RMC No. 27-2011 makes voluntary excess SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth and Pag-IBIG contributions taxable and limits exemption to mandatory contributions.

Employees and employers can no longer treat voluntary contributions to SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG 2, insurance plans, pre-need plans, and similar optional programs as automatically tax-exempt compensation deductions. Under RMC No. 27-2011, only mandatory or compulsory contributions required by law are excluded from gross income and exempt from income tax and withholding tax. Amounts voluntarily contributed in excess of what the law requires must be included in taxable compensation, and employers must review payroll withholding immediately to avoid deficiency assessments.

What RMC No. 27-2011 Changed

RMC No. 27-2011 revoked BIR Ruling Nos. 002-99 dated January 12, 1999, DA-184-04 dated April 6, 2004, DA-569-04 dated November 10, 2004, and DA-087-06 dated March 6, 2006. Those prior rulings had allowed certain contributions in excess of the mandatory monthly contribution to be excluded from the taxpayer’s gross income and treated as exempt from income tax.

The revoked rulings covered contributions to Pag-IBIG 2, GSIS, SSS, life insurance, pre-need plans, GSIS Optional Insurance Premium, GSIS Educational Plan Premium, GSIS Memorial Plan Premium, and GSIS Unlimited Optional Insurance Premium. The prior position was based on an interpretation of Section 32(B)(7)(f) of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, which was previously read to include optional GSIS and Pag-IBIG 2 contributions because the law and implementing regulations did not expressly limit the exemption to regular GSIS and Pag-IBIG contributions.

RMC No. 27-2011 reverses that position. The BIR expressly held that the contributions referred to in Section 32(B)(7)(f) of the NIRC cover only mandatory or compulsory contributions of employees to SSS, GSIS, PHIC and HDMF. Voluntary contributions in excess of what the law allows are not excludible from gross income, are not exempt from income tax, and are not exempt from withholding tax on compensation.

Why the BIR Changed Its Position

The BIR stated that the income tax exemption for SSS, GSIS, PHIC and Pag-IBIG contributions in excess of the mandatory amounts was being abused. The concern was that employees could use voluntary contributions as a form of investment while avoiding tax on amounts that would otherwise form part of taxable compensation.

The circular gives a concrete example: aside from a mandatory contribution of Php100.00 per month to the Pag-IBIG Fund and 1% for those with monthly compensation of Php1,500.00 and below, or 2% for those with monthly compensation of over Php1,500.00 to PHIC, an employee may contribute an additional Php1,000.00 per month to Pag-IBIG 2 and Php1,000.00 per month to PHIC as voluntary contributions. The BIR viewed these additional contributions as capable of being used as investment-type placements that were not being taxed.

The BIR also identified a practical withholding problem. Employers are required to correctly withhold the tax due from employees, so that the tax due is equivalent to the tax withheld. However, voluntary contributions by employees may not always pass through the employer. This makes payroll tax compliance difficult where employees claim tax exemption for voluntary contributions made outside the payroll system.

Who Is Affected

RMC No. 27-2011 directly affects employees who make voluntary contributions beyond the mandatory amounts required by law to SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth or Pag-IBIG, including Pag-IBIG 2 contributions and optional GSIS-related premiums. It also affects employees who participate in life insurance, pre-need, educational, memorial or optional insurance arrangements that were previously treated under the revoked BIR rulings as excluded from gross income.

The circular is equally important for employers, payroll teams, corporate accountants, HR departments, CFOs and withholding agents. Employers cannot simply deduct all SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth and Pag-IBIG-related amounts from taxable compensation. They must distinguish mandatory or compulsory contributions from voluntary or excess contributions, because only the mandatory portion qualifies for exclusion from gross income and exemption from withholding tax on compensation.

This is especially relevant to companies with employees who maximize savings or investment features through Pag-IBIG 2, GSIS optional products, voluntary PhilHealth payments, or other similar arrangements. It is also relevant during BIR audits, because revenue officers conducting audit investigations are instructed to take the circular into consideration.

Specific Contribution Rules and Figures Cited in the Circular

For Pag-IBIG, RMC No. 27-2011 refers to the Home Development Mutual Fund Law of 2009. Covered employees earning not more than Php1,500.00 per month contribute 1%. Employees earning more than Php1,500.00 per month contribute 2%. All employers contribute 2% of the monthly compensation of all covered employees. The maximum monthly compensation to be used in computing employee and employer contributions shall not be more than Php5,000.00, subject to adjustment by the Board of Trustees through rules and regulations.

The circular also refers to the mandatory nature of GSIS contributions under Republic Act No. 8291, SSS contributions under Republic Act No. 8282, and Medicare or PhilHealth contributions under Republic Act No. 7875. The key point across these laws is that the statutory term contribution is tied to amounts payable or paid in accordance with the governing statute, salary or wage schedules, coverage rules, or other criteria defined by the relevant program.

For payroll and tax purposes, the practical rule is straightforward: the mandatory contribution required under the governing law may be excluded from gross income. The voluntary excess, optional add-on, investment-like contribution, or additional premium is taxable compensation unless another specific tax exemption applies.

Effect on Withholding Tax on Compensation

RMC No. 27-2011 also clarifies the application of Section 2.78.1(B)(12) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98. The exemption from withholding tax on compensation under that provision applies only to mandatory or compulsory GSIS, SSS, Medicare and Pag-IBIG contributions.

This means that employers should not allow voluntary employee contributions to reduce the taxable compensation base for withholding tax purposes. Where an employee makes excess voluntary payments to SSS, GSIS, PHIC or HDMF, the employer should treat those amounts as taxable unless they fall within the mandatory contribution required by law.

Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

RMC No. 27-2011 is dated July 1, 2011. It revokes and invalidates the prior rulings and deems all revenue issuances inconsistent with the circular repealed. The circular does not provide a separate transition period, grace period, or delayed effectivity date.

For employers and withholding agents, the compliance action is immediate: review payroll deductions, identify voluntary or excess employee contributions, and ensure that only mandatory SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth and Pag-IBIG contributions are excluded from gross income and withholding tax on compensation. Any payroll system, HR policy, employment benefit package, or accounting treatment that treats voluntary contributions as exempt should be corrected.

Penalties and Audit Risk for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 27-2011 does not create a new special penalty rate. However, it expressly instructs revenue officers conducting audit investigations to apply the circular. Any claim for exemption for voluntary contributions shall be disallowed, and where applicable, the corresponding deficiency assessment shall be made.

For businesses, the real risk is a BIR audit finding that payroll withholding tax was undercomputed because voluntary contributions were improperly excluded from taxable compensation. The employer may then face deficiency withholding tax assessments, and the affected employee’s compensation tax treatment may also be questioned. Payroll compliance should therefore be documented and reconciled with the statutory contribution schedules.

Practical Steps for Employers, CFOs and Payroll Teams

Companies should first separate mandatory contributions from voluntary contributions in their payroll register. Mandatory SSS, GSIS, PhilHealth and Pag-IBIG contributions should remain coded as statutory deductions. Voluntary Pag-IBIG 2 contributions, optional GSIS insurance premiums, GSIS educational plan premiums, GSIS memorial plan premiums, unlimited optional insurance premiums, and similar excess payments should be reviewed and, where applicable, treated as taxable compensation.

Second, employers should update payroll tax computation templates so that only the legally required contribution is excluded from gross income. Payroll teams should not rely on the mere label of the payment as SSS, GSIS, PHIC or Pag-IBIG. The controlling question is whether the amount is mandatory or compulsory under the applicable law.

Third, companies should communicate the tax treatment to employees who voluntarily make additional contributions. Employees may still contribute voluntarily for savings, insurance or investment reasons, but they should not assume that the excess amount will reduce taxable compensation or withholding tax.

Fourth, accountants should prepare audit support showing the basis for the excluded contribution amounts, including contribution schedules and payroll computations. This is particularly important because the circular specifically directs revenue officers to disallow exemption claims for voluntary contributions.

Common search issues affected by this circular include tax on Pag-IBIG 2 contributions, withholding tax on voluntary SSS contributions, income tax treatment of GSIS optional insurance premium, taxable compensation voluntary PhilHealth contribution, and BIR rules on excess employee contributions.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 27-2011 is a reminder that payroll tax compliance is not only about applying statutory deduction codes. Employers must identify which deductions are legally mandatory and which are voluntary, optional, or investment-like payments that may remain taxable. A small payroll classification error can become a recurring withholding tax exposure across many employees and taxable periods.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, HR departments and in-house counsel on BIR compliance, withholding tax exposure, payroll tax reviews, tax audit defense, and employee compensation structuring. For assistance in reviewing the tax treatment of employee contributions, correcting payroll policies, or responding to BIR audit findings, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *