RMO No. 88-2010 sets BIR Subpoena Duces Tecum procedures, a 14-day compliance period, and Php10,000 penalty risk for delayed compliance.

Taxpayers under BIR audit must treat a Subpoena Duces Tecum as a time-sensitive legal command, not an ordinary document request. RMO No. 88-2010 sets a formal procedure for the issuance, service, enforcement, and prosecution of cases involving failure to submit books of accounts and accounting records required by the BIR. The most urgent compliance point is that the compliance date for submission of the required books and records is set on the fourteenth day from the date of issuance of the Subpoena Duces Tecum, and delayed compliance may still expose the taxpayer or responsible officer to a Php10,000.00 penalty under Section 266 of the National Internal Revenue Code.

What RMO No. 88-2010 Changed

RMO No. 88-2010 prescribed the guidelines and procedures for the issuance and enforcement of a Subpoena Duces Tecum, or SDT, and for the prosecution of cases for failure to obey summons. The issuance is grounded on the BIRโ€™s authority to examine and inspect books of accounts and other accounting records, and to conduct investigations relating to internal revenue tax liabilities of taxpayers under Section 5(c) of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997.

The order matters because it converts what may appear to be an audit follow-up into a structured legal process with criminal consequences. When a taxpayer or responsible officer fails to comply with an SDT, the BIR may file a criminal case for violation of Section 5, in relation to Sections 14 and 266 of the NIRC. Since the case is criminal in nature, conviction requires proof beyond reasonable doubt. RMO No. 88-2010 therefore requires strict compliance by revenue officials and employees with the prescribed steps to support successful prosecution.

The order also amended BIR Form No. 0713. The revision date was changed from July 1999 to September 2010. The introductory provision was also corrected to refer to Section 37, Chapter 9, Book I of the Administrative Code of 1987, instead of the previously misquoted Section 36. For businesses, the practical point is that SDTs issued under this process must comply with specific form, serial-numbering, authority, and service requirements.

Who Is Affected by RMO No. 88-2010

RMO No. 88-2010 directly affects taxpayers under BIR audit or investigation, especially those who have received earlier requests for books of accounts, accounting records, or other documents but have not fully complied. It is relevant to individual taxpayers, corporations, partnerships, associations, large taxpayers, SMEs, and any business whose records are required for the determination of internal revenue tax liabilities.

For individual taxpayers, the SDT is issued to the same person who is the subject of the audit investigation. For corporations, partnerships, or associations, the SDT may be issued to the partner, president, general manager, branch manager, treasurer, officer-in-charge, or the employees responsible for the custody of the books of accounts and other accounting records required for audit investigation, pursuant to Section 253(d) of the NIRC.

This is particularly important for CFOs, corporate accountants, controllers, treasurers, finance managers, and in-house counsel because the person with custody or control over the books and records may become the named person required to comply. Businesses searching for BIR subpoena duces tecum, failure to obey summons BIR, BIR Form 0713, BIR audit records subpoena, and NIRC Section 266 penalty should understand that the issue is not merely administrative. It may become a criminal prosecution if the required books and records are not produced.

Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

Every SDT must contain a serial number and must include the number and date of the Letter of Authority, Tax Verification Notice, or other official document authorizing the audit investigation. This detail is important because an SDT must be linked to an authorized audit or investigation. The date of issuance of the SDT is the date when it is officially signed.

The most important deadline is the fourteen-day compliance period. RMO No. 88-2010 provides that the compliance date for submission of books of accounts and other accounting records shall be set on the fourteenth day from the date of issuance of the SDT. Revenue Officers must also indicate a compliance date that corresponds to this fourteen-day rule.

The order also imposes deadlines on BIR officers. The Prosecution Division, Legal Division, or other authorized office must evaluate a request for issuance of an SDT within two working days from receipt. After issuance, the duly issued SDT must be served within three working days from receipt by the concerned Revenue Officers. Within three working days from service of the SDT, the Revenue Officers who served it must furnish the issuing office with the served copy and a duly executed Affidavit of Service.

Service must follow strict procedural rules. Whenever practicable, the SDT must be served by handing a copy to the person named in it. If the person refuses to receive and sign, it may be tendered to that person, witnessed by another revenue officer accompanying the server. If personal service cannot be made for justifiable causes, service may be made at the dwelling place or residence of the subject individual with a person of suitable age and discretion then residing there, or at the office or regular place of business with a competent person in charge. In both substituted service situations, the service must be witnessed by another revenue officer.

Enforcement of the Subpoena Duces Tecum

Revenue Officers conducting the audit investigation are required to be present during the designated time, date, and place set for presentation of the books of accounts and accounting records. Their presence is necessary to verify whether the records presented are substantially complete as required by the SDT. The order expressly states that non-compliance by the concerned Revenue Officers with this requirement shall subject violators to administrative liability.

If the records presented are substantially complete, the case is referred back to the assessing unit for continuation of the delayed investigation. If the taxpayer or responsible person fails to present the required books and accounting records, the action lawyer assigned to the case must request a conference with the concerned Revenue Officers. This conference is scheduled on the fifth working day from the date set for compliance with the SDT. The Revenue Officers and action lawyer then work together in documenting and gathering evidence for criminal prosecution of the individual who disobeyed the SDT.

Criminal Case for Failure to Obey Summons

RMO No. 88-2010 provides a specific timeline for filing a case. Within seven working days from the conference scheduled after non-compliance, the action lawyer must prepare a Letter-Complaint addressed to the City Prosecutor recommending criminal prosecution for failure to obey summons. The complaint package must include the Affidavit-Complaint and supporting evidentiary documents, properly marked, and must be routed for review and signature by the concerned revenue officials.

The Revenue Officers are the complainants in the Affidavit-Complaint because they have personal knowledge of the non-compliance. They requested the issuance of the SDT, served it on the taxpayer or responsible person, and were present on the compliance date indicated in the SDT. For SDTs issued by Revenue Regions, the Regional Directors sign the letter-complaint. For SDTs issued by the Legal Service and the Large Taxpayers Service, the Deputy Commissioner for Legal and Inspection Group signs the letter-complaint, in accordance with Revenue Delegated Authority Order No. 2-2007.

Penalties and Delayed Compliance

Delayed compliance does not automatically erase the consequences of non-compliance. If, during the pendency of the criminal action for failure to obey summons, the respondent submits the required books of accounts and accounting records and seeks dismissal of the case, the BIR prosecuting officer may concur only upon presentation of two items.

First, there must be a joint certification issued by the Prosecution Division, Legal Division, or other authorized office, together with the Revenue Officers who requested the SDT, stating that the required books and accounting records have been received from the respondent and specifically stating the date of submission. Second, there must be a receipt showing payment of the Php10,000.00 penalty imposed by Section 266 of the NIRC on account of delayed compliance that deferred the ongoing audit investigation.

For businesses, this means that late submission may reduce litigation risk only if properly documented and accompanied by payment of the required penalty. It is not enough to informally submit records or negotiate with the examiner without ensuring that the required certification and payment documentation are in place.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Businesses

Upon receipt of an SDT, the taxpayer should immediately identify the date of issuance, the compliance date, the records required, the taxable year under investigation, and the underlying Letter of Authority, Tax Verification Notice, or other audit authority stated in the SDT. The fourteen-day period should be treated as a hard deadline for organizing and producing the required books of accounts and accounting records.

Corporate taxpayers should identify the officer or employee named in the SDT and determine whether that person actually has custody or control over the required records. The company should also ensure that finance, accounting, legal, and management teams coordinate quickly, because the named officer may be personally exposed to proceedings if the SDT is ignored.

Taxpayers should also preserve proof of what was submitted, when it was submitted, who received it, and whether the records were complete. If only partial records are available, the taxpayer should document the reason and seek legal guidance on how to respond. Since the SDT process may lead to criminal prosecution, casual or incomplete responses can create avoidable risk.

Businesses undergoing BIR audit should also review earlier BIR letter requests. RMO No. 88-2010 requires that the request for issuance of an SDT list the particular books and records to be examined, excluding documents already submitted as partial compliance with earlier requests. This means taxpayers should maintain an organized record of all prior submissions to avoid duplication and to show good-faith compliance.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMO No. 88-2010 is a reminder that BIR audit compliance is not limited to assessment strategy. A failure to properly respond to a Subpoena Duces Tecum may trigger criminal exposure, a formal complaint before the City Prosecutor, and a statutory penalty for delayed compliance. Businesses should respond early, preserve documentation, and obtain legal guidance before the matter escalates from audit to prosecution.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in BIR audit defense, document production strategy, responses to Subpoena Duces Tecum, settlement and compliance documentation, and representation in tax-related criminal complaints. For assistance with BIR audit notices, RMO No. 88-2010 compliance, or failure to obey summons issues, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *