wage periods from taxable compensation periods.
The circular is also important for employees who have multiple employers, side businesses, commissions, fixed allowances, or promotions. A worker who is paid the statutory minimum wage by two employers may still cease to be a minimum wage earner for tax purposes if the total daily wage from both employers exceeds the prevailing minimum wage. A minimum wage worker who also earns business income from a sari-sari store, or who receives commissions or fixed monthly transportation allowance from the employer, may lose the exemption and become taxable on the entire income received or earned.
Key Compliance Rules and Deadlines for Employers
The first payroll rule is that if the employee’s wage is above the applicable statutory minimum wage, the employer must withhold income tax, subject to the employee’s personal and additional exemptions. In the circular’s example, if an employee earning P400 per day was increased by the P22 statutory wage increase and therefore became paid P422 per day, the employer must withhold income tax because P422 per day is above the new P404 per day statutory minimum wage.
The second rule is that where an employee becomes a minimum wage earner only for part of the year, only the taxable portion should be subjected to income tax. In the example where the employee earned P400 per day from January to June 2010 but P404 per day from July to December 2010, only the January-to-June salary is taxable if it exceeds personal and additional exemptions. The July-to-December compensation, including overtime pay and 13th month pay, is not subjected to income tax because the worker’s basic daily wage does not exceed the statutory minimum wage and she earns purely compensation income from one employer.
The third rule is that additional income may destroy the minimum wage earner exemption. A minimum wage earner who receives income other than statutory minimum wage, holiday pay, overtime pay, hazard pay, and night shift differential pay ceases to be a minimum wage earner. RMC No. 91-2010 specifically treats commission as disqualifying income. It also treats fixed monthly transportation allowance as disqualifying income when received together with commission. Once disqualified, the entire payments made by the employer, including the statutory minimum wage, are subject to withholding tax.
The fourth rule concerns multiple employers. If an employee has two employers and both pay the statutory minimum wage, the employers are required to withhold tax if the total daily wage from both employers exceeds the prevailing minimum wage. For withholding computation, the main employer considers the actual personal exemption of P50,000 and additional exemption of P25,000 for each qualified dependent child, not exceeding four children, if applicable. The other employer does not consider any personal or additional exemption.
The circular also requires both employers to make the employee accomplish BIR Form 1902, Application for Registration, within ten days from date of employment. If the form discloses other employment, the employer must require the employee to submit a photocopy of the filed BIR Form 1902 to the other employer.
Promotions, Transfers, and Year-End Adjustment
RMC No. 91-2010 clarifies that a minimum wage earner promoted later in the year, such as in December, does not automatically become taxable for the entire year. The employee remains exempt for the period when the salary did not exceed the statutory minimum wage. The employee is taxable only for the month when the salary exceeds the minimum wage, if the salary exceeds the employee’s personal and additional exemptions.
If the employer already completed the year-end adjustment before the promotion became effective, the employer should amend the year-end adjustment to reflect the salary change. This is a critical payroll compliance point because the annualization process must match the worker’s actual taxable and exempt periods.
Regional transfers also matter. The circular gives an example of a Philippine National Police employee assigned in NCR from January 1, 2010 to April 30, 2010 at P382 per day, then transferred to Laguna on May 1, 2010 with the same rate. The salary in Laguna was subject to withholding tax because P382 per day was above the prevailing minimum wage in that region. However, only the income earned from the PNP-Laguna assignment is taxable; the earlier income remains exempt if the employee was a minimum wage earner during that period.
Other Income Beyond the Employer’s Control
Employers are not required to withhold tax on income outside their control merely because they know that the employee has other income. RMC No. 91-2010 states that the law requires employers to withhold the corresponding income tax only from income payments over which they have control. However, the employee must file an Income Tax Return reflecting income from all sources, including employment, business, or practice of profession, and pay the tax due, if any.
This distinction is important for business owners and payroll teams. If the disqualifying income is paid by the same employer, such as commission or fixed transportation allowance, the employer must treat the employee as no longer enjoying the minimum wage earner income tax exemption. If the other income is outside the employer’s payment system, the employee has the filing obligation.
Penalties and Compliance Risks
RMC No. 91-2010 does not prescribe a new standalone penalty for these minimum wage earner classifications. Its practical compliance risk is incorrect withholding, incorrect year-end adjustment, and incorrect BIR Form 2316 reporting. Employers that treated taxable compensation as exempt may need to correct payroll withholding. Employers that over-remitted taxes because of the implementation of RA No. 9504 may apply the over-remitted taxes as payments in the immediately succeeding months’ remittable withheld taxes pursuant to Section 79(C)(1) of the Tax Code.
The circular’s examples show that employers must be careful when issuing BIR Form 2316. If the employee ceased to be a minimum wage earner because she received commission, BIR Form 2316 should reflect taxable income inclusive of minimum wage received, because RR No. 10-2008 provides that the employee shall be taxed on the entire income received or earned once the disqualifying income is present.
Practical Steps for Employers, Accountants, and CFOs
Employers should first map every employee’s daily wage against the statutory minimum wage applicable to the employee’s region and period of work. For 2010 NCR payroll affected by Wage Order No. NCR-15, the key figures are the move from P383 per day to P404 per day effective July 1, 2010.
Second, employers should flag employees receiving commissions, fixed allowances, business-related income, or income from multiple employers. For tax exemption purposes, the relevant search terms for payroll teams are minimum wage earner income tax exemption Philippines, RA 9504 minimum wage earner withholding tax, RMC 91-2010 BIR Form 2316, statutory minimum wage tax exemption, and minimum wage earner commission taxable.
Third, employers should confirm whether the worker earns purely compensation income from one employer. If not, the exemption may not apply or may require withholding coordination, depending on whether the income is paid by the employer or outside the employer’s control.
Fourth, employers should revisit year-end adjustment when employees are promoted, transferred to another region, or reclassified because of wage orders. Where an employee was exempt for part of the year and taxable for another part, only the taxable period should be subjected to income tax, consistent with the examples in RMC No. 91-2010.
Finally, HR and accounting teams should ensure timely BIR Form 1902 compliance for employees with multiple employment. The circular specifically refers to completion of BIR Form 1902 within ten days from employment and coordination with the other employer when multiple employment is disclosed.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 91-2010 remains useful for employers dealing with wage orders, minimum wage earner classification, payroll withholding, BIR Form 2316 preparation, and annualization issues. The key business risk is not merely whether a worker is paid at minimum wage, but whether the worker receives other income, works in another region, has multiple employers, or becomes taxable for only part of the year.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists employers, SMEs, corporations, CFOs, accountants, and HR teams in reviewing payroll tax treatment, withholding tax compliance, BIR reporting, employee documentation, and tax exposure arising from wage and compensation structures. For assistance with minimum wage earner tax exemption, payroll withholding, BIR Form 2316, or broader BIR compliance issues, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.