RMC No. 96-2018 deletes TRAIN Law FAQ items on group health insurance premiums and directors’ fees from RMC No. 50-2018.
Employers, corporations, payroll teams, and tax practitioners should no longer treat the RMC No. 50-2018 discussions on group health insurance premiums and directors’ fees as TRAIN Law clarifications. RMC No. 96-2018 removes those items from RMC No. 50-2018 because they were not affected by Republic Act No. 10963, or the TRAIN Law. For businesses, the immediate compliance point is narrow but important: do not use the deleted Q&A items as authority for TRAIN-related tax treatment, payroll classification, or withholding positions.
What RMC No. 96-2018 Changed
RMC No. 96-2018 clarifies the scope of RMC No. 50-2018, which was issued to answer frequently asked questions raised during briefings on the implementation of Republic Act No. 10963, more commonly known as the TRAIN Law. The BIR recognized that some questions and answers included in RMC No. 50-2018 involved matters that were not actually part of the TRAIN Law changes.
The most important change is the deletion from RMC No. 50-2018 of the provisions relating to group health insurance premiums and directors’ fees. Specifically, RMC No. 96-2018 states that the provisions under RMC No. 50-2018 on group health insurance premiums, identified as Q7/A7, and directors’ fees, identified as Q34/A34, were not affected by the provisions of the TRAIN Law and are therefore deleted from RMC No. 50-2018.
This means that taxpayers searching for BIR guidance on “TRAIN Law group health insurance premiums,” “RMC 50-2018 health insurance tax treatment,” “directors fees withholding tax TRAIN Law,” or “BIR tax treatment directors fees” should be careful. RMC No. 96-2018 does not create a new tax rate, threshold, exemption, or withholding deadline for those items. Instead, it narrows the coverage of RMC No. 50-2018 by removing topics that should not have been treated as TRAIN Law implementation issues.
Why the Deletion Matters for Businesses
The practical effect of RMC No. 96-2018 is to prevent taxpayers from relying on RMC No. 50-2018 for matters outside the TRAIN Law. RMC No. 50-2018 was intended to clarify TRAIN Law implementation and its related revenue regulations. When provisions on group health insurance premiums and directors’ fees were included despite not being affected by the TRAIN Law, the risk was that employers, corporations, and tax practitioners could mistakenly treat those discussions as new TRAIN-based rules.
For employers, group health insurance premiums are commonly reviewed in connection with employee compensation, fringe benefits, payroll tax compliance, and employee benefits planning. For corporations, directors’ fees are commonly reviewed in connection with compensation of directors, board approvals, expanded withholding tax, compensation reporting, and income tax treatment. Because these items may have tax consequences even outside the TRAIN Law, the deletion does not mean they are tax-free, non-reportable, or irrelevant. It only means that RMC No. 50-2018 should no longer be cited as the TRAIN Law clarification for those items.
In tax compliance, source authority matters. A company’s tax position should be tied to the correct law, regulation, circular, ruling, or other applicable BIR issuance. RMC No. 96-2018 is therefore a housekeeping but significant clarification: it tells taxpayers that the deleted provisions should not be treated as part of the official TRAIN Law FAQ framework under RMC No. 50-2018.
Who Is Most Affected
The taxpayers most affected are corporations, employers, HR and payroll departments, finance teams, corporate accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel who previously used RMC No. 50-2018 as a reference for the tax treatment of group health insurance premiums or directors’ fees.
Corporations with active boards of directors should review any internal tax memos, board compensation policies, payroll instructions, and withholding tax procedures that cite RMC No. 50-2018 for directors’ fees. The same applies to employers maintaining group health insurance plans for employees, especially where the tax treatment of premiums is documented in compensation manuals, benefits policies, tax audit files, or payroll guidance notes.
Tax practitioners and accountants handling BIR audits, tax advisory work, annualization, withholding tax returns, and compensation reporting should also take note. RMC No. 96-2018 may be relevant when reviewing whether a taxpayer’s cited basis for a position is still the correct BIR authority. A reference to the deleted Q7/A7 or Q34/A34 of RMC No. 50-2018 may need to be replaced with the proper governing law, regulation, or issuance applicable to the particular tax issue.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 96-2018 is dated November 26, 2018. The issuance does not state a new filing deadline, transition period, payment deadline, registration requirement, or tax return submission date. It also does not prescribe a new tax rate, threshold, exemption ceiling, or formula for group health insurance premiums or directors’ fees.
The key compliance requirement is interpretive: taxpayers should treat the provisions on group health insurance premiums, Q7/A7, and directors’ fees, Q34/A34, as deleted from RMC No. 50-2018. Businesses should ensure that their tax compliance files and advisory references are updated accordingly.
For practical purposes, companies should immediately review any 2018 TRAIN Law implementation memos, payroll guides, HR benefits policies, directors’ compensation templates, and tax audit position papers that rely on those deleted RMC No. 50-2018 items. If those documents still cite RMC No. 50-2018 as authority for group health insurance premium treatment or directors’ fees, the citation should be revisited.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 96-2018 does not specify a special penalty for continuing to cite or rely on the deleted portions of RMC No. 50-2018. However, the absence of a specific penalty in the circular should not be treated as a license to ignore the clarification.
The real risk is audit and assessment exposure if a taxpayer applies the wrong authority or misclassifies a payment, benefit, or fee. For example, a company that treats directors’ fees or employee benefit payments incorrectly may face issues in withholding tax compliance, reporting, deductibility, or substantiation, depending on the applicable tax rule governing the transaction. RMC No. 96-2018 does not provide those rules; it simply clarifies that the deleted topics were not TRAIN Law matters under RMC No. 50-2018.
Accordingly, businesses should not assume that deletion equals exemption. It does not. The correct approach is to identify the proper tax rule outside RMC No. 50-2018 and apply that rule consistently in payroll, accounting, tax reporting, and documentation.
Practical Steps for Employers, CFOs, and Tax Teams
First, identify whether your company ever used RMC No. 50-2018 as authority for group health insurance premiums or directors’ fees. This may appear in tax memos, payroll manuals, HR benefits guidelines, board compensation approvals, tax audit schedules, or advice from prior accountants.
Second, remove or qualify references to RMC No. 50-2018 Q7/A7 and Q34/A34. Since RMC No. 96-2018 states that these items are deleted, they should not remain as controlling citations for TRAIN Law implementation.
Third, determine the correct authority for the actual tax question. If the issue is whether a group health insurance premium is taxable, exempt, deductible, or subject to withholding, that question must be answered under the applicable provisions of the Tax Code, revenue regulations, and other relevant BIR issuances. If the issue is the tax treatment of directors’ fees, the same discipline applies: determine the correct classification and withholding treatment using the proper governing rules, not the deleted RMC No. 50-2018 Q&A.
Fourth, document the correction. For companies preparing for BIR audits, it is helpful to show that internal references have been updated in light of RMC No. 96-2018. This is especially important for businesses with formal tax compliance manuals, recurring directors’ fees, or structured employee benefits programs.
ASG Law Can Help Review TRAIN Law and BIR Compliance Positions
RMC No. 96-2018 is short, but it illustrates a common tax compliance problem: businesses often rely on one BIR issuance without checking whether later clarifications have narrowed, corrected, or deleted part of that guidance. For employers and corporations, the cost of using the wrong authority can appear later in a BIR audit, withholding tax review, compensation tax issue, or deductibility dispute.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, founders, CFOs, accountants, and in-house legal teams in reviewing BIR issuances, TRAIN Law compliance positions, payroll tax practices, withholding tax exposure, directors’ fees, employee benefits, and tax documentation. For practical legal and tax guidance tailored to your business, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.