RMC No. 21-2017 stops RDO personnel from requiring AABs to submit BCS copies and tax returns when reporting returned or dishonored checks.
Authorized Agent Banks handling returned or dishonored tax payment checks should not be required by Revenue District Office personnel to submit copies of the Batch Control Sheet and the related tax returns or forms merely for the BIR to acknowledge receipt of dishonored checks. RMC No. 21-2017 matters now because it removes an unnecessary document-request layer in the reporting of dishonored check transactions and clarifies what RDO personnel may demand when receiving the Report of Returned/Dishonored Checks, BIR Form No. 12.58.
What RMC No. 21-2017 Changed
RMC No. 21-2017 addresses a specific operational issue between Revenue District Offices and Authorized Agent Banks. Some RDO personnel had reportedly been requiring AABs to submit copies of the Batch Control Sheet and the relevant tax returns or forms with dishonored check transactions before acknowledging receipt of the original copies of dishonored checks.
The circular directs RDO personnel to refrain from requiring those documents when acknowledging receipt of the Report of Returned/Dishonored Checks, BIR Form No. 12.58. The reason is practical and administrative: the Batch Control Sheet and the tax returns or forms are already regularly retrieved by authorized personnel of the concerned RDO under Revenue Memorandum Order No. 32-2000.
In plain terms, the BIR clarified that RDO personnel should not duplicate document collection from AABs where the documents are already subject to regular retrieval through the existing BIR procedure. The key compliance phrase for banks and tax departments is this: for returned or dishonored checks received by Authorized Agent Banks, the RDO should not require submission of BCS copies and tax returns or forms as a condition for acknowledging BIR Form No. 12.58.
Who Is Most Affected
The most directly affected parties are Authorized Agent Banks that receive tax payments by check and later encounter returned or dishonored checks. These banks are the entities that prepare and report dishonored check transactions to the BIR through the required reporting mechanism.
Revenue District Office personnel are also directly affected because RMC No. 21-2017 is addressed to all internal revenue officials, employees, and others concerned. The directive is operational: when acknowledging receipt of the Report of Returned/Dishonored Checks, BIR Form No. 12.58, RDO personnel must not require the AAB to submit copies of the Batch Control Sheet or the tax returns or forms with dishonored check transactions.
Taxpayers are indirectly affected. A taxpayer whose tax payment check is dishonored remains exposed to the tax consequences of a failed payment under applicable tax rules, but RMC No. 21-2017 is not primarily about taxpayer penalties or taxpayer filing procedures. It is about the BIR-AAB reporting process after a dishonored check occurs. For CFOs, accountants, and business owners searching for BIR returned dishonored checks AAB, BIR Form No. 12.58, Batch Control Sheet dishonored check, tax payment dishonored check Philippines, or Authorized Agent Bank returned checks, the practical point is that the circular simplifies the document handoff between banks and RDOs.
Key Compliance Requirement
The central compliance requirement is directed at RDO personnel: they must refrain from requiring AABs to submit copies of the Batch Control Sheet and tax returns or forms with dishonored check transactions when acknowledging receipt of the Report of Returned/Dishonored Checks, BIR Form No. 12.58.
The document expressly identifies the documents that should no longer be required in that context. First, copies of the Batch Control Sheet, commonly searched as BCS. Second, copies of tax returns or forms with dishonored check transactions. Third, these documents should not be required by the RDO for the purpose of acknowledging receipt of the original copies of dishonored checks, because they are already regularly retrieved by authorized RDO personnel under RMO No. 32-2000.
This distinction matters. RMC No. 21-2017 does not say that dishonored checks no longer need to be reported. It does not abolish BIR Form No. 12.58. It does not excuse dishonored check transactions. It simply tells RDO personnel not to impose an additional document submission requirement on AABs for documents already retrieved through the existing process.
Effective Date and Deadline
RMC No. 21-2017 is dated March 1, 2017. The document does not state a separate future effectivity date, transition period, or grace period. It is a directive to internal revenue officials, employees, taxpayers, and others concerned regarding how the reporting of returned or dishonored checks received by AABs should be handled.
No numerical tax rate, threshold, or payment deadline is introduced by RMC No. 21-2017. Its importance lies in the removal of a specific administrative requirement that had been imposed by some RDO personnel. Therefore, businesses should not treat this as a new tax rate circular. It is a BIR administrative clarification affecting returned or dishonored check reporting by Authorized Agent Banks.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 21-2017 does not create a new penalty, surcharge, interest rate, compromise penalty, or criminal consequence. It also does not prescribe a separate penalty for RDO personnel who continue to require the Batch Control Sheet and tax returns or forms from AABs in the specific situation covered by the circular.
However, businesses should not confuse the absence of a new penalty in RMC No. 21-2017 with leniency for dishonored tax payment checks. The circular concerns the reporting and acknowledgment process after dishonored checks are received by AABs. It does not amend the substantive tax rules on payment, filing, assessment, collection, or the consequences of a failed tax payment. A taxpayer whose check payment fails should still coordinate promptly with its bank, accountant, and tax counsel to determine the status of payment and any remedial steps required under applicable BIR rules.
Practical Steps for Banks, CFOs, and Tax Teams
Authorized Agent Banks should review their procedures for reporting returned or dishonored checks to the BIR and ensure that staff handling BIR coordination know that RDO personnel should not require copies of the Batch Control Sheet and the related tax returns or forms merely to acknowledge receipt of BIR Form No. 12.58.
Tax departments and corporate accountants should also keep this circular in mind when monitoring tax payments made through checks. If a tax payment check is dishonored, the internal focus should be on immediate remediation, confirming whether the payment was accepted or failed, and ensuring that the company can document its actions. RMC No. 21-2017 will not cure the taxpayer’s failed payment, but it helps clarify the administrative reporting process between the AAB and the RDO.
Businesses should also coordinate with their AABs if there are delays caused by RDO requests for documents that the circular says should not be demanded in this context. A practical response would be to refer to RMC No. 21-2017, identify the specific documents being requested, and clarify that the BCS and tax returns or forms are regularly retrieved by authorized RDO personnel under RMO No. 32-2000.
For companies with frequent tax payments, especially those paying high-value tax obligations through bank channels, the lesson is broader: tax payment documentation should be centralized, verified, and monitored. A dishonored check is not merely a banking issue. It can create tax exposure if not corrected promptly. Accounting teams should maintain proof of attempted payment, bank advice, correspondence with the AAB, replacement payment details, and any BIR acknowledgment or reporting documents connected with the returned check.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, banks, corporate accountants, and in-house legal teams on BIR compliance, tax payment issues, documentary requirements, and administrative dealings with Revenue District Offices. RMC No. 21-2017 is a reminder that not every BIR office request is automatically supported by the applicable issuance, and that companies should know when to comply, when to clarify, and when to push back professionally.
For assistance with BIR compliance, dishonored tax payment checks, RDO documentation issues, tax assessments, and corporate tax risk management, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.