RR No. 7-2017 reduces BSP creditable withholding tax on metallic mineral purchases from 5% to 1%, while retaining documentation and excise tax duties.
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas purchases of metallic minerals are now subject to only one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax, instead of the general five percent (5%) rate imposed on buyers of metallic minerals. Sellers and possessors of metallic minerals dealing with BSP must immediately ensure that the correct withholding tax is collected, remitted, and documented, because proof of withholding and remittance is required to support the claimed costs and expenses associated with the metallic minerals.
What RR No. 7-2017 Changed
RR No. 7-2017 amended the withholding tax rules under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by RR No. 17-2003, in relation to RR No. 6-2012. The key change is narrow but important: BSP’s obligation as withholding agent for creditable withholding tax on purchases of metallic minerals was reduced from five percent (5%) to one percent (1%) of gross payments made.
The regulation keeps the general rule for income payments on purchases of minerals, mineral products, and quarry resources. Income payments on purchases of minerals, mineral products, and quarry resources, including silver, gold, marble, granite, sand, boulders, and other materials or products, remain generally subject to five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax. However, RR No. 7-2017 creates a specific BSP exception: BSP is required to withhold only one percent (1%) of gross payments made and remit the same to the Government.
This matters because metallic mineral transactions, particularly those involving gold and other minerals sold to or purchased by BSP, require correct withholding treatment. Applying the ordinary five percent (5%) rate to BSP transactions may result in over-withholding, while failure to document the one percent (1%) withholding and remittance can create income tax substantiation problems for sellers or possessors claiming related costs and expenses.
Who Is Affected by RR No. 7-2017
The issuance directly affects BSP as a buyer and withholding agent in purchases of metallic minerals. It also affects sellers and possessors of metallic minerals who transact with BSP, including taxpayers who need to claim the costs of metallic minerals in computing taxable income.
The regulation is especially relevant to taxpayers involved in metallic minerals, gold sales to BSP, mineral product transactions, and businesses or individuals who rely on proof of withholding tax remittance to support deductibility of costs. Corporate accountants, tax managers, and CFOs should also take note because the rate applicable to BSP is different from the rate applicable to other buyers of metallic minerals.
For non-BSP buyers of metallic minerals, the general rule remains unchanged: buyers of metallic minerals are required to withhold five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax. RR No. 7-2017 does not reduce the withholding obligation of private buyers or other buyers outside BSP. The one percent (1%) rate is expressly tied to BSP’s purchase of metallic minerals.
Key Rates Under RR No. 7-2017
The most searched compliance detail in RR No. 7-2017 is the rate distinction. For income payments on purchases of minerals, mineral products, and quarry resources, the general withholding tax rate remains five percent (5%). For BSP purchases of metallic minerals, the creditable withholding tax rate is one percent (1%) of gross payments made.
RR No. 7-2017 also confirms that all buyers of metallic minerals are constituted as agents for the collection of the two percent (2%) excise tax on metallic minerals and the five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax thereon. However, BSP, as a constituted agent, shall only collect the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax on its purchase of metallic minerals and the two percent (2%) excise tax due thereon.
In practical terms, a BSP purchase of metallic minerals carries two tax collection points under the amended rule: one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax and two percent (2%) excise tax. By contrast, the general rule for other buyers of metallic minerals remains five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax, together with the two percent (2%) excise tax on metallic minerals where applicable.
Income Tax Treatment for Sellers of Metallic Minerals
RR No. 7-2017 reiterates that sellers are subject to income tax at the applicable rate under Section 24(A) of the 1997 National Internal Revenue Code in the case of individual taxpayers, and under Section 27(A) in the case of corporations. The reduced BSP withholding rate does not exempt sellers from income tax. It only changes the amount BSP must withhold and remit as creditable withholding tax.
For sellers, the creditable withholding tax is important because it forms part of the tax documentation for the transaction. Corporate sellers and individual sellers should ensure that withholding tax certificates, proof of remittance, and transaction records are properly retained. The reduced one percent (1%) rate must be reflected correctly for BSP transactions so that tax filings, income reporting, and expense substantiation remain consistent.
Documentation Requirement: Proof of Withholding and Remittance
The regulation contains a critical substantiation rule. In order for a seller or possessor of metallic minerals to claim the costs of the metallic mineral, the seller or possessor must be able to show proof of withholding and remittance of the withholding tax on the product.
For the general rule, the required proof relates to the five percent (5%) withholding tax. In the case of metallic minerals sold to BSP, the required proof relates to the one percent (1%) withholding tax. If the seller or possessor cannot show proof of withholding and remittance, all claimed costs and expenses associated with the metallic minerals shall be disallowed.
This is the most practical risk for taxpayers. The issue is not merely whether the correct tax rate was applied. The taxpayer must also be able to prove that the tax was withheld and remitted. Without that proof, the taxpayer may lose the deduction or cost claim connected to the metallic mineral, increasing taxable income and potential tax exposure.
Effective Date and Immediate Compliance
RR No. 7-2017 was issued on October 26, 2017 and provides that the regulations shall take effect immediately. Businesses and taxpayers involved in metallic mineral transactions should therefore treat the BSP one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax rule as immediately applicable from the effectivity of the regulation.
For tax teams reviewing historical transactions, the effective date matters when testing whether the five percent (5%) or one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax rate should have been applied to BSP purchases. For current compliance systems, the main point is to ensure that BSP transactions are coded separately from other metallic mineral buyer transactions.
Penalties and Tax Risks for Non-Compliance
RR No. 7-2017 specifically states that where the seller or possessor of metallic minerals cannot show proof of withholding and remittance, all claimed costs and expenses associated with the metallic minerals shall be disallowed. This disallowance can be financially significant because it affects the taxpayer’s income tax computation.
Although the regulation focuses on the disallowance of costs and expenses, taxpayers should also treat incorrect withholding, non-remittance, or poor documentation as audit risks. A mismatch between reported income, claimed costs, withholding tax certificates, and remittance records may invite BIR scrutiny, particularly for taxpayers engaged in mineral product transactions, quarry resources, and metallic minerals.
Practical Steps for BSP Transactions and Metallic Mineral Sellers
Taxpayers selling metallic minerals to BSP should confirm that the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax is applied to gross payments made by BSP. They should also confirm that the two percent (2%) excise tax on metallic minerals is properly collected where applicable under the amended rules.
Accounting departments should maintain transaction files showing the buyer, gross payment, tax withheld, tax remitted, and supporting certificates or proof of remittance. Because the disallowance rule is tied to proof of withholding and remittance, documentation should not be treated as a mere administrative formality. It is the basis for preserving the deductibility or recognition of costs and expenses associated with the metallic minerals.
Tax managers should also separate BSP purchases from purchases by private buyers or other entities. The one percent (1%) rate should not be generalized to all metallic mineral transactions. The ordinary rule remains five percent (5%) creditable withholding tax for buyers of metallic minerals other than BSP.
Businesses searching for guidance on RR No. 7-2017, BSP withholding tax on gold purchases, one percent withholding tax on metallic minerals, five percent creditable withholding tax minerals, and two percent excise tax on metallic minerals should focus on both the correct rate and the proof of remittance requirement. In a BIR audit, the taxpayer must be able to show not only that the right rate was applied, but that the withholding tax was actually remitted.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, mineral sellers, corporate taxpayers, accountants, and finance teams in reviewing BIR withholding tax compliance, transaction documentation, and exposure to cost or expense disallowances. For companies dealing with BSP, metallic minerals, excise tax, or creditable withholding tax, the safest approach is to review contracts, invoices, tax certificates, and remittance records before a BIR examination begins.
For legal and tax assistance on RR No. 7-2017, BSP withholding tax, metallic minerals taxation, and BIR compliance in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.