RMC No. 66-2013 revokes BIR Ruling No. 011-07 and treats PSALM/TransCo sub-transmission asset disposals as VATable transactions.
Businesses involved in electric power assets, concessions, transmission facilities, distribution utilities, and government privatization transactions must treat the sale or disposition of sub-transmission assets by PSALM as subject to value-added tax. RMC No. 66-2013 circularizes the revocation of BIR Ruling No. 011-07, removing the prior confirmation that TransCo would not be subject to VAT on the disposal of sub-transmission assets. The practical consequence is immediate and significant: parties to power sector asset sales can no longer rely on BIR Ruling No. 011-07 as authority for VAT exemption where the assets are used in the trade or business of the seller.
What RMC No. 66-2013 Changed
RMC No. 66-2013 circularized the revocation of BIR Ruling No. 011-07 dated May 31, 2007. That earlier ruling had confirmed, among others, that the National Transmission Corporation, or TransCo, would not be subject to VAT upon its disposal of sub-transmission assets. The basis then was that the disposal would be undertaken pursuant to the mandate of Republic Act No. 9136, otherwise known as the Electric Power Industry Reform Act of 2001 or EPIRA, and not in the ordinary course of TransCo’s trade or business.
The revoked ruling arose from transactions connected with the privatization of TransCo, including the award by PSALM to the winning bidder or concessionaire of the concession to construct, install, improve, expand, operate, maintain, rehabilitate, repair, and refurbish TransCo’s high voltage and medium voltage transmission system, as well as the temporary operation and management of sub-transmission assets until their disposal to qualified distribution utilities.
RMC No. 66-2013 changes the tax treatment by expressly recognizing that the sale or disposition of sub-transmission assets by PSALM is subject to VAT. The circular adopts the view that sub-transmission assets form part of the other real properties or disposable assets of PSALM that are subject to VAT under the rules clarified in RMC No. 11-2012.
Why the VAT Treatment Changed
The revocation is anchored on Republic Act No. 9337, enacted on July 1, 2005. Section 6 of RA 9337 amended Section 108 of the Tax Code on value-added tax on sale of services and use or lease of properties. The amendment placed the electric power industry within the VAT system by including sales of electricity by generation companies, transmission companies, and distribution companies among transactions subject to VAT.
RMC No. 66-2013 also relies on the amendments to Revenue Regulations No. 16-2005 by Revenue Regulations No. 04-2007. Under the cited rule, sales of real properties not primarily held for sale to customers or held for lease in the ordinary course of trade or business may still be subject to VAT if the real property is used in the trade or business of the seller. In that case, the sale is treated as a transaction incidental to the taxpayer’s main business.
The circular therefore rejects the earlier position that the statutory or privatization-driven nature of the disposal, by itself, removes the transaction from VAT. The controlling point is that assets used in business, including assets in the electric power industry that is now within the VAT system, may be subject to VAT when sold or disposed of, unless a specific exemption or zero-rating rule applies.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 66-2013
The most directly affected taxpayers and stakeholders are PSALM, TransCo, concessionaires, winning bidders, qualified distribution utilities, power sector asset purchasers, and entities involved in the disposal or acquisition of sub-transmission assets. The circular is particularly important for companies participating in electric power industry privatization, asset acquisition, due diligence, concession agreements, and purchase transactions involving transmission or sub-transmission facilities.
Corporate accountants, CFOs, tax managers, and in-house counsel for power companies should also review this issuance carefully. The key search issues are VAT on sale of sub-transmission assets, PSALM asset sale VAT, TransCo VAT treatment, RMC No. 66-2013 revocation of BIR Ruling No. 011-07, and VAT on real properties used in business. These phrases reflect the practical questions companies will ask when structuring or reviewing similar transactions.
Although the circular specifically concerns TransCo, PSALM, and sub-transmission assets, the reasoning is broader. A company should not assume that a sale of business-used real property is VAT-exempt merely because the property is not primarily held for sale or lease. If the property is used in the seller’s trade or business, the BIR may treat the sale as subject to VAT as an incidental transaction.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 66-2013 is dated September 30, 2013. It circularizes the September 18, 2013 memorandum revoking BIR Ruling No. 011-07 and directs all concerned to be guided accordingly. The document does not provide a separate future compliance deadline or grace period. The practical compliance point is that affected parties should no longer rely on BIR Ruling No. 011-07 for VAT exemption in covered transactions.
The revoked ruling had previously confirmed that TransCo was not subject to VAT on the disposal of sub-transmission assets. RMC No. 66-2013 expressly states that the sale or disposition of sub-transmission assets by PSALM is subject to VAT. It also revokes the earlier ruling insofar as it opined that TransCo was not subject to VAT on its transfer of title to transferable assets and assignment of intellectual property rights to the concessionaire pursuant to the award of the concession.
The circular further states that the Large Taxpayers Service is ordered to conduct an audit and investigation to ascertain the taxes due on the transaction. This makes the issuance more than a prospective interpretive clarification. It signals actual enforcement, especially for large taxpayers and power sector transactions covered by the revoked ruling.
Penalties and Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 66-2013 does not specify a new special penalty rate. However, failure to properly treat a VAT-subject transaction as subject to VAT may expose the taxpayer to the ordinary consequences under the Tax Code, including deficiency VAT assessment, surcharge, interest, and compromise penalties, depending on the facts and the applicable rules at the time of assessment.
The most immediate risk identified in the circular is audit exposure. The Large Taxpayers Service was expressly directed to conduct an audit and investigation to determine the taxes due on the transaction. For businesses, this means that tax positions based on the revoked ruling should be reviewed before they become the subject of an assessment, especially where large asset values, concession fees, or government privatization transactions are involved.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Tax Teams
First, review all power sector asset sale, concession, transfer, and privatization documents that previously relied on BIR Ruling No. 011-07. Any tax clause, pricing provision, gross-up clause, or indemnity clause assuming VAT exemption should be revisited.
Second, determine whether the assets involved are real properties, generation assets, sub-transmission assets, transferable assets, intellectual property rights, or other disposable assets used in trade or business. Under the reasoning of RMC No. 66-2013, the fact that an asset is not primarily held for sale does not automatically remove VAT exposure if it was used in business.
Third, check whether VAT was billed, paid, accrued, or claimed as input VAT. RMC No. 66-2013 notes that the VAT imposed on the sale of transferred assets may be utilized by the buyer as creditable input VAT. Purchasers should therefore review whether the transaction documentation and invoices support input VAT claims.
Fourth, prepare for possible BIR audit questions. Tax teams should maintain copies of the transaction agreements, invoices, VAT returns, accounting entries, board approvals, regulatory approvals, and legal memoranda supporting the tax treatment. For large taxpayers, the express instruction to the Large Taxpayers Service makes documentation especially important.
Finally, companies should avoid using old BIR rulings as blanket authority without checking whether later revenue memorandum circulars, revenue regulations, or statutory amendments have revoked or superseded them. RMC No. 66-2013 is a clear reminder that BIR rulings may be revoked when they become inconsistent with later issuances or statutory developments.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 66-2013 is a focused issuance, but its business impact is substantial for companies dealing with VAT on asset sales, electric power industry transactions, government privatization, and real properties used in business. The key lesson is that VAT exposure must be tested against the current Tax Code, revenue regulations, and later BIR issuances, not merely against a favorable historical ruling.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, CFOs, accountants, in-house counsel, and business owners on BIR compliance, VAT exposure, transaction structuring, tax assessments, and documentation for high-value corporate transactions. If your company is reviewing a power sector asset sale, a business-used property transfer, or a transaction previously treated as VAT-exempt, consult ASG Law before the BIR audit begins. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to schedule a consultation with our tax and business law team.