RMC No. 40-2015 clarifies when sugar cooperatives qualify as producers for advance VAT and Percentage Tax exemption on sugar withdrawals.

Agricultural cooperatives dealing in sugar must verify immediately whether they qualify as the producer of the sugar before claiming exemption from advance VAT or Percentage Tax on withdrawals for sale to non-members or to another agricultural cooperative. RMC No. 40-2015 makes clear that cooperative registration alone is not enough. To avoid advance business tax at the sugar refinery or mill, the cooperative must satisfy the producer test: it must be the tiller, through its members, of land it owns or leases, and it must incur the cost of agricultural production and produce the sugar cane to be refined.

What RMC No. 40-2015 Changed

RMC No. 40-2015 clarified the nature and extent of an agricultural cooperative being treated as the producer of sugar for purposes of exemption from advance VAT and Percentage Tax. The ruling is important because Revenue Regulations No. 8-2015 already provided that withdrawals of sugar for sale to non-members are subject to advance VAT or Percentage Tax if the agricultural cooperative is not the producer of the sugar. RMC No. 40-2015 explains when an agricultural cooperative may be considered the producer and when it is merely acting as a buyer, trader, transferee, or intermediary.

The key rule is direct: a duly registered agricultural cooperative is considered the producer of sugar only if two requisites are present. First, it must be the tiller, through its members, of the land it owns or leases. Second, it must incur the cost of agricultural production of the sugar and produce the sugar cane to be refined. These requisites must concur. If either requirement is absent, the cooperative cannot be treated as the producer of sugar for this exemption.

This clarification matters because Section 109(1)(L) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, exempts from VAT the sale by agricultural cooperatives duly registered with the Cooperative Development Authority of their produce, whether in original state or processed form, to non-members. The phrase that matters is “of their produce.” RMC No. 40-2015 confirms that, for sugar, the cooperative must be able to show that the sugar is truly its produce, not merely sugar purchased from planters or transferred to the cooperative by assignment.

Who Is Most Affected

The taxpayers most affected are CDA-registered agricultural cooperatives engaged in sugar production, sugar milling withdrawals, refined sugar transactions, and sales of sugar to non-members or to other agricultural cooperatives. The ruling is especially relevant to cooperatives operating in the sugar industry that rely on VAT exemption for agricultural cooperative sales and advance VAT exemption for sugar withdrawals from a refinery or mill.

It also affects sugar planters who are members of cooperatives, sugar mills and refineries that release sugar upon withdrawal, cooperative accountants, CFOs, tax managers, and buyers who transact with agricultural cooperatives. A cooperative that cannot document that it is the producer may face advance VAT or Percentage Tax at the point of withdrawal, which directly affects cash flow, pricing, and the tax treatment of subsequent sales.

Businesses searching for “RMC 40-2015 agricultural cooperative sugar producer,” “advance VAT on sugar withdrawals,” “percentage tax sugar cooperative exemption,” “CDA cooperative VAT exemption sugar,” or “RR 8-2015 sugar advance VAT” should focus on the producer test and not merely on whether the seller is a registered cooperative.

Key Compliance Rule: The Two Requisites Must Both Be Present

RMC No. 40-2015 adopts the concept of a producer’s cooperative under the Cooperative Code of 2008 and the related Joint Rules and Regulations implementing Articles 60, 61, and 144 of Republic Act No. 9520. Under that framework, a producer’s cooperative undertakes joint production, whether agricultural or industrial, and is formed and operated by its members to undertake the production and processing of raw materials or goods produced by its members into finished or processed products for sale by the cooperative to members and non-members.

For sugar transactions, the BIR’s clarification is specific. A cooperative is the producer if it is the tiller, through its members, of land that it owns or leases. This recognizes that the cooperative may act through its members in the actual tilling of the land, consistent with the nature of a cooperative. However, this alone is not sufficient.

The cooperative must also incur the cost of agricultural production of the sugar and produce the sugar cane to be refined. This requirement prevents a cooperative from claiming producer status where it merely purchases sugar or sugar cane from planters, whether members or non-members, or receives sugar through assignment without undertaking the underlying production activity and production cost.

The ruling expressly states that the requisites must concur. Therefore, a cooperative that tills land through its members but does not incur the cost of agricultural production may fail the test. Likewise, a cooperative that pays certain costs but is not the tiller, through its members, of land it owns or leases may also fail the test. The exemption depends on satisfying both elements together.

What Happens If the Cooperative Is Not the Producer

If the agricultural cooperative is not the producer of the sugar, its withdrawals of sugar for sale to non-members or to another agricultural cooperative are subject to advance VAT or Percentage Tax. This is the immediate tax consequence that cooperatives and sugar mills must apply at the point of withdrawal from the sugar refinery or mill.

RMC No. 40-2015 also confirms the treatment under RR No. 8-2015: if the cooperative is not an agricultural producer but merely purchases the sugar from planters, whether members or non-members, or if the sugar is transferred to the cooperative through assignment, its sale of the resulting sugar to another agricultural cooperative is subject to VAT. Its withdrawals from the sugar refinery or mill will be allowed only upon payment of the advance VAT or Percentage Tax.

This is a significant distinction. Sales by agricultural cooperatives to non-members may be exempt from VAT only if the producer of the agricultural products sold is the cooperative itself. If the cooperative is not the producer, such as where it is effectively acting as a trader, only sales to its members are covered by the exemption described in the Joint Rules and Regulations. For sales to non-members, the cooperative must be able to prove producer status.

Effective Date and Deadline

RMC No. 40-2015 is dated July 15, 2015 and states that it takes effect immediately. Although the issuance is clarificatory, it has practical operational impact for sugar withdrawals and cooperative sales because it directs revenue officers and concerned taxpayers to apply the producer test when determining whether advance VAT or Percentage Tax is due.

There is no grace period stated in RMC No. 40-2015. Cooperatives and sugar industry participants should therefore treat the rule as immediately applicable to covered withdrawals and sales from the date of issuance. The practical compliance deadline is before the sugar is withdrawn from the refinery or mill and before the cooperative claims exemption on sales to non-members or to another agricultural cooperative.

Penalties and Tax Risk for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 40-2015 does not create a new specific penalty schedule. However, the tax risk is clear: if a cooperative claims exemption but fails the producer test, its withdrawals of sugar for sale to non-members or another agricultural cooperative are subject to advance VAT or Percentage Tax. Failure to pay the proper tax may expose the taxpayer to the usual consequences under the National Internal Revenue Code, including assessment of deficiency taxes and applicable additions imposed by law.

The more immediate commercial risk is that the sugar withdrawal may not be allowed without payment of the advance VAT or Percentage Tax where the cooperative does not qualify as the producer. This can affect delivery timelines, buyer commitments, working capital, and the cooperative’s pricing assumptions. Cooperatives should avoid treating the exemption as automatic merely because they are registered with the CDA.

Practical Steps for Agricultural Cooperatives and Sugar Businesses

First, confirm whether the cooperative’s sugar transactions involve sales to members, sales to non-members, or sales to another agricultural cooperative. RMC No. 40-2015 is most critical where the cooperative claims exemption for sugar withdrawals intended for sale to non-members or to another agricultural cooperative.

Second, document the land basis for production. The cooperative should maintain records showing that the land is owned or leased by the cooperative and that it is tilled through its members. Documents may include land titles, lease contracts, member production records, farm management documents, and internal cooperative records showing member participation in production.

Third, document the production cost requirement. The cooperative should be able to show that it incurred the cost of agricultural production of the sugar. This may include records of farm inputs, labor, cultivation, planting, harvesting, hauling, and related expenses. The documentation should support the position that the cooperative produced the sugar cane to be refined, instead of merely purchasing or receiving sugar from another person.

Fourth, review contracts with planters and members. If the arrangement is structured as a purchase of sugar or sugar cane from planters, or as an assignment of sugar to the cooperative, the cooperative may not qualify as the producer for purposes of the advance VAT or Percentage Tax exemption. The legal form and accounting treatment should align with the actual production arrangement.

Fifth, coordinate with the sugar mill or refinery before withdrawal. Since the tax consequence arises at withdrawal, cooperatives should ensure that their supporting documents are ready before the withdrawal process. Tax managers should not wait until audit to assemble proof of producer status.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 40-2015 is a reminder that tax exemptions for agricultural cooperatives must be supported by substance, documentation, and proper transaction structuring. For sugar cooperatives, the decisive question is not simply whether the cooperative is CDA-registered, but whether it can prove that it is the producer of the sugar under the BIR’s two-part test.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists agricultural cooperatives, sugar businesses, corporate taxpayers, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing VAT exemption positions, advance VAT exposure, Percentage Tax issues, cooperative documentation, and BIR audit risks. For guidance on RMC No. 40-2015, RR No. 8-2015, cooperative tax exemptions, and sugar industry tax compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *