RMC No. 61-2014 revokes the ruling allowing creditable withholding taxes under RA 9480 tax amnesty, leaving withholding agents exposed to BIR assessment.

Withholding agents can no longer rely on the Tax Amnesty Program under Republic Act No. 9480 to extinguish creditable withholding tax liabilities. RMC No. 61-2014 revokes BIR Ruling No. DA (OSL-A1)001-2008 and clarifies that withholding taxes, including creditable withholding taxes, are outside the coverage of the 2007 Tax Amnesty Program. For businesses, CFOs, accountants, and tax managers, the practical consequence is immediate: unpaid or deficient withholding tax assessments remain collectible despite any tax amnesty position previously taken under the revoked ruling.

What Changed Under RMC No. 61-2014

RMC No. 61-2014 expressly revokes BIR Ruling No. DA (OSL-A1)001-2008 dated October 17, 2008. The revoked ruling had previously declared that creditable withholding taxes fell within the coverage of Republic Act No. 9480, otherwise known as the tax amnesty law covering taxable year 2005 and prior years. That earlier interpretation benefited taxpayers who argued that deficiency creditable withholding tax assessments could be nullified through availment of the Tax Amnesty Program.

The BIR reversed that position. RMC No. 61-2014 states that the earlier ruling was an erroneous interpretation of Republic Act No. 9480. The circular explains that withholding agents, with respect to their withholding tax liabilities, are excluded from the tax amnesty. It further emphasizes that RMC No. 69-2007 already identified two kinds of taxes not covered by the Tax Amnesty Program: withholding taxes, and taxes passed-on and already collected from customers for remittance to the BIR.

The most important compliance takeaway is that creditable withholding taxes are treated as withholding taxes for purposes of the exclusion. The BIR rejected the view that only final withholding taxes are excluded. Therefore, a taxpayer assessed as a withholding agent for failure to withhold creditable withholding tax cannot use Republic Act No. 9480 as a shield against assessment or collection.

Why Creditable Withholding Taxes Are Outside the Tax Amnesty Program

The circular anchors its ruling on Section 8 of Republic Act No. 9480, which excludes withholding agents with respect to their withholding tax liabilities. The BIR also relies on RMC No. 69-2007 and RMC No. 19-2008, which describe who may avail of the Tax Amnesty Program and which taxes are covered. Under those issuances, individuals, estates and trusts, corporations, cooperatives, tax-exempt entities that became taxable as of December 31, 2005, other juridical entities including partnerships, and fiscal year taxpayers could generally avail of the program for covered national internal revenue taxes for 2005 and prior years. However, withholding agents with respect to withholding tax liabilities were expressly excepted.

RMC No. 61-2014 stresses that the word and in the phrase referring to withholding taxes and taxes passed-on and already collected does not mean that only taxes satisfying both descriptions are excluded. The BIR interprets the phrase as identifying two separate exclusions. First, withholding taxes are excluded. Second, taxes passed-on and already collected from customers for remittance to the BIR are also excluded. This interpretation is important for businesses searching for guidance on creditable withholding tax amnesty, BIR tax amnesty withholding tax liabilities, and whether expanded withholding tax can be covered by tax amnesty.

The circular also cites the distinction recognized in jurisprudence between indirect taxes, such as VAT and excise tax, and withholding taxes. In indirect taxes, the burden may be passed on to another person. In withholding taxes, the statutory taxpayer is the withholding agent, which merely deducts and remits the tax due from payments made to income recipients. Because of this distinction, the BIR states that the treatment of passed-on indirect taxes cannot be used to deem withholding tax deficiencies as covered by the tax amnesty.

Who Is Most Affected

RMC No. 61-2014 directly affects withholding agents. This includes corporations, large taxpayers, employers, payors of professional fees, service fees, rentals, commissions, income payments subject to expanded withholding tax, and businesses required to withhold and remit taxes under the National Internal Revenue Code and related BIR regulations.

The circular is particularly relevant to companies with pending or potential deficiency withholding tax assessments for taxable year 2005 and prior years where a tax amnesty defense was raised or considered. It also matters to companies that relied on BIR Ruling No. DA (OSL-A1)001-2008 in taking the position that creditable withholding tax deficiencies were wiped out by Republic Act No. 9480. After RMC No. 61-2014, that reliance is no longer supported by the BIR.

Tax practitioners, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel should also review old assessments, protest files, compromise discussions, and audit defense memoranda involving creditable withholding tax, expanded withholding tax, or withholding agent liabilities. The circular changes the risk analysis for any case where the tax amnesty law was invoked against a deficiency withholding tax assessment.

Key Compliance Requirements and Effective Date

RMC No. 61-2014 was issued on July 30, 2014. From a compliance standpoint, the circular instructs all internal revenue officials, employees, and concerned parties to be guided accordingly and to give the circular wide publicity. The operational effect is that BIR Ruling No. DA (OSL-A1)001-2008 can no longer be relied upon to support a claim that creditable withholding tax liabilities fall under Republic Act No. 9480.

Businesses should treat withholding tax liabilities separately from income tax, estate tax, donor’s tax, capital gains tax, value-added tax, other percentage taxes, excise tax, and documentary stamp tax liabilities that may have been covered by the Tax Amnesty Program, subject to the specific rules then applicable. The key point is that withholding tax liabilities of withholding agents are excluded. The circular does not create a new tax rate, threshold, or filing deadline, but it does remove a previously relied-upon BIR ruling as legal basis for tax amnesty coverage of creditable withholding tax assessments.

Penalties and Consequences of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 61-2014 does not prescribe a new penalty schedule. Its consequence is more direct: deficiency creditable withholding tax assessments are not extinguished by the Tax Amnesty Program. The BIR explains that the assessment of deficiency creditable withholding tax is not merely a penalty for failure to withhold. It is a tax liability imposed on the withholding agent under the withholding tax system.

Accordingly, if a business failed to withhold the required creditable withholding tax, or withheld but failed to remit the tax to the BIR, the tax amnesty under Republic Act No. 9480 does not provide immunity. Any applicable basic tax, surcharge, interest, compromise penalty, or other statutory additions must be evaluated under the National Internal Revenue Code and the relevant assessment documents. The circular’s clear position is that the amnesty defense is unavailable for these withholding tax liabilities.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Tax Teams

Companies should first identify whether they have open, pending, or archived BIR assessments involving creditable withholding tax, expanded withholding tax, final withholding tax, or other withholding tax liabilities. If a position paper, protest, request for reconsideration, compromise proposal, or legal memorandum relied on BIR Ruling No. DA (OSL-A1)001-2008, that position should be revisited in light of RMC No. 61-2014.

Second, businesses should separate tax amnesty issues from withholding tax compliance issues. The fact that a taxpayer availed of the Tax Amnesty Program for other national internal revenue taxes does not automatically protect the same taxpayer from liability as a withholding agent. Accountants should review whether income payments were properly subjected to withholding, whether tax was remitted on time, and whether certificates and returns support the company’s position.

Third, CFOs and tax managers should reassess reserve positions for pending BIR cases involving withholding tax amnesty Philippines, RMC 61-2014 creditable withholding tax, RA 9480 tax amnesty withholding agents, BIR ruling DA OSL-A1 001-2008 revoked, and expanded withholding tax amnesty coverage. These are the search terms and audit issues most likely to arise when old assessments are reactivated or when the BIR challenges a taxpayer’s reliance on the revoked ruling.

Finally, legal counsel should review whether the assessment itself remains procedurally valid, whether the BIR observed due process, whether prescription issues exist, and whether the taxpayer has defenses apart from the rejected tax amnesty theory. RMC No. 61-2014 removes one defense, but it does not automatically cure every assessment defect or eliminate other remedies available under tax law.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 61-2014 is a reminder that BIR rulings can be reversed and that withholding tax liabilities require careful, document-based defense. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, executives, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR assessments, withholding tax exposure, tax amnesty positions, protest strategy, settlement options, and compliance remediation.

If your company is facing a creditable withholding tax assessment, an expanded withholding tax audit, or a disputed BIR position involving Republic Act No. 9480, our Makati-based tax and business law team can help evaluate your legal risks and next steps. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance, tax assessments, and withholding tax disputes.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *