A hospital pathologist appointed by board resolution was not a corporate officer or employee because CDMC lacked by-law proof and work control.
Professionals who serve a company may fall outside both corporate-officer status and employee status when their position is not fixed in the by-laws and the company does not control how, when, and where they perform their work. For hospitals, clinics, and businesses engaging doctors, consultants, or revenue-sharing professionals, the decisive question is not the title given by management, but the real nature of control and economic dependence.
The Practical Doctrine: Appointment Is Not Employment, and Appointment Is Not Corporate Office
The ruling in Loreche-Amit draws an important line for disputes involving professional consultants, hospital-based doctors, and other specialized workers. A board resolution appointing a person to a position does not automatically make that person a corporate officer. At the same time, the fact that a person performs services for a company does not automatically make that person an employee entitled to pursue an illegal dismissal complaint before labor tribunals.
The doctrine may be stated this way: corporate-office status must come from the Corporation Code or the corporationâs by-laws, while employment status must be proven through the four-fold test, with control over the means and manner of work as the most important factor. Where the professional works at her own pace, serves other institutions, receives compensation based on output or revenue share, and is not subject to definite work hours or methods, the relationship may be treated as non-employment.
Background: A Hospital Pathologist Challenged the Recall of Her Appointment
Dr. Mary Jean P. Loreche-Amit began working with Cagayan de Oro Medical Center, Inc. sometime in May 1996 as Associate Pathologist in the Department of Laboratories. After the death of Dr. Jose N. Gaerlan, the hospitalâs Board of Directors appointed her as Chief Pathologist for a five-year term ending on May 15, 2011. Later, the Board passed a resolution recalling her appointment, prompting her to file a complaint for illegal dismissal (G.R. No. 216635, June 3, 2019).
The Labor Arbiter dismissed the complaint for lack of jurisdiction, reasoning that she was a corporate officer because she had been appointed by the Board. The NLRC and the Court of Appeals affirmed. The Supreme Court partly disagreed: it held that she was not shown to be a corporate officer. However, the Court ultimately affirmed the dismissal because she also failed to prove that she was an employee of the hospital.
Why the Doctor Was Not a Corporate Officer
The Court emphasized that a person becomes a corporate officer only when the position is provided by law or by the corporationâs by-laws. Under the Corporation Code framework discussed by the Court, the recognized officers include the president, secretary, treasurer, and such other officers as may be provided in the by-laws.
This was decisive because the by-laws of the hospital were not found in the records. Without the by-laws, there was no basis to say that the position of Pathologist or Chief Pathologist was a corporate office. The Court stated that appointment through a board resolution does not, by itself, make the appointee a corporate officer. The position must be created or recognized in the Corporation Code or the by-laws.
This matters in litigation because intra-corporate controversies are heard by regular courts, while illegal dismissal claims generally fall within labor jurisdiction. If a company wants to treat a position as a corporate office, it must be able to point to the governing legal or by-law basis for that status. A board resolution alone is not enough.
Why the Doctor Was Still Not an Employee
The Court then turned to the separate question of whether Dr. Loreche-Amit was an employee. The four-fold test asks whether the alleged employer selected and engaged the worker, paid wages, had the power of dismissal, and controlled the workerâs conduct. Among these factors, the power of control is the most significant. The key inquiry is whether the company controls not only the result to be achieved, but also the manner and means by which the work is performed.
Although the hospital selected her as Pathologist and paid her compensation equivalent to four percent of the gross receipts of the Clinical Section of the laboratory, the Court found that the element of control was not established. She worked for two other hospitals and also served other hospitals when her services were needed. This showed that she controlled her working hours and was not wholly dependent on CDMC.
The Court also considered the economic reality test. Under that approach, courts examine the totality of circumstances surrounding the true nature of the relationship, especially the workerâs economic dependence on the alleged employer. Because Dr. Loreche-Amit continued to work with other hospitals and received her four percent share regardless of how many hours she worked at CDMC, the Court concluded that she managed her own method and hours of work.
Revenue Sharing and Multiple Clients Can Weigh Against Employment
One of the most practical parts of the ruling is its treatment of compensation and work arrangement. The Court noted the rule that where a person performs work more or less at her own pleasure, in the manner she sees fit, without definite hours or conditions of work, and is compensated according to the result of her efforts rather than the amount of time spent, no employer-employee relationship exists.
This does not mean that all doctors, consultants, or professionals paid by percentage are automatically independent contractors. The Courtâs analysis remains fact-specific. A company may still be treated as an employer if it controls work schedules, imposes detailed methods, requires exclusivity, disciplines the worker as an employee, or otherwise dictates how the work must be performed. But in this case, the evidence showed professional independence rather than employment control.
Administrative Discipline Is Not Always Labor Control
Dr. Loreche-Amit also pointed to a memorandum concerning her behavior in the hospital. The Court held that this was insufficient to establish control over her work. The memorandum was administrative in character and concerned conduct within the hospital; it did not pertain to the manner and method by which she performed pathology work.
This distinction is important. A hospital or business may impose reasonable rules on conduct, safety, access, confidentiality, or facility use without necessarily becoming an employer of every professional who enters its premises. What matters for employment status is control over the work itself: how the service is performed, when it must be performed, and by what methods it must be achieved.
What This Means for Employers, Professionals, and Tax Compliance Teams
For businesses, the ruling is a warning against relying on titles. Calling someone a consultant, officer, chief, director, or appointee will not determine the case. Courts will look at by-laws, board authority, contracts, payment structure, work schedules, actual supervision, exclusivity, and economic dependence.
For professionals, the ruling shows why illegal dismissal claims require proof of employment, not merely proof that an appointment was revoked or a service relationship ended. A doctor, consultant, or specialist may have contractual remedies if the engagement was wrongfully terminated, but labor remedies require an employer-employee relationship.
For tax and compliance teams, the decision is also relevant to worker classification, although the Court did not decide a tax issue. The same factual questions that matter in labor classification often affect how businesses document consultants, professionals, and revenue-sharing arrangements. Companies should ensure that contracts, board resolutions, payroll treatment, invoices, withholding practices, and operational controls are consistent with the intended legal relationship.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists companies, medical institutions, professional service providers, and individuals in disputes involving employment status, consultant classification, corporate officer disputes, labor claims, and contract termination. If your business is facing an illegal dismissal complaint, a consultant classification issue, or a dispute over whether a role is a corporate office or employment position, our litigation and corporate counsel team can help assess the facts, structure the evidence, and develop a practical legal strategy.
For consultations on labor disputes, corporate governance conflicts, professional engagement contracts, and related compliance concerns, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.