RMC No. 34-2014 clarifies that Best Evidence assessments are not automatically doubtful for BIR compromise settlement purposes.
Taxpayers facing jeopardy assessments, arbitrary assessments, or assessments issued under the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule cannot assume that the assessment may automatically be compromised on the ground of doubtful validity. RMC No. 34-2014 clarifies that, for compromise settlement purposes under Revenue Regulations No. 30-2002, a Best Evidence assessment remains prima facie correct and sufficient unless the taxpayer can show, through the surrounding facts and competent evidence, that there is reasonable doubt as to its legal or factual basis.
What RMC No. 34-2014 Changed
RMC No. 34-2014 clarifies the application of the ground of doubtful validity of assessment under Revenue Regulations No. 30-2002. The circular addresses a practical question often raised in BIR compromise settlement applications: whether an assessment resulting from a jeopardy assessment, an arbitrary assessment, or an assessment based on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule may automatically be treated as a doubtful assessment.
The answer is no. The BIR clarified that an assessment based on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule should not be automatically considered a doubtful assessment. Revenue officers must examine the surrounding circumstances that led to the issuance of the assessment. The mere fact that the BIR used the best evidence obtainable method does not, by itself, mean that the assessment lacks validity or may immediately qualify for compromise on the ground of reasonable doubt.
This matters because many taxpayers confronted with assessments issued after failure to submit books, accounting records, invoices, receipts, or supporting documents may attempt to argue that the assessment is doubtful simply because the BIR relied on available third-party information, presumptions, or other obtainable evidence. RMC No. 34-2014 makes clear that this is not enough. If the taxpayer’s own failure to present required documents forced the BIR to use the best evidence obtainable method, the resulting assessment is presumed prima facie correct and sufficient for all legal purposes.
Who Is Most Affected
RMC No. 34-2014 is especially important for taxpayers with delinquent accounts or disputed assessments who are considering a compromise settlement with the BIR. This includes corporations, SMEs, sole proprietors, professionals, withholding agents, and other taxpayers who received assessments after failing to comply with audit and investigation requirements.
The circular is also significant for CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel handling BIR audits where the company was unable to produce complete books of accounts, invoices, receipts, schedules, contracts, or other documents requested by revenue officers. In such cases, the BIR may issue an assessment without the benefit of complete records, or may rely on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule to determine tax liability.
Businesses searching for guidance on BIR compromise settlement, doubtful validity of assessment, best evidence obtainable rule, jeopardy assessment, and RR No. 30-2002 should treat RMC No. 34-2014 as a warning: compromise is not automatic merely because the assessment was computed using indirect or incomplete evidence.
Key Rule on Doubtful Validity of Assessment
Revenue Regulations No. 30-2002 recognizes two grounds for compromise settlement under Section 204(A) of the Tax Code: financial incapacity and doubtful validity of the assessment. RMC No. 34-2014 deals with the second ground.
Under RR No. 30-2002, an offer to compromise a delinquent account or disputed assessment on the ground of reasonable doubt as to the validity of the assessment may be accepted in specific situations. These include where the delinquent account or disputed assessment resulted from a jeopardy assessment, where the assessment appears arbitrary in nature and seems based on presumptions with reason to believe that it lacks legal or factual basis, or where the assessment was made based on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule and there is reason to believe that it can be disputed by sufficient and competent evidence.
RMC No. 34-2014 clarifies the limitation on that rule. For Best Evidence assessments, there must still be a reason to believe that the assessment can be disputed by sufficient and competent evidence. The taxpayer must show more than the label or method used by the BIR. The taxpayer must point to facts, records, or legal grounds showing that the assessment is genuinely doubtful.
What Counts as a Jeopardy Assessment
RMC No. 34-2014 repeats the definition of jeopardy assessment under RR No. 30-2002. A jeopardy assessment refers to a tax assessment made without the benefit of complete or partial audit by an authorized revenue officer who has reason to believe that assessment and collection of deficiency tax will be jeopardized by delay.
The regulation identifies examples of taxpayer conduct that may lead to this situation, including failure to comply with audit and investigation requirements, failure to present books of accounts or pertinent records, and failure to substantiate deductions, exemptions, or tax credits claimed in the return.
For businesses, this means that failure to cooperate in a BIR audit can have two consequences. First, the BIR may issue an assessment using the evidence available to it. Second, if the taxpayer later seeks a compromise settlement, the taxpayer may not automatically rely on the BIR’s use of indirect evidence as proof that the assessment is doubtful.
Best Evidence Obtainable Rule: No Automatic Doubtful Assessment
The most important rule in RMC No. 34-2014 is that a Best Evidence assessment is not automatically a doubtful assessment. The BIR emphasized that the circumstances surrounding the assessment must be thoroughly evaluated. The circular specifically refers to assessments based on issuances such as RMC No. 23-2000 and RMC No. 99-2010 as examples of assessments whose circumstances should be scrutinized.
The reason is straightforward: where the taxpayer failed to present or submit the documents needed to determine tax liability, the BIR becomes compelled to apply the best evidence obtainable method to recover unpaid taxes due the government. In that situation, the assessment is not treated as defective merely because it was based on the best evidence available to the BIR.
RMC No. 34-2014 therefore places the burden back on the taxpayer to produce sufficient and competent evidence if it wants to dispute the assessment or use doubtful validity as the ground for compromise settlement. A general allegation that the assessment is arbitrary, presumptive, or based on incomplete information will likely be insufficient without supporting records and legal argument.
Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 34-2014 does not create a new filing deadline, tax rate, threshold, or payment schedule. Its compliance impact is procedural and evidentiary. Taxpayers involved in BIR audits must comply with audit and investigation requirements, preserve and present books of accounts and pertinent records, and substantiate deductions, exemptions, and credits claimed in their tax returns.
For taxpayers seeking compromise settlement under RR No. 30-2002, the immediate compliance requirement is to prepare evidence showing why the assessment is doubtful. If the taxpayer relies on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule as part of its compromise position, it must be ready to show that the assessment can be disputed by sufficient and competent evidence.
The relevant date of RMC No. 34-2014 is April 1, 2014. From that date, taxpayers and revenue officers were guided by the clarification that Best Evidence assessments must be evaluated based on their surrounding circumstances and are not automatically compromisable as doubtful assessments.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 34-2014 does not prescribe a separate penalty. However, the risks for taxpayers are substantial. A taxpayer who fails to submit books and supporting documents may face an assessment based on the best evidence obtainable by the BIR. Once issued, that assessment is presumed prima facie correct and sufficient for all legal purposes.
This presumption can make it harder for the taxpayer to obtain a compromise settlement on the ground of doubtful validity. It can also weaken the taxpayer’s position in administrative protest, collection proceedings, or litigation if the taxpayer cannot later produce competent evidence to refute the assessment.
For corporate officers and finance teams, the practical risk is that poor audit response management can convert a documentation problem into a tax assessment problem. Missing records, delayed submissions, unsupported deductions, and incomplete reconciliations may give the BIR grounds to rely on alternative evidence and may prevent the taxpayer from later arguing that the assessment is automatically doubtful.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Tax Teams
Businesses should treat RMC No. 34-2014 as a reminder that document control is a tax defense tool. The first step is to ensure that books of accounts, invoices, receipts, contracts, schedules, withholding tax records, VAT records, payroll records, and supporting documents are complete and readily retrievable during a BIR audit.
Second, companies should respond promptly and carefully to BIR requests for documents. If certain records are unavailable, the company should document the reason and consider submitting alternative competent evidence. Silence, delay, or incomplete submissions can lead the BIR to use the best evidence obtainable method.
Third, taxpayers considering compromise settlement should not rely on broad arguments that the assessment is arbitrary or presumptive. The compromise application should identify the specific factual or legal defects in the assessment and attach evidence showing why the assessment can be disputed. This may include reconciliations, ledgers, invoices, audited financial statements, tax returns, third-party confirmations, legal authorities, and explanations of how the BIR computation overstated the tax liability.
Fourth, management should involve tax counsel early. Once an assessment is issued and presumed correct, the taxpayer’s options may narrow. Early review can help determine whether the better route is protest, compromise based on doubtful validity, compromise based on financial incapacity, or another lawful remedy.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 34-2014 is important because it affects how businesses defend themselves when the BIR issues assessments after incomplete audit submissions or reliance on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule. The key lesson is that taxpayers must build an evidence-based defense. A compromise settlement on doubtful validity must be supported by concrete legal and factual grounds, not merely by the fact that the BIR used indirect or available evidence.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in BIR audits, deficiency tax assessments, compromise settlement applications, tax protest strategy, and documentation review. For assistance with BIR compromise settlement, doubtful validity of assessment, jeopardy assessment, or Best Evidence Obtainable Rule issues, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.