RMC No. 59-2011 clarifies how SARO, TSAC, and TSDM tax subsidy collections must be credited and reported to prevent double-counted BIR collections.
Revenue District Offices that previously counted the same tax subsidy-related collections more than once had to correct their BIR Form No. 12.09 reporting, because RMC No. 59-2011 clarified that SARO-based collections, TSAC availments, and TSDM availments must be reported differently to avoid distorted tax collection figures. The most urgent compliance point was the December 28, 2011 deadline for concerned RDOs to amend their January to October 2011 Monthly Statistical Reports where TSAC, TSDM, CES-only, or out-of-period SARO collections were incorrectly included as regular collection performance.
What RMC No. 59-2011 Changed
RMC No. 59-2011 clarified the proper crediting and reporting of tax collections arising from Special Allotment Release Orders, Tax Subsidy Availment Certificates, and Tax Subsidy Debit Memos. The issue addressed was not a new tax rate or a new tax imposed on taxpayers. Instead, the ruling corrected how non-cash tax subsidy collections should be recognized in BIR collection performance reports, particularly where more than one Revenue District Office appeared to be claiming the same tax collection.
The BIR observed discrepancies between tax collections reported by some Revenue District Offices and tax collections recognized by the Bureau of the Treasury. These discrepancies arose from tax subsidy availments of qualified beneficiaries determined by the Fiscal Incentives Review Board, such as the Armed Forces of the Philippines Commissary Exchange Services, Philippine National Police Service Store System, and Bases Conversion and Development Authority.
Under the clarified rule, tax collections through SAROs are credited to the RDO having jurisdiction over the principal place of business of the tax subsidy beneficiary. This means that the RDO of the tax subsidy beneficiary, not the RDOs of later suppliers or contractors using TSACs or TSDMs, is the office that may recognize the SARO collection as part of collection performance.
Who Is Affected by the Clarification
The immediate parties affected were Revenue District Offices, the Revenue Accounting Division, the Statistics Division, and officials involved in the monthly reporting of tax collections under BIR Form No. 12.09. However, the clarification also matters to government contractors, suppliers, sub-suppliers, consultants, subcontractors, and tax subsidy beneficiaries because their tax payments through TSACs and TSDMs are classified in a specific way for BIR reporting purposes.
Businesses dealing with tax subsidy beneficiaries should understand that the use of a TSAC or TSDM may settle a tax liability, but the resulting tax collection is not to be treated as regular collection performance of the RDO having jurisdiction over the supplier, sub-supplier, contractor, subcontractor, or consultant. For accountants and tax managers searching for RMC No. 59-2011, SARO tax collections, TSAC tax payments, TSDM reporting, non-cash BIR collections, or BIR Form 12.09 amendments, the key point is classification: SAROs, TSACs, and TSDMs do not all generate the same reporting credit.
Crediting of SARO Tax Collections
Tax collections through SAROs are credited to the concerned RDO having jurisdiction over the principal place of business of the tax subsidy beneficiary. The collection is recognized by the Revenue Accounting Division and by the concerned RDO in the month when the amount is taken up in the books of the Bureau of the Treasury.
RMC No. 59-2011 specifically required the concerned RDO to be proactive in ensuring that all DBM-approved SAROs are immediately transmitted to the Bureau of the Treasury before the monthly closing of the latter’s books of accounts. The monthly closing occurs not later than the eighth working day of the following month. For December transactions, the closing date is the last working day of January of the ensuing year.
The circular gave examples showing that the relevant collection month follows the date the SARO is taken up in the BTr books, not merely the date when the RDO receives the document. For example, a SARO dated December 20, 2010 with a BTr JEV dated December 27, 2010, where the BTr books closed on January 31, 2011 and the RDO received it on January 7, 2011, was treated as a December 2010 collection month. Likewise, a SARO dated September 28, 2010 with a BTr JEV dated December 10, 2010 and an RDO receipt date of December 17, 2010 was also treated as a December 2010 collection.
Only DBM-Issued SAROs Are Acceptable for Collection Performance
Only SAROs duly issued by the Department of Budget and Management are acceptable as basis for claiming tax collections. RMC No. 59-2011 expressly states that a Certificate of Entitlement to Subsidy issued by the Fiscal Incentives Review Board, or any similar document issued before the SARO, cannot be used as the basis for recognizing the collection performance of RDOs.
This is important because a CES may show that a subsidy entitlement exists, but it is not the same as a SARO issued by the DBM. For BIR reporting purposes, the operative document for claiming collection performance is the SARO, not the preliminary entitlement document.
How TSAC and TSDM Collections Must Be Reported
Tax collections generated through TSACs and TSDMs must not be claimed as collection performance of the RDOs having jurisdiction over the local manufacturers, producers, suppliers, contractors, consultants, subcontractors, or sub-suppliers of tax subsidy beneficiaries. Instead, these amounts must only be classified as tax collections through TSACs and TSDMs in the BIR Form No. 12.09 reports.
The circular further required these TSAC and TSDM amounts to be denominated under the non-cash collection column, similar to the reporting of tax collections through Tax Debit Memos. In practical terms, a supplier using a TSAC or TSDM to pay tax may have a tax liability settled, but the RDO handling that supplier cannot count the same amount as its own regular collection performance.
Required Amendments and Deadline
RMC No. 59-2011 imposed a specific corrective action for RDOs that had already reported these items incorrectly. All RDOs that claimed collection performance from TSAC and TSDM availments, collections based only on CES, and out-of-period SARO collections as part of regular tax collections in their BIR Form No. 12.09 reports had to prepare and submit amended 12.09 reports to the Statistics Division.
The amended reports covered the period January to October 2011 and had to be submitted not later than December 28, 2011. Thereafter, collections from TSACs and TSDMs had to be reported in accordance with the clarified non-cash collection reporting rule.
Penalties and Compliance Risk
RMC No. 59-2011 does not specify a separate monetary penalty, surcharge, or interest charge for non-compliance. However, it directs all revenue officials and concerned offices to strictly comply with the circular. The Statistics Division, in coordination with the Revenue Accounting Division, was tasked to monitor compliance to ensure that correct tax collections were reported in BIR Form No. 12.09 reports.
The practical risk is inaccurate revenue reporting, double counting of tax collections, incorrect collection performance recognition, and the need to amend prior reports. For taxpayers and businesses, the ruling underscores the importance of keeping clear documentation when tax liabilities are settled through tax subsidy mechanisms rather than ordinary cash payments.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers, Suppliers, and Accountants
Businesses dealing with government tax subsidy beneficiaries should first identify whether the tax settlement involved a SARO, TSAC, TSDM, TDM, or only a CES. The distinction matters because only DBM-issued SAROs may support collection performance recognition, while TSACs and TSDMs must be treated as non-cash collections in the appropriate reporting column.
Second, companies should preserve copies of the relevant SARO, TSAC, TSDM, BTr Journal Entry Voucher, and related BIR payment or availment documentation. Although the circular is directed mainly to BIR offices, taxpayers that rely on tax subsidy instruments should be ready to explain how a tax liability was settled and when the payment was recognized.
Third, accountants should verify the timing of recognition. For SARO collections, the relevant month is the month when the item is taken up in the books of the Bureau of the Treasury. RDO receipt dates and SARO dates may be relevant, but the BTr book recognition date controls the collection month under the circular’s examples.
Fourth, suppliers, contractors, consultants, subcontractors, and sub-suppliers should not assume that payment through a TSAC or TSDM is treated the same way as an ordinary cash tax payment for collection performance purposes. For internal tax files, they should classify the transaction as a non-cash tax subsidy-related settlement where applicable.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 59-2011 is a technical reporting clarification, but it affects how tax subsidy transactions are documented, classified, and defended during BIR review. Businesses that deal with government entities, tax subsidy beneficiaries, contractors, suppliers, or non-cash tax settlement instruments should ensure that their accounting files match the BIR’s treatment of SAROs, TSACs, and TSDMs.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists companies, CFOs, accounting teams, government contractors, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR compliance, tax documentation, non-cash tax settlement issues, and audit-ready reporting procedures. For guidance on SARO, TSAC, TSDM, BIR Form No. 12.09, and other Philippine tax compliance concerns, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.