RMC No. 12-2018 clarifies that BIR Section 5 information requests may override attorney-client and accountant-client privilege in tax investigations.

Lawyers, accountants, corporations, partnerships, and other third parties may be compelled to provide tax-related information requested by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, even where attorney-client privilege or accountant-client privilege is invoked. RMC No. 12-2018 matters now because it clarifies that the Commissioner’s statutory power under Section 5 of the National Internal Revenue Code may operate as an exception to professional confidentiality rules when the BIR is ascertaining tax correctness, determining liability, collecting tax, or evaluating tax compliance.

What RMC No. 12-2018 Changed

RMC No. 12-2018 clarifies the nature and extent of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s authority to obtain information under Section 5 of the NIRC of 1997, as amended, in relation to attorney-client privilege and accountant-client privilege. The key rule is direct: the BIR’s power to obtain information under Section 5 may prevail over claims of attorney-client and accountant-client privilege when the information is sought for legitimate tax administration purposes.

Section 5 of the NIRC empowers the Commissioner, in ascertaining the correctness of any return, making a return when none has been made, determining the tax liability of any person, collecting such liability, or evaluating tax compliance, to obtain information on a regular basis from any person other than the person whose internal revenue tax liability is subject to audit or investigation. The information covered includes, among others, receipts or sales, gross income of taxpayers, and the names, addresses, and financial statements of corporations, registered partnerships, and their members.

The practical implication is significant for tax audits and BIR investigations. A taxpayer’s lawyer, accountant, auditor, consultant, business counterparty, corporation, partnership, or other third party cannot simply refuse every BIR request by invoking professional confidentiality. RMC No. 12-2018 makes clear that privilege cannot be used to defeat the very purpose of Section 5: enabling the Commissioner to gather information needed to verify tax compliance and enforce internal revenue laws.

Who Is Most Affected

The circular most directly affects lawyers, certified public accountants, external auditors, tax consultants, corporations, registered partnerships, and persons who possess information relevant to another taxpayer’s internal revenue liability. It is especially important for businesses under BIR audit, corporate groups with related-party records, accountants maintaining working papers, and law firms or professional advisers holding tax-sensitive documents.

For business owners, CFOs, and corporate accountants, the immediate concern is not limited to the taxpayer under examination. Section 5 expressly allows the Commissioner to obtain information from any person other than the person being audited or investigated. That means suppliers, customers, affiliates, professional advisers, and other parties may receive BIR requests for information connected to a taxpayer’s receipts, sales, gross income, corporate membership, partnership information, addresses, and financial statements.

For lawyers and accountants, RMC No. 12-2018 requires careful handling of BIR requests. Professional confidentiality remains important, but the circular identifies statutory and ethical exceptions where disclosure may be required by law or where there is a legal right or duty to disclose. The document therefore affects both the taxpayer and the professional adviser who must decide how to respond to a BIR request without violating either tax law or professional obligations.

Attorney-Client Privilege and the BIR’s Section 5 Power

RMC No. 12-2018 recognizes attorney-client privilege under the Code of Professional Responsibility and the Revised Rules on Evidence. It acknowledges the rule that an attorney cannot, without the consent of the client, be examined as to communications made by the client or advice given in the course of, or with a view to, professional employment.

However, the circular clarifies that this privilege is not absolute in the face of the Commissioner’s statutory information-gathering power. It cites Rule 21.01 of the Lawyer’s Code of Professional Responsibility, which allows disclosure of client confidences or secrets when required by law. It also cites the Supreme Court ruling in Genato v. Silapan, where the Court stressed that privilege against disclosure of confidential communication or information does not extend to communications made in contemplation of a crime or the perpetration of fraud.

This is particularly important in tax cases because an attempt to evade or defeat tax is a criminal offense under Section 254 of the NIRC, as amended. The circular’s logic is that where tax enforcement requires lawful access to information, professional privilege cannot be used as a shield to obstruct the Commissioner’s statutory function.

Accountant-Client Privilege and CPA Working Papers

RMC No. 12-2018 also addresses accountant-client privilege under Republic Act No. 9298, or the Philippine Accountancy Act of 2004, and the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants. It recognizes that working papers, schedules, and memoranda prepared by a certified public accountant in the course of an examination, including documents prepared and submitted by the client in connection with the examination, are generally treated as confidential and privileged.

The circular then identifies the important statutory limitation. Section 29 of RA 9298 states that accountant-client privilege does not apply if the production of documents is required through a subpoena issued by any court, tribunal, or government regulatory or administrative body. It also refers to Section 140.1 of the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants, under which professional accountants must refrain from disclosing confidential information acquired from professional and business relationships unless there is a legal right or duty to disclose.

For accountants and auditors, the compliance point is clear: records, schedules, memoranda, and working papers may be confidential, but confidentiality may yield where the BIR exercises a lawful information-gathering power or where production is required through proper legal process. A CPA receiving a BIR request should not automatically disclose everything, but neither should the CPA assume that accountant-client privilege is a complete defense against a Section 5 request.

Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

RMC No. 12-2018 is dated 22 February 2018. It does not create a new filing deadline or tax return deadline. Instead, it clarifies how existing BIR information-gathering powers should be understood and applied in relation to professional privilege.

The compliance requirement is procedural but serious: persons from whom information is sought under Section 5 of the NIRC must respond to lawful BIR requests for tax-relevant information. The information may include receipts or sales, gross income data, names, addresses, and financial statements of corporations, registered partnerships, and their members. Where the BIR request concerns another taxpayer under audit or investigation, the third party receiving the request must treat it as a matter requiring legal and tax review, not as an optional inquiry.

For corporations and partnerships, this means maintaining accessible records of financial statements, member or shareholder information, registered addresses, sales, receipts, and gross income data. For professional advisers, this means creating an internal response protocol for BIR requests, including review of the legal basis, scope of request, privilege issues, authority of the requesting office, and potential exposure for non-compliance.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 12-2018 expressly cites the penalties for non-compliance. Failure to comply with the Commissioner’s information-gathering authority under Section 5 may warrant the imposition of One Thousand Pesos, or P1,000, for each failure under Section 250 of the NIRC, as amended.

The circular also cites Section 255 of the NIRC, as amended, which may impose a fine of Ten Thousand Pesos, or P10,000, and imprisonment of not less than one year but not more than ten years. These figures are critical because many businesses treat BIR requests for third-party information as administrative correspondence only. RMC No. 12-2018 emphasizes that failure to comply may have statutory consequences beyond inconvenience or audit friction.

Businesses should therefore avoid casual refusal, delayed response, or blanket privilege objections. A privilege claim may still require careful evaluation, but after RMC No. 12-2018, the safer approach is to document the review, identify the legal basis for any objection, and respond within the scope permitted or required by law.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, Lawyers, and Accountants

First, businesses should identify who is authorized to receive and respond to BIR information requests. The recipient should immediately determine whether the request is made under Section 5 of the NIRC, what taxpayer is under audit or investigation, what specific documents or information are requested, and whether the request concerns receipts, sales, gross income, names, addresses, financial statements, corporate records, partnership records, or professional working papers.

Second, CFOs and accounting departments should maintain an internal index of tax-sensitive documents. This should include financial statements, sales reports, gross income schedules, official receipts and invoices, tax returns, customer and supplier records, corporate records, and documents submitted to external accountants or auditors. RMC No. 12-2018 makes these records important not only for the taxpayer’s own audit but also for third-party information requests involving other taxpayers.

Third, lawyers and accountants should avoid giving clients a blanket assurance that all tax-related communications and records are immune from BIR access. Attorney-client privilege and accountant-client privilege continue to exist, but RMC No. 12-2018 clarifies that they are subject to exceptions when disclosure is required by law, when information relates to crime or fraud, or when a proper subpoena or lawful demand is issued by a competent authority.

Fourth, companies should create a documented BIR response protocol. The protocol should require immediate routing to legal and tax counsel, preservation of all requested records, review of privilege issues, preparation of a written response, and tracking of deadlines. Even if the circular does not set a specific calendar deadline, every BIR request should be treated as time-sensitive because non-compliance may trigger the penalties cited in Sections 250 and 255 of the NIRC.

Common search phrases for this issue include BIR power to obtain information, Section 5 NIRC information request, attorney-client privilege BIR tax audit, accountant-client privilege BIR subpoena, CPA working papers BIR request, and RMC No. 12-2018 tax investigation. These phrases capture the central compliance risk: professional privilege may not be enough to refuse a lawful BIR demand for tax-relevant information.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 12-2018 is a reminder that BIR audits and investigations are not limited to the taxpayer being examined. Third parties, lawyers, accountants, corporations, partnerships, and professional advisers may all be drawn into the information-gathering process. The legal risk lies in responding too broadly, refusing too quickly, or failing to preserve privilege where a valid privilege claim remains available.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and professional advisers in handling BIR letters, tax audits, third-party information requests, privilege reviews, CPA working paper issues, and tax compliance protocols. For businesses that receive a BIR request under Section 5 of the NIRC, early legal review can help determine what must be disclosed, what may be protected, and how to respond without increasing civil, criminal, or professional exposure.

For assistance with BIR compliance, tax audit response, accountant-client privilege concerns, attorney-client privilege issues, and tax investigation strategy, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *