Condo unit owners cannot rely on builder in good faith rules to keep unauthorized structures in common areas; the Condominium Act and by-laws prevail.

A condominium unit owner who builds into common areas cannot force the condominium corporation to buy the illegal structure or lease the affected space. When condominium property is governed by the Condominium Act, the master deed, and the corporation’s by-laws, the special rules for condominium ownership prevail over the Civil Code rules on builders in good faith.

The Practical Rule: A Permit Is Not Enough

For condominium owners, developers, property managers, and building administrators, the ruling establishes a direct and practical rule: a building permit does not automatically create a private right to build on condominium common areas. Even if a unit owner obtains a permit from the building official, the construction may still violate the condominium’s governing documents and the rights of other unit owners.

The case is especially important for penthouse owners, roof deck users, commercial unit owners, and condominium corporations dealing with unauthorized improvements. Ownership of a unit does not necessarily include ownership of the air space above it. Unless the master deed or declaration of restrictions clearly grants that area as part of the unit, the space above the unit may form part of the condominium’s common areas.

Background: A New Structure on the Roof Deck

Legaspi Towers 200 was a condominium building in Makati governed by a master deed and by-laws. Leviste Management System, Inc. owned Concession 3, a unit located above the roof deck area. In 1989, Leviste Management decided to construct another unit, called Concession 4, on top of Concession 3. It obtained a building permit and began construction in 1990.

Legaspi Towers objected, asserting that the construction was illegal and that the air space above Concession 3 belonged to the condominium corporation, not to Leviste Management. The dispute reached the courts after Leviste Management sought an injunction to complete the construction and Legaspi Towers sought to nullify the permit and remove the structure. The Supreme Court decided the consolidated petitions on April 4, 2018.

The Court Rejected the Builder in Good Faith Argument

Leviste Management argued that even if Legaspi Towers owned the affected space, the Civil Code rules on builders in good faith should apply. Under those rules, a landowner whose land is built upon in good faith generally must choose between appropriating the improvement after paying indemnity or requiring the builder to pay for the land, subject to legal limitations.

The Supreme Court refused to apply that doctrine. It explained that the Civil Code provisions on builders in good faith presuppose a situation where the landowner and the builder are distinct persons who are not already governed by a special law or by contract. That was not the case here. The property was a condominium project, the parties were bound by the Condominium Act, and their relationship was also governed by the master deed and by-laws.

Because the Condominium Act is a special law governing condominium projects, it prevailed over the general Civil Code rules. The Court emphasized the principle that a special law controls over a general law when both appear to cover the same subject. Condominium ownership is a special form of property ownership because it combines separate ownership of units with shared ownership or interests in common areas. That legal arrangement requires rules different from ordinary disputes between neighboring landowners.

Why the Air Space Was Treated as a Common Area

The Court affirmed the lower courts’ finding that the air space above Concession 3 was not owned by Leviste Management. The area was not merely above one private unit; it was above the condominium building itself. Under the Condominium Act, a unit generally consists of the separate interest granted to the unit owner, while common areas cover the portions of the project not separately granted or reserved.

The Court cited the Condominium Act’s rule that, unless otherwise provided in the master deed, the boundaries of a unit are the interior surfaces of its perimeter walls, ceilings, windows, and doors. Structural components such as roofs, columns, bearing walls, foundations, and common structural elements are not part of the private unit. On that logic, the area above Concession 3 was not automatically included in the ownership of Concession 3.

The master deed described the Legaspi Towers building as having seven stories, a basement, a ground floor, a roof deck, and two levels above the roof deck. Concession 4 added another level beyond what the master deed described. The master deed had not been amended to include that new structure.

Condominium Approval Was Required

The Court found that Leviste Management failed to comply with the Condominium Act and the condominium’s by-laws. Under the Condominium Act, an enabling or master deed may be amended only through the proper registered instrument and with the consent required by law, including the registered owners of condominium units in the project.

The by-laws of Legaspi Towers also required approval of the members for extraordinary improvements or additions involving structural construction or modification. Instead of securing the required approval, Leviste Management relied on an internal arrangement with the condominium corporation’s then president. The Court held that this was insufficient. A corporation, including a condominium corporation, acts through its board of directors, not merely through informal arrangements with one officer.

The Corporation Could Demolish the Structure at the Builder’s Expense

The Supreme Court held that Legaspi Towers had the right to demolish Concession 4 at the expense of Leviste Management. The Court considered it unjust to force the condominium corporation to either appropriate and pay for an illegal structure or allow it to remain in exchange for rent. Such a result would reward a construction that violated the Condominium Act, the master deed, and the by-laws, while also threatening the structural integrity of the condominium building.

The Court therefore denied Leviste Management’s petition and granted Legaspi Towers’ petition. It reversed the Court of Appeals and ordered Leviste Management to remove Concession 4 at its own expense.

What This Means for Condominium Corporations and Unit Owners

For condominium corporations, this ruling strengthens the power to enforce the master deed, declaration of restrictions, and by-laws against unauthorized structural additions. It confirms that common areas cannot be appropriated by individual unit owners through unilateral construction, even when the construction appears to have some form of administrative permit.

For unit owners, the lesson is equally clear. Before building, expanding, enclosing, or modifying any part of a condominium project beyond the interior boundaries of the unit, the owner must examine the master deed, the by-laws, the Condominium Act, and the required approvals of the corporation and the registered owners. A private arrangement with an officer, manager, or administrator may not be enough.

For buyers of penthouses, roof deck units, commercial concessions, and top-floor spaces, the case is a warning against assuming that vertical space belongs to the unit owner. The precise scope of ownership must be traced to the title, master deed, declaration of restrictions, and condominium documents. Silence in the master deed is not permission to build upward.

Why the Ruling Matters in Property and Real Estate Disputes

This decision is significant because it prevents the Civil Code doctrine on builders in good faith from being used to defeat condominium governance. In ordinary land disputes, the builder in good faith doctrine may protect a person who mistakenly builds on another’s land. In condominium disputes, however, unit owners are already bound by a special legal and contractual framework. The doctrine cannot be used to override that framework.

The ruling also protects the collective interest of all unit owners. Unauthorized vertical construction may affect structural safety, building design, insurance, common area allocation, title documentation, and the proportionate rights of other condominium members. The Court’s approach recognizes that condominium living depends on strict compliance with shared rules.

Talk to a Makati Property Litigation Lawyer

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises condominium corporations, property owners, developers, unit owners, and businesses involved in real estate disputes, condominium governance issues, unauthorized construction, title conflicts, and enforcement of master deeds and by-laws. If you are dealing with an unauthorized condominium improvement, a dispute over common areas, or a construction-related property conflict, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our litigation and real estate team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *