RMC No. 71-2012 clarifies deferred VAT remittance rules for power suppliers, DUs, ECs, PEMC, and WESM, including deadlines and audit exposure.
Electric power industry taxpayers with deferred VAT balances before August 25, 2012 must determine immediately which amounts were actually collected from end-users, remitted by distribution utilities or electric cooperatives, and still outstanding. RMC No. 71-2012 clarifies that generation companies, aggregators, market operators, retail electricity suppliers, and other electricity suppliers are not automatically liable for interest and penalties on all unpaid deferred VAT; however, amounts already received from distribution utilities or electric cooperatives but not paid to the BIR within the prescribed deadline are exposed to surcharge, interest, and penalties.
What RMC No. 71-2012 Changed
RMC No. 71-2012 clarified the implementation of RMC No. 62-2012, particularly on the treatment of deferred VAT accumulated before August 25, 2012 in the electric power industry. The central rule is that generation companies, aggregators, market operators, retail electricity suppliers, and other suppliers of electricity are required to remit only the deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012 that they have actually collected from distribution utilities and electric cooperatives, where those utilities and cooperatives have also collected the corresponding VAT from end-users or customers.
This clarification is important because it prevents the BIR from treating all outstanding deferred VAT balances as immediately collectible from suppliers regardless of actual collection. The obligation is tied to collection. If the distribution utility or electric cooperative has not collected the deferred VAT from end-users, or has not remitted the amount to the relevant supplier, the supplier is not treated as liable for interest and penalties on that uncollected amount solely by reason of the outstanding balance.
However, the protection is not absolute. If deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012 was already remitted by the distribution utility or electric cooperative to the generation company, aggregator, market operator, retail electricity supplier, or other electricity supplier, but the recipient supplier failed to pay the amount to the BIR within the applicable deadline, the unpaid amount becomes subject to surcharge, interest, and penalties.
Who Is Affected
RMC No. 71-2012 directly affects generation companies, aggregators, market operators, retail electricity suppliers, other suppliers of electricity, distribution utilities, electric cooperatives, and the Philippine Electricity Market Corporation or Wholesale Electricity Spot Market. It also affects government and GOCC customers of distribution utilities and electric cooperatives because the circular provides guidance on the issuance of BIR Form No. 2306 for the 5% creditable withholding VAT on electricity transactions.
The most affected taxpayers are those with deferred VAT accounts accumulated before the billing period or period ending August 25, 2012. CFOs, tax managers, and accounting teams in the electric power sector should search their books for deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012, RMC 71-2012 deferred VAT, RMC 62-2012 electricity VAT, BIR Form 0605 deferred VAT payment, and WESM PEMC deferred VAT remittance because these are the operational phrases tied to the compliance obligations under the circular.
Key Deadlines and Compliance Requirements
The circular imposed specific transitory procedures and dates. Generation companies, aggregators, market operators, retail electricity suppliers, and other suppliers of electricity were required to submit to the Office of the Commissioner, on or before November 19, 2012, both hard copy and soft copy in CD form of an inventory as of September 30, 2012 of the outstanding deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012 from distribution utilities, electric cooperatives, and others. The prescribed format was provided in Annex A.
Distribution utilities and electric cooperatives were required to remit the deferred VAT on behalf of each generation company, aggregator, retail electricity supplier, and other supplier of electricity through manual filing and payment on or before November 26, 2012 using BIR Form No. 0605. The taxpayer identification number of the generation company, aggregator, retail electricity supplier, or other electricity supplier had to be clearly indicated on BIR Form No. 0605. The box for “Others (Specify)” had to be marked with an “X,” and the payment had to be described as “DEFERRED VAT – RMC 71-2012.” The filing and payment had to be made at the Revenue District Office where the distribution utility or electric cooperative was registered.
Distribution utilities and electric cooperatives were also required to submit to the Office of the Commissioner on November 28, 2012, both hard copy and soft copy in CD form of a Summary of the Remittance of Deferred VAT. The summary had to indicate the name of the supplier, address, TIN, RDO number, amount of VAT remitted, billing period, name of bank, and date of remittance, following the format in Annex B.
After payment, distribution utilities and electric cooperatives had to provide the relevant generation companies, aggregators, retail electricity suppliers, and other electricity suppliers with copies of the duly filed BIR Form No. 0605 and proof of payment within three days from the date of remittance to the BIR. Those documents became the basis for the suppliers to record payment of deferred VAT. Any unremitted portion of deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012 remained outstanding until the closure of the BIR audit of the distribution utility or electric cooperative.
Special Rules for PEMC and WESM Deferred VAT
For deferred VAT prior to the billing period ending August 25, 2012 involving the Philippine Electricity Market Corporation or Wholesale Electricity Spot Market, distribution utilities and electric cooperatives were required to remit the deferred VAT to PEMC not later than November 19, 2012. PEMC, in turn, was required to remit the amount to the BIR through manual filing and payment on or before November 26, 2012 using BIR Form No. 0605.
For PEMC and WESM payments, the TIN of the generation company, aggregator, retail electricity supplier, or other electricity supplier had to be clearly indicated on BIR Form No. 0605. The “Others (Specify)” box also had to be marked, with the payment identified as “DEFERRED VAT – RMC 71-2012.” Filing and payment had to be made at the Development Bank of the Philippines, either at the ground floor of the BIR National Office or the Quezon Avenue Branch, after securing approval from the Chief of LTDPQAD.
Distribution utilities and electric cooperatives were required to submit to the Office of the Commissioner on November 28, 2012 a Summary of Remittance of Deferred VAT to PEMC/WESM following Annex C. PEMC/WESM was likewise required to submit on November 28, 2012 a Summary of the Remittance of Deferred VAT indicating the supplier name, address, TIN, RDO number, amount of VAT remitted, billing period, bank name, and remittance date following Annex B.
Amounts That Distribution Utilities and Electric Cooperatives Need Not Advance
RMC No. 71-2012 expressly states that distribution utilities and electric cooperatives are not required to advance all outstanding VAT where the amounts can no longer be collected from customers. The circular identifies three examples: VAT zero-rated sales of distribution utilities and electric cooperatives relating to PEZA-registered enterprises, the 5% withholding VAT relating to sales by distribution utilities and electric cooperatives to the Government or GOCCs, and the corresponding VAT of written-off delinquent accounts.
The controlling rule is that distribution utilities and electric cooperatives are only required to remit VAT actually collected from end-users. However, any remaining deferred VAT account balance is not ignored. Distribution utilities and electric cooperatives are subject to immediate audit to validate the reasons for the remaining deferred VAT balance.
Ongoing VAT Remittance Process After RMC No. 62-2012
Under the new process clarified by RMC No. 71-2012, VAT collected from end-users by distribution utilities and electric cooperatives must be immediately remitted to generation companies, aggregators, market operators, retail electricity suppliers, and other suppliers of electricity not later than the 10th day of the following month. This timing is designed to enable generation companies and other suppliers to remit VAT on or before the 20th or 25th of the same month, whichever is applicable, net of their own input tax, if any.
Distribution utilities and electric cooperatives must also furnish the generation companies with a summary list of VAT collections from end-users or customers. This list enables generation companies to file VAT returns and attach the summary list as a supplemental schedule to the Summary List of Sales submitted to the BIR.
The circular also addresses prompt payment discounts. If a distribution utility or electric cooperative has a special arrangement with a generation company for discounts due to prompt payment, and the distribution utility or electric cooperative avails of the discount, the payment is deemed collected from the end-user or client. The amount must therefore be reported as part of the generation company’s vatable gross receipts and subjected to VAT.
Zero-Rated Sales, Reconciling Items, and Withholding VAT Certificates
For allocation purposes, zero-rated sales and other reconciling items must be proportionately allocated by distribution utilities and electric cooperatives based on kilowatt purchased. This rule is significant for tax accounting teams because it provides a concrete allocation method instead of allowing arbitrary assignment of reconciling items among generation companies or suppliers.
For sales to government and GOCC customers, distribution utilities and electric cooperatives must provide those customers with a breakdown of their generation companies. This serves as the reference for the issuance of separate Certificates of Final Tax Withheld at Source, or BIR Form No. 2306, for the generation cost and distribution cost. The same procedure applies where generation companies indirectly sell to distribution utilities and electric cooperatives through the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines, NPC, or PSALM.
The circular further notes that NGCP, as a provider of transmission services, is subject to 3% franchise tax. Accordingly, withholding on government money payments relating to NGCP transmission services is through percentage tax withholding, not through the VAT withholding treatment applicable to the generation and distribution components.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
The principal penalty exposure under RMC No. 71-2012 applies when deferred VAT prior to August 25, 2012 has already been remitted by the distribution utility or electric cooperative to the generation company, aggregator, market operator, retail electricity supplier, or other electricity supplier, but the recipient fails to pay the amount to the BIR within the prescribed deadline. In that situation, the unpaid amount is subject to surcharge, interest, and penalties.
For distribution utilities, electric cooperatives, PEMC, and WESM, the practical risk is audit exposure. Unremitted deferred VAT balances remain outstanding until the closure of the BIR audit. Where the taxpayer claims that certain balances were not collectible, were zero-rated, involved 5% withholding VAT on government or GOCC sales, or related to written-off delinquent accounts, the taxpayer must be prepared to support the treatment through books, customer records, billing data, remittance summaries, and other documentary evidence.
Practical Steps for Power Sector Taxpayers
Electric power sector taxpayers should first isolate all deferred VAT balances prior to August 25, 2012 and reconcile them against collections from end-users, remittances by distribution utilities or electric cooperatives, and payments already made to the BIR. The reconciliation should separately identify amounts collected and remitted, collected but not yet remitted, not collected from customers, zero-rated transactions, government or GOCC withholding VAT items, written-off delinquent accounts, and WESM or PEMC-related transactions.
Second, taxpayers should preserve the BIR Form No. 0605 payment records, proof of payment, summary remittance schedules, supplier breakdowns, TIN references, billing period details, and bank remittance information. These are not mere filing documents. Under RMC No. 71-2012, they are the basis for recording payment of deferred VAT and for defending remaining balances in a BIR audit.
Third, distribution utilities and electric cooperatives should maintain a defensible allocation worksheet for zero-rated sales and reconciling items based on kilowatt purchased. Government and GOCC sales should also be supported by proper breakdowns for BIR Form No. 2306 issuance, separating the generation cost from the distribution cost.
Finally, power sector taxpayers should review whether their monthly VAT remittance workflow complies with the 10th-day remittance rule for VAT collected from end-users, and whether the relevant suppliers are able to file VAT returns by the 20th or 25th day of the same month, as applicable. The operational issue is not only historical deferred VAT; it is also the continuing process for timely VAT reporting and payment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 71-2012 is highly technical because it connects VAT collection, power sector billing flows, WESM/PEMC remittances, government withholding certificates, zero-rated sales, and BIR audit documentation. A taxpayer’s exposure depends on the specific path of the money: whether VAT was collected from the end-user, whether it was remitted to the supplier, whether it was paid to the BIR, and whether any remaining balance is supported by valid reconciling items.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists Philippine businesses, power sector participants, distribution utilities, electric cooperatives, and corporate taxpayers in BIR compliance, VAT reconciliation, audit defense, tax documentation, and regulatory risk management. For assistance in reviewing deferred VAT exposure, preparing audit-ready documentation, or structuring compliant VAT remittance procedures, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.