Land beside NLEX did not create a right to direct expressway access; safety fencing was police power, not compensable taking.

Property beside a toll road does not automatically carry a right to open direct access to the expressway, and a safety fence that restricts entry may be treated as a valid police-power regulation rather than a compensable taking. For landowners, developers, and businesses near highways, the ruling is a reminder that location beside a major road is not the same as a legal entitlement to use that road as a private access point.

The Doctrine: Expressway Safety Restrictions Are Not Always Eminent Domain

The central doctrine may be called the limited-access police power rule. When the government restricts access to a tollway or limited-access highway to protect traffic flow and public safety, the restriction may be upheld as an exercise of police power. If the property itself is not taken and devoted to public use, the owner may not be entitled to just compensation merely because the restriction reduces the property’s commercial convenience or limits its direct connection to the expressway.

This distinction matters because eminent domain and police power lead to very different remedies. Eminent domain generally requires just compensation because private property is taken for public use. Police power, by contrast, allows reasonable regulation to promote public welfare, safety, and order, usually without compensation, provided constitutional limits such as due process and equal protection are respected.

Background: A Landowner Sought Direct Access to the North Luzon Expressway

Hermano Oil Manufacturing & Sugar Corporation owned land at the right side of the Sta. Rita Exit of the North Luzon Expressway in Guiguinto, Bulacan. The property was bounded by an access fence along the expressway. Hermano asked the Toll Regulatory Board for an easement of right of way, claiming that the fence deprived it of the enjoyment and possession of its property by blocking entry to and exit from the NLEX.

The TRB denied the request, citing the Limited Access Highway Act and warning that allowing the easement could affect the rehabilitation and improvement of NLEX interchanges and create operational traffic conflicts. Hermano then filed a complaint for specific performance, right of way, injunction, damages, and, alternatively, just compensation. The case reached the Supreme Court in Hermano Oil Manufacturing & Sugar Corporation v. Toll Regulatory Board (G.R. No. 167290).

Why the Lower Courts Could Not Order the Fence Removed

The Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of the complaint. One major reason was jurisdictional: the case sought to restrain acts connected with the operation and improvement of a government infrastructure project. Under Presidential Decree No. 1818, as amended by Republic Act No. 8975, lower courts generally cannot issue temporary restraining orders or injunctions against government infrastructure projects. Only the Supreme Court may issue such relief in the covered cases, subject to the statutory requirements.

The Court viewed the maintenance of safety measures, including the access fence, as part of the continuous improvement and development of the NLEX. Because Hermano’s requested relief would effectively compel access through the fence and interfere with the implementation or operation of the tollway project, the Regional Trial Court could not grant that relief without exceeding its jurisdiction.

Sovereign Immunity Protected Government Agencies, But Not PNCC

The Court also discussed sovereign immunity. It held that the TRB and DPWH, as unincorporated government agencies performing governmental or public functions, could invoke immunity from suit. Engr. Jaime Dumlao, Jr., who acted as an agent of the TRB in the matter, was likewise protected in his official capacity.

The ruling is more nuanced as to PNCC. The Court rejected the view that PNCC enjoyed sovereign immunity merely because the government owned a controlling stake. PNCC was created under the Corporation Code and remained essentially a private corporation for immunity purposes. The doctrine of sovereign immunity therefore did not apply to PNCC. Still, that did not save Hermano’s complaint because the action failed on jurisdictional and substantive grounds.

No Automatic Easement Over a Limited-Access Highway

The Court treated the NLEX as a special road governed by limited-access rules. A tollway is not an ordinary road. It is designed for faster and safer movement of traffic, and its use requires close regulation. Restrictions that would be unreasonable on a normal street may be valid when imposed on an expressway because unrestricted entry and exit points can create traffic conflicts and safety risks.

Hermano argued that neighboring properties had been given access and that denial of access violated equal protection. The Court disagreed. It found a valid and reasonable classification because some adjacent properties provided ancillary services to motorists, such as gasoline stations and food stores. Equal protection does not require identical treatment of every property beside an expressway. A classification based on practical convenience and common knowledge may be valid even if it is not mathematically perfect.

Why There Was No Compensable Taking

The most important practical holding is that the access fence did not amount to compensable taking. The property was not seized, transferred, or devoted to public use. Instead, it was subjected to a restraint intended to protect motorists using the NLEX. Because the Court characterized the fence as a valid safety regulation under police power, Hermano was not entitled to just compensation.

For property owners, this means that a loss of convenience, reduced commercial potential, or inability to connect directly to an expressway will not automatically support an expropriation claim. The legal question is not simply whether the owner suffered economic disadvantage. The question is whether the government actually took property for public use, or merely imposed a reasonable restriction to protect public safety and regulate a special public facility.

What This Means for Landowners and Businesses Near Toll Roads

Businesses that buy or develop land near expressways should conduct legal and technical due diligence before assuming that the property can be used as a direct entry or exit point. A title, roadside location, or commercial plan does not by itself create a right of way into a limited-access facility. Access approvals are regulatory matters, and denial may be upheld where traffic safety, tollway operations, or infrastructure development would be affected.

The ruling also affects litigation strategy. A complaint filed in a trial court asking for an injunction against a government infrastructure project may fail at the threshold. A claimant must carefully identify the proper remedy, the proper forum, and the specific legal right allegedly violated. Where the grievance involves a regulatory denial rather than a physical taking, the case must be framed with precision and supported by facts showing arbitrariness, discrimination, grave abuse, or a true compensable taking.

Practical Takeaway

The Supreme Court’s message is clear: property rights are protected, but they are not absolute. When private land borders a limited-access expressway, public safety and traffic regulation may justify restrictions on direct access. Unless the property is actually taken for public use, the owner may have no right to compensation merely because the regulation reduces the property’s usefulness or commercial value.

For landowners, developers, tollway operators, and businesses affected by infrastructure projects, early legal review is essential. The proper analysis should cover title history, access rights, easements, zoning, regulatory approvals, expropriation issues, and the limits of injunctive relief against government projects.

Need Advice on Property Rights, Government Projects, or Infrastructure Disputes?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises property owners, corporations, contractors, and regulated businesses on disputes involving land access, government infrastructure, expropriation, easements, injunctions, and administrative action. If your property or business is affected by a highway, tollway, right-of-way project, or government restriction, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com for focused legal guidance before filing suit or responding to government action.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *