RMC No. 3-2014 treats real property transfers for preferred share redemption as subject to VAT, DST, and income tax consequences.
Real estate developers and corporations using property to redeem shares must treat the transaction as taxable when the transferred property is an ordinary asset. RMC No. 3-2014 modifies the earlier tax treatment of Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation’s conveyance of real properties to Bases Conversion and Development Authority, clarifying that the redemption transaction is subject to VAT, documentary stamp tax, and income tax consequences.
What Changed Under RMC No. 3-2014
RMC No. 3-2014 circularizes the modification of BIR Ruling DA (C-133) 431-2008. The earlier ruling had held that the transfer by Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation, or FBDC, of certain real properties to Bases Conversion and Development Authority, or BCDA, in redemption of preferred shares held by BCDA, was not subject to income tax, VAT, donor’s tax, and documentary stamp tax.
The modification changed that conclusion. The BIR ruled that the conveyance of real properties by FBDC in partial redemption of Preferred B shares owned by BCDA is subject to income tax, documentary stamp tax, and VAT. The key practical point is that a transfer of real property to redeem preferred shares may still be taxable even if it is not a regular sale to a customer and even if the transaction is structured as a share redemption rather than a conventional sale of land.
The issuance is particularly important for searches involving BIR tax on share redemption, VAT on transfer of real property, documentary stamp tax on real property conveyance, real estate developer ordinary assets, and deemed sale VAT Philippines.
Why the BIR Treated the Transfer as Taxable
The ruling involved the transfer of FBDC real properties to BCDA in redemption of preferred shares. The properties specifically discussed included TCT No. 2156-P with an area of 6,147 square meters and a portion of the lot covered by TCT No. 38167 with an area of 5,020 square meters. A related query also involved the possible application of the earlier ruling to another lot covered by TCT No. 2097-P with an area of 3,710 square meters.
The BIR’s analysis turned on the nature of the property and the tax treatment of redemption. On income tax, the BIR cited the rule under RR No. 6-2008 that when preferred shares are redeemed while the issuing corporation remains a going concern and is not dissolving or liquidating, capital gain or capital loss upon redemption is recognized based on the difference between the amount or value received at redemption and the cost of the preferred shares.
For the shareholder whose preferred shares are redeemed, any gain realized from the redemption is subject to the applicable income tax rules. In the case discussed, any gain realized by BCDA on the redemption of shares by FBDC was treated as subject to corporate income tax under Section 27(A) of the Tax Code of 1997 and consequently to creditable withholding tax under Section 57 of the same Code.
For the redeeming corporation, the BIR stated that FBDC was not subject to income tax on receipt of the shares surrendered by BCDA because the redeeming corporation does not realize gain or loss on the redemption of its own shares. The redeemed or reacquired shares are considered retired and no longer issuable.
VAT Treatment: Real Property Transferred in Redemption May Be a Deemed Sale
The most important operational rule in RMC No. 3-2014 concerns VAT. The BIR relied on RR No. 7-2003, which provides that, for a real estate developer, all real properties acquired by the developer, whether developed or undeveloped at the time of acquisition, all real properties held primarily for sale or lease to customers in the ordinary course of business, and all real properties used in the trade or business are considered ordinary assets.
Because FBDC was a real estate developer that owned substantial parcels of land, the real properties it acquired, held for sale or lease, or used in its trade or business were considered ordinary assets. The BIR emphasized that sales of real properties held primarily for sale to customers or held for lease in the ordinary course of trade or business are generally subject to VAT.
Even though the transfer to BCDA was not made in the regular conduct of FBDC’s trade or business and was not a transaction done with regularity, the BIR still treated the conveyance as subject to VAT because it was a transaction deemed sale. Section 106(B)(1) of the Tax Code covers the transfer, use, or consumption not in the course of business of goods or properties originally intended for sale or for use in the course of business.
The VAT rate specifically cited in the ruling is twelve percent (12%) under RR No. 16-2005, as amended, for every sale, barter, exchange, or transaction deemed sale of taxable goods or properties. For tax teams, the key takeaway is direct: moving ordinary real property out of the business through a redemption arrangement does not automatically avoid VAT.
How the VAT Base Is Computed
RMC No. 3-2014 provides a specific basis for determining the VAT base. For VAT on real property, gross selling price means the consideration stated in the sales document or the fair market value, whichever is higher.
The fair market value is whichever is higher between the zonal value determined by the Commissioner and the fair market value shown in the schedule of values of the provincial or city assessor, commonly reflected in the real property tax declaration. If there is no zonal value, the gross selling price refers to the market value shown in the latest real property tax declaration or the consideration, whichever is higher.
In this particular transaction, the BIR stated that the gross selling price is whichever is higher between the consideration received by FBDC, meaning the redemption price for the preferred shares, and the fair market value of the real property transferred, meaning the fair market value shown in the real property tax declarations issued by the Assessor’s Office or the zonal value, whichever is higher.
The ruling also confirms an important VAT-invoicing point: if the gross selling price is based on the zonal value or market value of the property, the zonal or market value is deemed inclusive of VAT. If the VAT is not billed separately, the selling price stated in the sales document is deemed inclusive of VAT.
Documentary Stamp Tax on the Conveyance
The BIR also ruled that documentary stamp tax applies to the conveyance of real property. Section 196 of the Tax Code imposes DST on conveyances, deeds, instruments, or writings whereby land, tenements, or other realty are granted, assigned, transferred, or otherwise conveyed to a purchaser or other designated person.
The DST base is the consideration contracted to be paid for the realty or its fair market value determined in accordance with Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher. Where one of the contracting parties is the Government, the tax is based on actual consideration. RMC No. 3-2014 does not state a separate special DST rate in the modified ruling, so taxpayers should apply the Tax Code and implementing rules applicable to the specific conveyance at the time of transaction.
Who Is Most Affected
The taxpayers most affected are real estate developers, corporations with substantial real property inventories, companies redeeming preferred shares through property transfers, shareholders receiving property as redemption proceeds, and tax teams structuring property-for-share transactions.
The ruling is also relevant to government counterparties, public-private project corporations, landholding companies, corporate secretaries, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel reviewing whether a transfer is merely a corporate restructuring or a taxable conveyance. The BIR’s position shows that labels are not controlling. If the property is an ordinary asset and was originally intended for sale or for use in the business, a transfer outside the regular course of business may still be treated as a VATable deemed sale.
Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 3-2014 is dated January 6, 2014 and circularizes the January 2, 2014 memorandum modifying BIR Ruling DA (C-133) 431-2008. It instructs all Revenue District Offices to be guided accordingly and to give the Circular wide publicity.
The issuance does not prescribe a new filing deadline, a new tax return, or a special transition period. Instead, its immediate compliance effect is interpretive: taxpayers involved in similar real property transfers should treat the transaction in accordance with the modified ruling and should not rely on the earlier conclusion that the redemption-related conveyance is exempt from income tax, VAT, and DST.
For pending or planned transactions, accountants should identify the nature of the property, determine whether the transferor is engaged in the real estate business, verify whether the property is an ordinary asset under RR No. 7-2003, compute VAT using the higher of consideration or fair market value, analyze DST on the conveyance, and determine income tax and creditable withholding tax consequences for the shareholder receiving the redemption value.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 3-2014 does not provide a separate penalty table, special surcharge, or new penalty rate. However, the practical exposure is significant because a taxpayer that treats a similar conveyance as non-taxable may face deficiency assessments for VAT, income tax, documentary stamp tax, and related withholding tax obligations, depending on the facts of the transaction and the applicable Tax Code provisions.
The most serious compliance risk is underpayment caused by using the wrong tax characterization. A redemption structure should not be evaluated only as a corporate law transaction. It must also be reviewed as a possible transfer of ordinary real property, a VAT deemed sale, a DST-taxable conveyance, and a taxable redemption event for the shareholder.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Tax Teams
Businesses planning to redeem preferred shares through a transfer of land should conduct a tax review before execution. The review should confirm whether the transferor is a real estate dealer, developer, or lessor; whether the property is classified as an ordinary asset; whether the transfer is a sale, barter, exchange, or transaction deemed sale; and whether the documents properly reflect the consideration and VAT treatment.
CFOs and corporate accountants should secure the latest zonal value, the latest real property tax declaration, and the agreed redemption price. The VAT base should be tested against all available values because the governing rule uses the higher amount. Corporate secretaries and legal teams should also ensure that board approvals, deeds, redemption documents, and tax filings are aligned.
For shareholders receiving property in redemption of preferred shares, tax teams should compute whether a capital gain or loss arises by comparing the amount or value received at redemption with the cost of the preferred shares. For corporate shareholders, RMC No. 3-2014 confirms that gain may be subject to corporate income tax and creditable withholding tax.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 3-2014 is a reminder that corporate restructuring, share redemption, and real property conveyancing must be reviewed together. A transaction that appears to be a redemption of shares may still trigger VAT, DST, income tax, and withholding tax issues when real property is used as consideration.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, real estate developers, landholding companies, CFOs, and in-house legal teams in structuring corporate transactions, reviewing BIR exposure, preparing tax-sensitive documentation, and responding to BIR assessments involving VAT, DST, income tax, and withholding tax. For assistance with BIR compliance, real property transfers, and tax-efficient corporate restructuring, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.