RMC No. 63-2013 confirms RR 12-2013 applies to 2013 audits, denying deductions where required withholding tax was not made in the Philippines.
Taxpayers undergoing audit for taxable year 2013 must treat withholding tax compliance as a condition for deductibility of covered income payments. RMC No. 63-2013 clarifies that the stricter rule under Revenue Regulations No. 12-2013 applies to audit investigations for taxable year 2013, meaning a taxpayer cannot simply cure a failure to withhold by paying the withholding tax later during audit, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
What Changed Under RMC No. 63-2013
RMC No. 63-2013 clarifies the taxable year covered by Revenue Regulations No. 12-2013. The practical effect is direct: the provisions of RR No. 12-2013 apply to audit investigations for taxable year 2013.
RR No. 12-2013 amended the requirements for deductibility of certain income payments under Section 2.58.5 of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended. The clarified rule is that no deduction will be allowed, notwithstanding payment of withholding tax at the time of audit investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration, in cases where no withholding of tax was made in accordance with Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code.
In plain terms, businesses cannot assume that a late payment of withholding tax during a BIR audit will automatically preserve the deductibility of the related expense. For taxable year 2013, the BIR position is that the failure to withhold at the proper time may result in disallowance of the deduction, even if the taxpayer later attempts to pay the withholding tax after the issue is discovered.
Why This Matters to Businesses and Accountants
For corporate taxpayers, SMEs, large enterprises, and withholding agents, the most important consequence is that deductibility now depends not only on whether the expense is ordinary, necessary, substantiated, and business-related, but also on whether the proper withholding tax was made in accordance with the Tax Code.
This is especially important for companies with substantial payments to suppliers, contractors, professionals, lessors, consultants, service providers, and other payees whose income payments may be subject to expanded withholding tax or other withholding obligations. A business may have valid invoices, accounting entries, and proof of payment, but still face disallowance if the BIR finds that the required withholding tax was not made.
For CFOs and accounting departments searching for RMC 63-2013, RR 12-2013 deductibility, withholding tax disallowance of deductions, BIR audit taxable year 2013, or late payment of withholding tax during audit, the key point is that this issuance addresses timing and audit coverage. It confirms that the RR No. 12-2013 rule applies to BIR audit investigations for taxable year 2013.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 63-2013
The taxpayers most affected are withholding agents and business taxpayers claiming deductions for income payments covered by withholding tax rules. This includes corporations, partnerships, sole proprietors, and other taxpayers that make payments subject to withholding under Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code.
Accounting teams of companies under BIR audit for taxable year 2013 should pay particular attention. The circular is addressed to all internal revenue officers and others concerned, which means BIR examiners are expected to apply this clarification when reviewing 2013 tax audit cases.
The rule is also relevant to in-house counsel, external tax advisers, and finance officers handling protest, reinvestigation, or reconsideration proceedings. The issuance expressly mentions audit investigation, reinvestigation, and reconsideration, confirming that the deductibility issue may arise not only during the initial audit stage but also during administrative dispute stages before the BIR.
Key Compliance Requirement: Withhold at the Proper Time
The central compliance requirement is straightforward but strict: if an income payment is subject to withholding tax under Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code, the taxpayer must make the required withholding in accordance with law. A later payment of the withholding tax during audit investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration does not, by itself, save the deduction where no withholding was made when required.
RMC No. 63-2013 does not create a new withholding tax rate, new threshold, or new filing form. Instead, it clarifies the coverage of RR No. 12-2013 and confirms its application to taxable year 2013 audits. The compliance burden is therefore documentary and procedural: businesses must be able to show that they withheld the correct tax on covered payments and complied at the proper time.
Companies should review 2013 expense accounts, supplier payments, professional fees, service fees, rentals, commissions, and other deductible payments that may have been subject to withholding. The risk is not limited to the withholding tax exposure itself; the larger assessment risk may come from the disallowance of the income tax deduction tied to the payment.
Effective Date and Taxable Year Covered
RMC No. 63-2013 is dated September 26, 2013. Its clarification specifically provides that the provisions of RR No. 12-2013 shall apply to audit investigation for taxable year 2013.
This is the most important date-related point for taxpayers. The issuance does not merely discuss future compliance in general terms. It tells revenue officers and taxpayers that the RR No. 12-2013 deductibility rule applies in the context of taxable year 2013 audit investigations.
Businesses with 2013 tax exposure, pending assessments, reopened issues, reinvestigation proceedings, or reconsideration requests should therefore review whether any deductions may be vulnerable because no withholding tax was made when required.
Penalties and Consequences for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 63-2013 does not specify a separate surcharge, interest rate, or compromise penalty. The specific consequence stated in the issuance is the disallowance of the deduction. The circular reiterates that no deduction will be allowed notwithstanding payment of withholding tax at the time of audit investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration where no withholding of tax was made in accordance with Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code.
For business taxpayers, this can materially increase taxable income. If a major expense is disallowed, the taxpayer may face a larger deficiency income tax assessment because the expense is removed from deductible expenses. The impact can be significant where the taxpayer has large recurring payments to suppliers, contractors, consultants, or other payees subject to withholding tax rules.
The circular should therefore be treated as a BIR audit risk warning. It is not enough to pay withholding tax after the BIR examiner discovers the omission. The BIR position clarified in this issuance is that the timing and fact of withholding matter for deductibility.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Withholding Agents
Businesses should immediately reconcile deductible expense accounts against withholding tax records for taxable year 2013 audit exposure. The review should identify which income payments were subject to withholding tax, whether withholding was actually made, whether the correct tax was remitted, and whether the company has documents to support compliance.
Accounting teams should match general ledger expense accounts with withholding tax returns and remittance records. Payments to professionals, contractors, consultants, suppliers, landlords, agents, and other service providers should be reviewed carefully because these are common areas where deductibility and withholding tax issues arise during BIR audit.
Taxpayers already in audit, reinvestigation, or reconsideration should not rely solely on late withholding tax payment as a defense to preserve deductions. Instead, they should prepare a legal and factual position on whether withholding was required, whether it was made, and whether the expense remains deductible under the applicable rules.
Companies should also update internal accounting controls so that withholding tax review happens before payment release. Procurement, accounts payable, finance, and tax teams should coordinate to ensure that payments are classified correctly before they are booked and paid. This is the most practical way to avoid the deduction disallowance risk emphasized by RMC No. 63-2013 and RR No. 12-2013.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 63-2013 is a reminder that withholding tax compliance is not a mere back-office formality. It can determine whether a business expense remains deductible in a BIR audit. For companies with significant supplier, contractor, professional fee, rental, or service payment exposure, the cost of failing to withhold properly may be far greater than the withholding tax amount itself.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR audit exposure, preparing tax compliance positions, responding to assessment findings, and strengthening withholding tax controls. For assistance with RMC No. 63-2013, RR No. 12-2013, withholding tax deductibility issues, or BIR audit defense, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.