A company that repeatedly pays an officer’s promised interest may be deemed to have ratified the obligation and cannot later deny corporate liability.

A corporation cannot escape a financial obligation by later calling its officer’s commitment unauthorized when the company itself repeatedly paid the obligation. For business owners, lenders, investors, and corporate officers, the lesson is direct: a company’s conduct may ratify what its paperwork does not expressly approve, and repeated payments can turn an alleged mistake into enforceable corporate liability.

The Doctrine: Ratification by Repeated Corporate Payment

The ruling establishes a practical corporate law doctrine that may be called ratification by repeated payment. When a corporate officer makes a commitment in the course of business, and the corporation thereafter performs that commitment more than once, the corporation may be treated as having adopted the officer’s act as its own. The company cannot simply disown the officer later by saying that the officer lacked authority, especially where the other party relied on the officer’s position and the company’s own subsequent conduct.

This doctrine matters beyond ordinary contract disputes. It affects banks, developers, borrowers, investors, construction companies, treasurers, finance officers, and corporate boards. In commercial transactions, the legally decisive evidence may not be a board resolution alone. It may also be the company’s pattern of conduct: letters sent by senior officers, payments made by the company, silence after performance, and continued treatment of the officer as a person entrusted with corporate affairs.

Background: A Bond Financing Dispute Over Additional Interest

Terp Construction Corporation planned to develop housing and condominium projects known as Margarita Eastville and Margarita Plaza. To finance these projects, Terp Construction, Home Insurance Guaranty Corporation, and Planters Development Bank arranged the issuance of bonds worth P400 million, called the Margarita Project Participation Certificates or Margarita Bonds. Planters Bank acted as trustee, while Home Insurance Guaranty Corporation guaranteed payment of the bond value at maturity plus 8.5 percent annual interest.

Banco Filipino purchased P100 million worth of Margarita Bonds. It later claimed that Terp Construction, through its Senior Vice President Alberto Escalona, committed to pay additional interest beyond the guaranteed 8.5 percent. Two letters were central to the case: one referring to a guaranteed floor rate of 16.5 percent, and another stating that the yield for the investment would be 15.5 percent, with Terp Construction paying the difference between the approved yield and the promised yield. The case reached the Supreme Court after the Court of Appeals ordered Terp Construction to pay Banco Filipino P18,104,431.33 in interest differentials (G.R. No. 221771, September 18, 2019).

Why Terp Construction Denied Liability

Terp Construction argued that it never became liable for the additional interest. It claimed there was no written contract binding it to pay anything beyond the guaranteed 8.5 percent. It also argued that Escalona, as senior vice president, had no authority to bind the corporation to the additional interest commitment. According to Terp Construction, any prior payments it made were merely erroneous payments and could not be treated as ratification.

The Regional Trial Court initially sided with Terp Construction. It found insufficient evidence that the corporation was obligated to pay the interest differentials and held that Escalona’s acts were not binding because they had supposedly not been ratified. The Court of Appeals reversed, finding that Terp Construction had agreed to pay additional interest and that its subsequent payments confirmed the obligation.

The Supreme Court’s Ruling: The Company Was Bound

The Supreme Court denied Terp Construction’s petition and sustained the Court of Appeals. It held that Terp Construction categorically committed itself to pay interest over and above the guaranteed 8.5 percent per annum. The Court gave weight to the letters sent by Escalona and, more importantly, to Terp Construction’s conduct after those letters were issued.

The decisive point was that Terp Construction did not deny that it paid Banco Filipino the additional interest during the holding period of the Margarita Bonds, not once but twice. For the Court, those payments were not legally meaningless. They amounted to ratification of Escalona’s acts. The Court rejected the defense that the payments were merely erroneous, stating in substance that corporations are bound by errors of their own making.

Actual Authority, Implied Authority, and Apparent Authority

The ruling is also important because it explains how corporate authority works in real transactions. A corporation acts through its board of directors, but the board may validly delegate corporate powers to officers, committees, or agents. That authority may be actual or apparent. Actual authority may be express, when clearly delegated, or implied, when shown by prior acts ratified by the corporation or by benefits accepted by the corporation.

Here, the Court found that Terp Construction’s repeated payment of the additional interest supported ratification. Even assuming that Escalona did not originally have express authority, the corporation’s own conduct adopted the commitment. By paying what he promised, Terp Construction made it reasonable to treat the commitment as corporate, not merely personal or unauthorized.

The Court also found that Escalona had apparent authority. Apparent authority arises when a corporation holds out an officer as having power to act, or acquiesces in acts of a particular nature with actual or constructive knowledge. Banco Filipino relied on Escalona’s apparent authority because he was Terp Construction’s senior vice president. That reliance was strengthened when Terp Construction actually paid the additional interest during the bond term.

Why the Rule 45 Issue Did Not Save Terp Construction

Terp Construction also tried to reopen factual findings by pointing out that the trial court and the Court of Appeals disagreed. The Supreme Court acknowledged that, generally, only questions of law may be raised in a Rule 45 petition. While conflicting factual findings may sometimes justify review, a party cannot merely invoke an exception. It must demonstrate and prove why factual review is necessary.

The Court emphasized that the Court of Appeals is itself a trier of facts. Its factual findings may bind the Supreme Court even if they differ from the trial court’s findings, so long as they are supported by the record or by substantial evidence. In this case, the Court found no error in the Court of Appeals’ factual conclusions.

What This Means for Business Owners and Corporate Officers

For business owners, the ruling is a warning against informal financial commitments followed by actual performance. If a senior officer promises a commercial term and the company pays according to that promise, the company may later be prevented from denying the obligation. A board cannot always rely on the absence of a formal resolution if the corporation’s conduct tells the market that the officer had authority.

For lenders and investors, the ruling provides a path to enforce obligations where corporate conduct confirms the commitment. Written communications from senior officers, actual payments, and continued corporate acquiescence may establish ratification or apparent authority. This is especially relevant in financing arrangements, bond issuances, project finance, loan restructuring, investment yield commitments, and settlement negotiations.

For corporate counsel and finance teams, the practical control is documentation. Companies should define who may promise interest, yields, discounts, penalties, extensions, guarantees, and payment terms. If an officer acts beyond authority, the corporation must promptly repudiate the act in writing and avoid conduct that can be read as acceptance. Making partial or repeated payments while remaining silent may later become the strongest evidence against the company.

Practical Takeaway

The most consequential part of the ruling is not merely that Banco Filipino recovered the interest differentials. It is that corporate liability may arise from the company’s own pattern of performance. A corporation that repeatedly pays an obligation cannot casually recharacterize those payments as mistakes after a dispute arises. In commercial litigation, courts will look not only at formal authority but also at how the corporation behaved when the transaction was being performed.

Businesses involved in financing, construction, banking, real estate development, and investment arrangements should treat this case as a reminder that internal authority limits must be matched by external discipline. A company that allows officers to appear authorized, and then performs what those officers promised, may be bound by the promise.

Need Help With a Corporate, Banking, or Contract Dispute?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises companies, investors, creditors, and individuals in commercial litigation, contract enforcement, corporate authority disputes, collection cases, and banking-related claims. If your company is facing a dispute involving unauthorized commitments, board authority, officer liability, loan terms, interest claims, or enforcement of commercial obligations, our litigation team can help assess your position and build a strategy grounded in Philippine law. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our lawyers.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *