Public utilities satisfy the 60-40 rule when Filipinos hold 60% of voting rights and total capital, not necessarily each share class.

Public utility companies may satisfy the Constitution’s Filipino ownership requirement when Filipino nationals hold both 60 percent of the voting shares and 60 percent of the total outstanding capital stock, even if the 60-40 rule is not applied separately to every class of shares.

Why This Case Matters to Investors and Regulated Companies

Foreign ownership limits are not just technical compliance rules. For companies operating public utilities, they can determine whether a franchise, certificate, or authority to operate remains valid. For investors, they affect whether shares may be lawfully acquired, retained, or required to be divested. For regulators, they define how far the government may go in testing whether Filipino control is real or merely nominal.

In Roy v. Chairperson Herbosa (G.R. No. 207246, April 18, 2017), the Court dealt with a challenge to SEC Memorandum Circular No. 8, Series of 2013, the Securities and Exchange Commission issuance implementing the earlier Gamboa doctrine on foreign ownership in public utilities. The challengers argued that the Filipino ownership requirement should apply uniformly to each class of shares. The SEC, however, adopted a dual test: the required Filipino percentage must apply to shares entitled to vote in the election of directors and to the total outstanding shares, whether voting or non-voting.

The Dual Compliance Rule for Public Utility Ownership

The controlling doctrine affirmed in this resolution may be called the Dual Compliance Rule. For public utilities, Filipino nationals must hold 60 percent of the outstanding capital stock and 60 percent of the voting rights. The SEC did not gravely abuse its discretion when it required compliance with both measurements rather than imposing a separate 60 percent Filipino ownership threshold on each individual class of shares.

The Court emphasized that the constitutional concern is control of public utilities. Section 11, Article XII of the Constitution is designed to prevent aliens from assuming control over enterprises considered vital to national interest. In corporate law terms, control is primarily exercised through voting rights, especially the right to elect directors. At the same time, the ownership requirement cannot be reduced to paper title alone. Full beneficial ownership must accompany the required Filipino equity.

Beneficial Ownership Is Tested Stock by Stock, Not by Dividend Preference Alone

A major point of clarification concerned beneficial ownership. The Court explained that beneficial ownership is relevant in determining who owns a specific stock for purposes of the nationality requirement. A Filipino may be considered the beneficial owner of a particular share if he or she has voting power over it, investment power over it, or both. Investment power includes the ability to dispose of the security or direct its disposition.

The Court rejected the view that dividend differences alone determine whether a stock is beneficially owned by Filipinos. Dividends are rights flowing from ownership, but dividend policy depends on corporate circumstances, including unrestricted retained earnings, expansion needs, and reserves for contingencies. So long as Filipinos retain the constitutionally required controlling interest, the allocation of economic benefits among classes of shares does not automatically prove foreign control.

Why the Challenge Failed Procedurally

The petition also failed on procedural grounds. The Court held that the petitioners did not sufficiently establish an actual case or controversy and did not demonstrate standing in a manner that justified judicial review. The Court also found that the hierarchy of courts had been violated and that indispensable parties had not been impleaded.

This was significant because the requested interpretation could have affected not only PLDT but many other public utility corporations and their shareholders. If the stricter interpretation had been adopted, foreign shareholders in several corporations could have been forced to divest shares, while public utilities could have faced serious consequences affecting their franchises and property rights. The Court was unwilling to make a sweeping ruling without giving affected corporations and shareholders their day in court.

The SEC Gets the First Look at Factual Compliance

The Court also stressed institutional competence. Whether a particular public utility actually complies with foreign ownership limits requires factual examination of corporate structures, share classifications, trust arrangements, voting rights, and beneficial ownership. The Court noted that the SEC is the government agency with the mandate and expertise to make that determination in the first instance.

For PLDT specifically, the Court declined to rule on factual allegations involving voting preferred shares, trust structures, and who actually controlled how certain shares would be voted. Those matters were considered premature in the absence of a definitive SEC ruling on PLDT’s compliance. The Court’s task in this case was narrower: to determine whether the SEC committed grave abuse of discretion in issuing the circular. It found none.

What This Means for Public Utilities, Investors, and Corporate Counsel

For public utilities, the ruling confirms that compliance cannot be tested by looking only at the total number of shares or only at voting shares. Both voting control and total outstanding capital must be reviewed. Filipino ownership must be real, legally supported, and beneficial, not merely nominal.

For foreign investors, the case provides a clearer compliance framework. Foreign participation in public utilities remains constitutionally limited, but the Court did not adopt the most restrictive possible rule requiring 60 percent Filipino ownership in every class of shares. This matters for preferred shares, voting preferred shares, and other capital structures used to raise funds while maintaining Filipino control.

For corporate lawyers and compliance officers, the ruling is a warning against treating nationality compliance as a one-page arithmetic exercise. Corporate documents, trust arrangements, shareholder rights, voting powers, investment powers, and SEC filings must align. A company may appear compliant on paper but still face scrutiny if beneficial ownership or actual voting control is doubtful.

Practical Takeaway

The practical lesson is that public utility ownership must be structured around two questions: who controls the vote, and who beneficially owns the stock? If Filipino nationals hold at least 60 percent of both the voting rights and the total outstanding capital stock, the structure is more likely to satisfy the constitutional standard recognized in this ruling. But if voting arrangements, trusts, side agreements, or nominee structures obscure who truly controls or benefits from the shares, SEC scrutiny may still follow.

Need Help Reviewing Foreign Ownership Compliance?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, investors, founders, and shareholders on corporate structuring, nationality restrictions, SEC compliance, public utility regulation, and shareholder disputes. If your company operates in a regulated or partially nationalized industry, our team can help review your ownership structure, corporate records, and compliance risks before they become litigation or regulatory problems. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our corporate and litigation lawyers.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *