RMC No. 98-2019 circulates RA 11439 on Islamic banks, highlighting BSP regulation, Shari’ah compliance, tax neutrality, and penalties for violations.
Banks, foreign financial institutions, investors, and businesses planning Shari’ah-compliant financing should now treat Islamic banking as a recognized Philippine banking framework, with BIR awareness of Republic Act No. 11439 and its tax-neutrality policy. RMC No. 98-2019 matters because it formally circulates the law within the tax administration system, placing internal revenue officials and affected taxpayers on notice that Islamic banking transactions are no longer merely contractual innovations, but part of a regulated banking regime supervised by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.
What RMC No. 98-2019 Changed
RMC No. 98-2019, dated September 9, 2019, publishes Republic Act No. 11439, entitled An Act Providing for the Regulation and Organization of Islamic Banks. The law was approved on August 22, 2019. The practical change is that the Philippine banking and tax system must now recognize a statutory framework for Islamic banks, Islamic banking units, and foreign Islamic banking operations in the Philippines.
For tax and accounting teams, the most important provision is the policy of tax neutrality. Republic Act No. 11439 states that the Government shall endeavor to achieve neutral tax treatment between Islamic banking transactions and equivalent conventional banking transactions within the provisions of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. This is highly relevant because Islamic finance structures may avoid interest or riba and may use profit-sharing, asset-backed, lease, sale, or investment arrangements that can look different from conventional loans for documentation and tax characterization purposes.
The circular itself is not a tax rate issuance and does not impose a new tax return, new percentage tax rate, VAT rate, documentary stamp tax rate, withholding tax rate, or filing deadline. Its importance is that it places the Islamic Banking Law into the BIR compliance environment and signals that revenue officials, taxpayers, banks, and their advisers must account for the legal status of Islamic banking when classifying transactions and reviewing tax consequences.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 98-2019 and Republic Act No. 11439
The most directly affected parties are banks and financial institutions that intend to establish Islamic banks or Islamic banking units. The Monetary Board may authorize the establishment of Islamic banks. It may also authorize conventional banks to engage in Islamic banking arrangements through a designated Islamic banking unit, provided that the bank has a system for segregating the transactions of the Islamic banking unit from its conventional banking business.
Foreign Islamic banks are also affected. Republic Act No. 11439 allows the Monetary Board, under rules and regulations it may prescribe, to authorize foreign Islamic banks to establish Islamic banking operations in the Philippines under the modes of entry allowed under the law on foreign banks. This is important for foreign banking groups, financial institutions serving Muslim markets, and investors looking at Islamic finance in the Philippines.
Business borrowers, SMEs, infrastructure proponents, real estate developers, exporters, and large corporate borrowers may also be affected where they intend to access Shari’ah-compliant funding. The policy behind the law expressly recognizes Islamic banking as a way to support financial inclusion, expand the funding base for small and medium-sized enterprises, and support large government infrastructure through risk-sharing arrangements.
Corporate shareholders and investors in Islamic banks should also pay attention. A person may not acquire shares in an Islamic bank resulting in direct or indirect ownership or control of more than ten percent of the voting stock without prior Monetary Board approval. Before Monetary Board approval, the transfer or acquisition has no legal effect and may not be recognized in the stock and transfer books of the Islamic bank or in the records of any government agency.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 98-2019 is dated September 9, 2019. It refers to Republic Act No. 11439 as approved on August 22, 2019. The law provides that it takes effect fifteen days after publication in the Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation. Because the tax circular does not state a specific publication date, affected banks and advisers should verify the relevant publication record when determining the exact statutory effectivity date for a specific compliance position.
Islamic banks must be supervised and regulated by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. They must comply with Shari’ah principles and constitute a Shari’ah advisory council composed of persons qualified in Shari’ah or with knowledge or experience in Shari’ah and in banking, finance, law, or related disciplines. The council renders advice and reviews applications of Shari’ah principles, but it must not directly involve itself in bank operations or activities that may give rise to conflicts of interest.
Islamic banks must comply with corporate and banking requirements applicable to private corporations engaged in banking. The capitalization requirement of an Islamic bank must be equal to that prescribed by the Bangko Sentral for a universal bank. Islamic banking units within conventional banks must be operated and managed under a structure that is properly disclosed and segregated from the parent bank’s conventional operations.
For compliance officers and accountants, the searchable issues are Islamic banking tax neutrality Philippines, RA 11439 tax treatment, Shari’ah banking Philippines, Islamic banking unit compliance, and BIR RMC 98-2019. These phrases matter because the core problem is not merely licensing; it is how Shari’ah-compliant transactions will be documented, booked, reported, and defended if questioned in a tax audit.
Tax Treatment: Why Tax Neutrality Matters
The tax-neutrality clause is the main tax issue in Republic Act No. 11439. In conventional banking, tax analysis often starts with interest, loan documentation, security arrangements, and the ordinary treatment of banking income. In Islamic banking, transactions may be structured around risk sharing or Shari’ah-compliant commercial arrangements rather than interest. Without a tax-neutral approach, economically equivalent financing could be taxed differently simply because the legal documentation uses a Shari’ah-compliant structure.
For CFOs and tax managers, this means the tax analysis should not stop at labels. A transaction described as Islamic finance, profit-sharing, leasing, sale-based financing, or investment participation must still be reviewed under the National Internal Revenue Code, BIR rules, and the specific terms of the contract. The policy is neutrality between Islamic banking transactions and equivalent conventional banking transactions, but the circular does not by itself provide a table of tax rates, documentary stamp tax rules, VAT exemptions, or withholding tax classifications for every possible Islamic finance product.
Businesses using Islamic banking should therefore prepare documentation showing the conventional equivalent of the financing arrangement, the accounting treatment adopted, the income recognition position, and the tax basis for neutrality. This is especially important for tax audits, related-party reviews, and transactions involving asset transfers, leases, deferred payments, or investment returns.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
Republic Act No. 11439 provides sanctions for violations. Any director, officer, employee, auditor, or agent of an Islamic bank found guilty of an act or omission in violation of the law and its implementing rules and regulations may be subject to sanctions and penalties under Sections 34, 35, 36, and 37 of Republic Act No. 7653. The law also provides for a fine not exceeding One Million Pesos or imprisonment of not more than five years, or both, at the discretion of the court, without prejudice to administrative and criminal sanctions under existing banking laws and regulations.
For shareholders, the more than ten percent voting stock threshold is a key compliance trigger. A covered acquisition without prior Monetary Board approval has no legal effect before approval and cannot be recognized in the stock and transfer books or in government records. This makes ownership planning, due diligence, and regulatory approval essential before closing any substantial equity transaction involving an Islamic bank.
Practical Steps for Banks, Investors, and Businesses
First, banks planning to offer Islamic banking products should determine whether they will operate as a full Islamic bank or as a designated Islamic banking unit. The distinction matters because a conventional bank operating an Islamic banking unit must maintain segregation between Islamic banking transactions and conventional banking business.
Second, institutions should prepare a Shari’ah governance framework. This includes identifying qualified members of the Shari’ah advisory council, defining their review function, and preventing conflicts of interest. The compliance file should show that Shari’ah review is real, documented, and independent from day-to-day bank operations.
Third, tax and accounting teams should map each Islamic banking product to its closest conventional banking equivalent. For each product, the business should identify expected income, charges, asset transfers, payment timing, withholding tax exposure, VAT or gross receipts tax issues, documentary stamp tax issues, and accounting entries. This is the practical way to support a tax-neutral position during a BIR review.
Fourth, investors acquiring shares in an Islamic bank must monitor the more than ten percent voting stock threshold. Transaction documents should include conditions precedent for Monetary Board approval where required. Closing, recognition in the stock and transfer books, and government filings should not proceed in a manner inconsistent with the statutory approval requirement.
Fifth, businesses seeking Islamic financing should not assume that Shari’ah-compliant financing is automatically tax-free or exempt. RMC No. 98-2019 and Republic Act No. 11439 point to neutral treatment, not blanket exemption. The safer approach is to review each financing structure before signing and to document the tax basis of the intended treatment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 98-2019 is important for banks, investors, and businesses because it connects Islamic banking regulation with tax compliance. The key issue is not only whether Islamic banking is allowed, but how its transactions will be documented, reported, and defended before regulators and the BIR.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists banks, fintech companies, investors, corporate borrowers, and business owners with BIR compliance, tax risk review, corporate structuring, regulatory documentation, and transaction support. For guidance on RMC No. 98-2019, Republic Act No. 11439, Islamic banking tax neutrality, and Philippine business tax compliance, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.