RMC No. 39-2012 requires garnishees to withhold 5% tax on taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits paid through labor award garnishment.

Backwage awards enforced through garnishment now require immediate withholding tax action: the garnishee holding or controlling the employer’s money must deduct and withhold 5% of the taxable portion of the judgment award representing backwages, allowances, and benefits before payment is made to the employee. For employers, banks, financial institutions, payroll teams, accountants, and counsel handling labor dispute awards, RMC No. 39-2012 makes clear that garnishment does not allow the withholding tax on wages to be bypassed.

What RMC No. 39-2012 Changed

RMC No. 39-2012 addresses a practical tax issue in labor cases: when an employee wins a labor dispute award for backwages, allowances, and benefits, and the award is enforced not by the employer directly but through garnishment of the employer’s debts, credits, bank deposits, financial interests, royalties, or commissions, who withholds the income tax?

The rule is specific. Backwages, allowances, and benefits awarded in a labor dispute are treated as remuneration for services that would have been performed by the employee either during the year when actually received or during the period from dismissal up to the final decision of the court awarding the backwages. They are income to the employee and are subject to withholding tax on wages.

Ordinarily, the employer withholds income tax on wages under the withholding tax system. However, when the judgment is enforced by garnishing debts or credits due to the employer, the employer may no longer have control over the actual payment to the employee. RMC No. 39-2012 solves this by treating the garnishee as the withholding agent because the garnishee is the person with control over the payment.

Who Is Affected by the 5% Withholding Rule

The most directly affected parties are garnishees of labor judgment awards. These may include banks, other financial institutions, persons owing money to the employer, persons holding credits belonging to the employer, or persons in possession or control of funds, deposits, financial interests, royalties, commissions, or similar credits that are garnished to satisfy a labor dispute award.

Employers involved in labor disputes are also affected because the tax treatment of backwages, allowances, and benefits must be anticipated when negotiating settlements, computing judgment exposure, or responding to garnishment proceedings. Even if payment is taken from a third party through garnishment, the award may still be subject to withholding tax on wages.

Employees who are awarded backwages, allowances, and benefits are affected because the amount released to them through garnishment may be reduced by withholding tax. Corporate accountants, HR payroll teams, labor counsel, in-house counsel, and tax practitioners should therefore account for the tax deduction when computing net proceeds from labor dispute awards.

Common search issues affected by this rule include BIR withholding tax on backwages, tax on labor dispute award, garnishment of employer bank deposits, withholding tax on NLRC backwages, and 5% withholding tax on judgment award.

Key Compliance Requirement: Garnishees Must Withhold 5%

The central compliance requirement under RMC No. 39-2012 is that garnishees of a judgment award in a labor dispute are constituted as withholding agents. They have the duty to deduct the corresponding withholding tax on wages due on the taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits.

The specific withholding amount stated in RMC No. 39-2012 is 5% of the portion of the judgment award representing taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits. This means the withholding obligation does not necessarily apply to every amount connected with the case if the amount is not part of the taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits covered by the circular. The key is to identify the portion of the award representing taxable compensation-type items.

For example, if a labor judgment is enforced by garnishment against a bank account or a receivable due to the employer, the bank or other garnishee must not simply release the full garnished amount to the employee without considering the withholding tax requirement. The garnishee is treated as the party having control of the payment and must deduct and withhold the 5% amount from the taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits to be paid.

Legal Basis: Control of Payment Determines the Withholding Agent

RMC No. 39-2012 relies on the statutory and regulatory concept of employer for withholding tax purposes. Section 78(D)(1) of the Tax Code of 1997, as amended, provides that if the person for whom the individual performs or performed services does not have control of the payment of wages, the term employer, for purposes of withholding, refers to the person having control of the payment of such wages.

The circular also refers to Section 2.78.4(A) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended. That provision explains that where the person for whom the services are or were performed does not control payment of compensation, the term employer also refers to the person having control of the payment of compensation.

Applied to garnishment, the reasoning is straightforward. The employer may be the party against whom the labor award was rendered, but the garnishee may be the party actually holding the funds or credits to be paid. Because the garnishee controls the payment, the garnishee is authorized and required to deduct and withhold the income tax due from the taxable portion of the award.

Effective Date and Timing Considerations

RMC No. 39-2012 is dated August 6, 2012. For compliance purposes, businesses and financial institutions handling labor dispute garnishments should treat the rule as applicable to garnished payments of taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits covered by the circular from that issuance date onward.

The practical timing issue arises at the point of release of the garnished funds. The withholding should be addressed before the garnishee pays the employee. A garnishee that waits until after release may have difficulty recovering the tax amount, especially where the full garnished sum has already been turned over pursuant to a labor judgment or execution process.

Penalties and Risk for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 39-2012 does not state a separate special penalty rate for failure to withhold the 5% amount. However, it expressly constitutes garnishees as withholding agents with the duty to deduct the corresponding withholding tax on wages. That designation is important because a party treated as a withholding agent is not merely a passive holder of funds; it has a tax compliance role when releasing the garnished amount.

For businesses and financial institutions, the main risk is releasing the full taxable portion of the labor award without withholding the 5% amount. This can create disputes over who should bear the unwithheld tax, delay implementation of the labor judgment, and expose the responsible withholding agent to ordinary withholding tax compliance issues under the applicable tax rules.

Practical Steps for Employers, Banks, and Accountants

First, identify whether the labor dispute award includes backwages, allowances, and benefits. RMC No. 39-2012 is aimed at these compensation-type amounts because they are treated as remuneration for services and are subject to withholding tax on wages.

Second, determine whether the award will be paid directly by the employer or through garnishment. If payment will be enforced against bank deposits, receivables, credits, financial interests, royalties, commissions, or other amounts belonging to the employer, the person holding or controlling those funds may become the withholding agent.

Third, isolate the taxable portion of the award. The 5% withholding applies to the portion of the judgment award representing taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits. Accounting teams should avoid applying the 5% mechanically to amounts not identified as taxable compensation-type items, while also avoiding release of taxable backwages without withholding.

Fourth, coordinate among legal, HR, payroll, treasury, and the garnishee before funds are released. The withholding treatment should be documented in the computation of the labor judgment award, the garnishment response, and the payment or release documents.

Finally, employees and their counsel should be advised that a garnished labor award may be paid net of withholding tax. This reduces confusion when the amount received is lower than the gross award stated in the labor decision or execution papers.

Why This Matters for Business Owners and CFOs

Labor dispute awards are often treated by management as litigation costs, but RMC No. 39-2012 reminds businesses that they also involve payroll tax and withholding tax consequences. A company facing execution or garnishment should not look only at the labor law liability. It should also review the tax treatment of backwages, allowances, and benefits to prevent a second compliance problem after the labor case.

For CFOs and controllers, the key takeaway is that garnishment changes who controls the payment, but it does not erase the withholding tax obligation. For banks and financial institutions, the key takeaway is even more direct: if they are the garnishee holding the employer’s funds, they may be required to withhold 5% from the taxable backwages, allowances, and benefits before paying the employee.

ASG Law Can Help with BIR Compliance for Labor Awards and Garnishments

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, business owners, banks, financial institutions, CFOs, accounting teams, and in-house counsel on the tax and labor law consequences of backwage awards, garnishments, settlements, and execution of labor judgments. Our Makati-based team can help review labor award computations, identify withholding tax exposure, coordinate with garnishees, and prepare practical compliance steps before funds are released.

For assistance with RMC No. 39-2012, BIR withholding tax on backwages, garnishment compliance, or the tax treatment of labor dispute awards in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *