LGUs cannot collect franchise taxes under a void municipal ordinance; later cityhood does not cure the invalid local tax assessment.
Local governments cannot collect taxes from businesses unless the tax is imposed through a valid ordinance enacted by an LGU that had legal authority to impose that tax at the time of enactment. Under the Void Ordinance Rule, a defective municipal tax ordinance does not become enforceable merely because the municipality later becomes a city. For companies facing local tax assessments, the legal basis of the assessment matters as much as the amount being demanded.
Background: The Dispute
The dispute arose when the City of Pasig demanded that Manila Electric Company pay franchise taxes for the years 1996 to 1999 under Municipal Ordinance No. 25, which had been enacted in 1992 while Pasig was still a municipality. MERALCO protested, arguing that municipalities had no authority under the Local Government Code to impose franchise taxes and that the ordinance had already been treated as void. After the trial court sustained Pasig’s demand, the Court of Appeals reversed and declared the assessment invalid, leading Pasig to seek relief from the Supreme Court (G.R. No. 181710, March 7, 2018).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Supreme Court denied Pasig’s petition and affirmed that the franchise tax demand against MERALCO had no valid legal basis. The Court explained that, under the Local Government Code, the power to impose a franchise tax belongs to provinces and cities, not municipalities. Section 142 of the Code allows municipalities to levy only taxes not otherwise levied by provinces, while Section 137 specifically grants franchise taxing authority to provinces and Section 151 extends such taxing powers to cities.
Because Pasig was still a municipality when Ordinance No. 25 was enacted, it had no authority to impose a franchise tax. The ordinance was therefore void from the beginning. A void ordinance cannot support an assessment, cannot be enforced, and cannot create rights in favor of the local government.
The Court also rejected Pasig’s argument that its conversion into a city cured the defect. Although Pasig later became a highly urbanized city, the Court held that cityhood did not breathe life into a tax ordinance that was void when enacted. The provision in Pasig’s cityhood law allowing existing municipal ordinances to continue in force applied only to ordinances that were valid and legally existing in the first place.
Key Legal Principles Established
The decision establishes the Void Ordinance Rule in local taxation: an LGU tax assessment must rest on a valid ordinance, and the ordinance must have been enacted by an LGU with authority to impose the specific tax. A statutory grant of taxing power under the Local Government Code is not enough by itself. The Sanggunian must enact an appropriate ordinance, and that ordinance must be consistent with the Constitution and prevailing law.
The ruling also clarifies that local autonomy does not give LGUs unrestricted taxing power. The Constitution recognizes local fiscal autonomy, but that autonomy remains subject to limitations imposed by Congress. Where Congress has withheld a taxing power from municipalities, a municipality cannot invoke autonomy to collect a tax it had no authority to impose.
Finally, the Court reaffirmed that ambiguity in local taxing powers is generally resolved against the local government. This principle is especially important for businesses disputing local tax assessments, because the burden remains on the LGU to show clear legal authority for the tax being collected.
What This Means for Businesses and Individuals
Businesses receiving local tax assessments should not assume that a demand letter is valid simply because it comes from a city or municipal treasurer. The assessment must be traced to a valid ordinance, and the LGU must have had legal authority to enact that ordinance when it was passed. This is especially relevant to franchise holders, utilities, regulated businesses, and companies operating across several cities or municipalities.
For LGUs, the decision is a reminder that revenue measures must be carefully reviewed before enforcement. A city cannot rely on an old municipal ordinance if that ordinance was void when enacted. If the LGU later acquires taxing authority, it must enact a proper ordinance under its current powers rather than attempt to enforce a defective one.
For taxpayers, the ruling offers a practical defense in Philippine local tax litigation: challenge not only the computation of the tax, but also the legal authority behind it. In local tax disputes, the ordinance, the timing of its enactment, and the LGU’s legal status at that time may determine whether the assessment survives.
Facing a Local Tax Assessment? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
A business that pays an invalid local tax assessment may lose substantial funds, face repeated collection demands, or miss the opportunity to challenge an assessment before the proper forum. Local tax disputes require close review of the Local Government Code, the ordinance being enforced, the LGU’s authority, and the taxpayer’s remedies.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco represents businesses, property owners, and regulated entities in Philippine tax litigation, local government disputes, and civil litigation involving assessments and collection actions. Speak with a Philippine tax lawyer at our Makati office or visit MakatiLawFirm.com for advice on local tax assessments and LGU tax disputes.