Security guards relieved from posts without new assignments may be illegally dismissed, but corporate officers are not personally liable absent bad faith.
Security guards and other project- or client-assigned workers are not deemed to have abandoned their jobs merely because their last post was withdrawn. When an employer relieves workers from an assignment but fails to give them a new post, fails to prove a valid cause for separation, and fails to serve the required termination notices, the law may treat the situation as illegal dismissal.
Why This Ruling Matters to Workers and Employers
For employees, the ruling is important because it recognizes a practical reality: a worker who is removed from a post and then left without work may be effectively dismissed even if the employer avoids using the word termination. This is especially relevant to security guards, janitorial workers, manpower agency personnel, and other employees whose day-to-day work depends on deployment to client sites.
For employers and service contractors, the case is a reminder that management prerogative over assignments has limits. A company may transfer employees, recall them from a client, or relieve them from a post for legitimate business reasons. But it must still show what happened afterward. If the employer claims that the worker abandoned employment, it must prove both unjustified failure to report and a clear intention to sever the employment relationship.
Background: Security Guards Relieved After Client Assignments
Peopleās Security, Inc. employed Julius Flores and Esteban Tapiru as security guards. They had been assigned to facilities of Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company under a security services agreement. After that agreement ended, the guards were recalled and later assigned to other client facilities, including a warehouse in Sta. Ana, Manila and Trinity Collegeās Elementary Department in Quezon City.
On January 13, 2003, the guards were relieved from their assignments under a special order issued by the companyās operations manager. The guards later claimed that they repeatedly reported to the company office for possible reassignment, but the company refused to give them any new assignment. In September 2005, they filed complaints for illegal dismissal and related monetary claims against the security agency and its president (G.R. No. 211312, December 5, 2016).
PEOPLE’S SECURITY, INC. AND NESā¦
The Employerās Defense: No Dismissal, Only Relief From Assignment
The security agency argued that the guards were not dismissed. It claimed they were merely relieved from a particular post because of performance concerns and that they stopped reporting after leaving the warehouse assignment. On that theory, the company characterized the guardsā conduct as abandonment or voluntary severance of employment.
The Supreme Court rejected that position. The Court emphasized that in termination cases, the employer carries the burden of proving that the dismissal was valid. That burden cannot be met by simply denying that any dismissal happened. If the employee was relieved from a post and no new assignment was actually given, the employer must be able to show a clear and lawful basis for the resulting loss of work.
The Doctrine: Relief From Post Is Not Abandonment Without Proof of Intent to Quit
The central doctrine may be called the no-assignment-as-dismissal rule. When a worker is removed from an assignment and the employer fails to provide another assignment or prove that the worker refused one, the employer cannot easily escape liability by saying the worker abandoned the job.
The Court restated the settled test for abandonment. First, the employee must have failed to report for work or must have been absent without valid or justifiable reason. Second, there must be a clear intention to sever the employer-employee relationship, shown through overt acts. Both elements must be present. Abandonment is a matter of intention and cannot be lightly inferred from uncertain or equivocal conduct.
Here, the employer failed to prove that Flores and Tapiru were given new assignments or that they were properly informed of any such assignments. The guardsā filing of an illegal dismissal case also contradicted the idea that they intended to sever the employment relationship. A worker who seeks reinstatement or relief for illegal dismissal is generally not acting like someone who freely walked away from employment.
Due Process Still Matters: The Two-Notice Rule
The Court also found that the employer failed to comply with procedural due process. Philippine labor law requires two written notices before a valid dismissal for just cause. The first notice must specify the grounds for termination and give the employee a reasonable opportunity to explain. The second notice must inform the employee that, after considering the circumstances, grounds have been established to justify termination.
No written notice was sent informing the guards that they were being terminated for abandonment. This failure placed the legality of the dismissal in serious doubt and supported the finding of illegal dismissal. The ruling therefore reinforces that even where an employer believes it has a substantive ground, it must still follow the required process.
Filing Almost Three Years Later Was Still Timely
The employer also argued that the delay in filing the illegal dismissal complaint weakened the guardsā claim. The Supreme Court disagreed. Illegal dismissal actions are subject to a four-year prescriptive period under Article 1146 of the Civil Code, because they involve injury to the rights of the employee. The guards were relieved on January 13, 2003 and filed their complaints in September 2005. Their claims were therefore filed within the allowable period.
This part of the ruling matters to employees who hesitate before filing a labor case. Delay may affect evidence or credibility depending on the facts, but it does not automatically defeat an illegal dismissal claim if the complaint is filed within the prescriptive period.
Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable
The Court affirmed liability against the security agency but modified the ruling as to its president, Nestor Racho. It held that a corporation has a personality separate from its officers, directors, and owners. Corporate officers may be held solidarily liable only in exceptional circumstances, such as when they acted in bad faith, assented to patently unlawful acts, committed gross negligence, acquired conflicting personal interests, or used the corporate fiction to defeat public convenience, justify wrong, protect fraud, or defend crime.
The employees failed to prove that Racho personally used the corporation to commit wrongdoing or acted with the kind of malice or bad faith required for personal liability. As a result, only the corporation remained responsible for the monetary awards. This is a significant reminder that illegal dismissal by a corporation does not, by itself, automatically pierce the corporate veil.
Practical Lessons for Security Agencies, Contractors, and Employees
For security agencies and manpower contractors, the lesson is straightforward: document assignments, recalls, transfers, and notices carefully. If a guard or deployed worker is relieved from a client site, the company should clearly communicate the next assignment, document any refusal, and comply with due process before treating the employee as having abandoned work.
For employees, the ruling confirms that being left floating without a real assignment may support an illegal dismissal claim, especially where the employer cannot prove that a new post was offered. Workers should preserve evidence of reporting for work, requests for reassignment, text messages, letters, gate logs, and other proof showing that they did not intend to abandon employment.
For company officers, the ruling offers a separate but equally important point. Personal liability is not presumed merely because an officer holds a high position. However, officers who directly participate in unlawful acts, act in bad faith, or misuse the corporation may still face solidary liability.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, employees, security agencies, contractors, and corporate officers in labor disputes, illegal dismissal cases, deployment issues, and corporate liability concerns. If your business is facing an NLRC complaint, or if you were removed from work without a clear assignment or notice, our litigation and labor law team can help evaluate the facts, preserve evidence, and develop a strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Makati-based full-service law firm on labor, employment, and corporate litigation matters.