Unlawful detainer based on tolerance fails unless the owner proves positive acts of permission; silence or delay is not enough.
Tolerance by positive acts is now a critical rule for property owners filing unlawful detainer cases in the Philippines: a plaintiff cannot rely on silence, delay, or inaction to prove that another person’s possession was merely tolerated. For landlords, buyers, lenders, family members, and property claimants, the practical consequence is serious. If the supposed owner waits and does nothing after acquiring rights over property, that passivity may defeat an ejectment case because unlawful detainer requires proof of permission, not mere neglect.
Background: The Dispute
Ma. Antonette Lozano and Jocelyn K. Fernandez disputed possession of a parcel of land and its improvements in CM Subdivision, New Cabalan, Olongapo City. Fernandez relied on a Waiver and Transfer of Possessory Rights allegedly executed by Lozano in her favor, while Lozano denied that the document reflected their real agreement and claimed that the transaction was only a loan with collateral.
Fernandez later demanded that Lozano vacate the property and filed an unlawful detainer case when Lozano refused to leave. The Municipal Trial Court in Cities dismissed the ejectment complaint, but the Regional Trial Court and the Court of Appeals ruled for Fernandez, prompting Lozano to bring the dispute to the Supreme Court in Lozano v. Fernandez (G.R. No. 212979, February 18, 2019).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling
The Court reinstated the dismissal of Fernandez’s unlawful detainer complaint. While it refused to disregard the notarized waiver based only on Lozano’s bare allegations, it held that Fernandez still failed to prove a necessary element of unlawful detainer based on tolerance: positive acts showing that she permitted Lozano to remain on the property.
The Court explained that notarization converts a private document into a public document, giving it evidentiary weight and a presumption of regularity. A person who seeks to defeat a notarized document must present clear and convincing evidence, not merely an unsupported denial. On this point, Lozano did not present enough proof to invalidate the waiver.
But the validity of the waiver did not automatically establish unlawful detainer. Fernandez’s theory was that after the waiver, she allowed Lozano to continue possessing the property and later withdrew that permission through a demand to vacate. The problem was evidentiary: Fernandez pointed mainly to her failure to act after the waiver. The Court held that inaction is not tolerance. Silence may show negligence, but it does not necessarily show consent.
Key Legal Principles Established
The central doctrine is the tolerance by positive acts rule. In an unlawful detainer case based on tolerance, the plaintiff must prove overt acts showing permission or consent. A mere conclusion that possession was tolerated is not enough. Affidavits that simply label the occupant’s stay as tolerated, without describing specific acts of permission, will not satisfy the rule.
The decision also clarifies the difference between ownership-related documents and ejectment requirements. Even if a document appears to transfer possessory rights, a plaintiff who waits for years before filing ejectment must still prove why the occupant’s continued stay was initially lawful and when it became unlawful. The unlawful detainer theory collapses when the plaintiff cannot show that the occupant stayed by permission that was later withdrawn.
At the same time, the Court reaffirmed the evidentiary strength of notarized documents. Parties who claim that a notarized deed, waiver, or transfer was simulated, irregular, or signed under questionable circumstances must be prepared to present strong evidence. Unsupported statements that a party did not appear before the notary, or that the true agreement was different, will not normally overcome the presumption of regularity.
What This Means for Businesses and Individuals
For property owners, buyers, and transferees, this ruling is a warning against informal handling of possession. If another person remains on the property after a sale, waiver, settlement, or transfer, the owner should document the basis of that stay. A written lease, temporary occupancy agreement, caretaker arrangement, demand letter, acknowledgment, or other clear record may be crucial if an ejectment case becomes necessary.
For occupants facing ejectment, Lozano shows that not every delay by a claimant proves tolerance. If the plaintiff cannot identify specific acts of permission, the case may not properly be one for unlawful detainer. This can affect jurisdiction, prescription, available remedies, and litigation strategy in a Philippine property dispute.
For lenders and parties using property documents in loan-related transactions, the case also highlights a recurring litigation risk. Courts may respect notarized documents, but the possessory consequences of those documents must still be enforced through the correct remedy and supported by the correct facts.
Facing an Ejectment or Property Possession Dispute?
A losing party in this type of property case may face eviction, rental liability, attorney’s fees, and the loss of practical control over land or improvements. But as this ruling shows, ejectment cases can turn on technical but decisive questions: whether possession was by tolerance, whether the demand was timely, and whether the plaintiff used the correct legal remedy.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists property owners, buyers, occupants, and businesses in evaluating ejectment, unlawful detainer, forcible entry, and related civil litigation strategies. Get advice from a Makati property lawyer by contacting Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com or visiting our Makati office.