RMC No. 11-2020 clarifies tax amnesty rules for withdrawn FAN, FLD, and FDDA protests, TAR filing, and invalid appeals that make assessments delinquent.

Taxpayers seeking to avail of tax amnesty on delinquencies must treat April 23, 2020 as a critical cut-off date: protests or appeals involving FAN, FLD, or FDDA assessments must be validly withdrawn on or before that date, and the Tax Amnesty Return must be filed within the applicable availment period unless the limited 30-day extension applies. RMC No. 11-2020 matters now because it clarifies when a disputed assessment becomes a delinquent account that may qualify for tax amnesty, and when a taxpayer’s amnesty payment is not enough without the proper filing of documentary requirements.

What RMC No. 11-2020 Changed

RMC No. 11-2020 further clarifies the rules on Tax Amnesty on Delinquencies under Revenue Regulations No. 4-2019, which implemented Title IV of Republic Act No. 11213, also known as the Tax Amnesty Act. It amends and supplements RMC No. 57-2019, specifically on the treatment of protested assessments, appealed Final Decisions on Disputed Assessment, and the filing requirements for the Tax Amnesty Return.

The most important clarification is that tax liabilities covered by a Final Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment may qualify for tax amnesty on delinquencies if the taxpayer withdrew the protest or appeal on or before April 23, 2020, and if the delinquent account pertains to taxable year 2017 and prior years.

This is significant for taxpayers searching for guidance on tax amnesty on delinquent accounts, withdrawal of FAN or FLD protest, FDDA appeal withdrawal, BIR tax amnesty return filing, and the April 23, 2020 tax amnesty deadline. The circular does not merely restate the amnesty rules. It clarifies when a disputed assessment is treated as though no protest or appeal had been filed, thereby allowing the assessment to become final, executory, and delinquent for purposes of the amnesty program.

Who Is Affected by the Clarification

RMC No. 11-2020 directly affects taxpayers with BIR assessments involving taxable year 2017 and prior years, particularly those who received a FAN, FLD, or FDDA and either filed a protest or pursued an appeal. It is particularly relevant to corporations, SMEs, business owners, accounting departments, CFOs, tax managers, and in-house counsel handling old BIR assessments that may be candidates for tax amnesty on delinquencies.

It also affects taxpayers whose protests or appeals may have been defective. Under the clarification, certain defective protests and appeals are treated as invalid, meaning they do not stop the running of the 30-day period to protest or appeal. Once that 30-day period lapses, the assessment becomes final and executory and therefore delinquent.

For corporate taxpayers, this matters because a pending assessment may appear to be disputed, but if the protest or appeal is invalid, the assessment may already be final. That legal status can determine whether the account may be treated as delinquent and whether tax amnesty on delinquencies is available.

Withdrawn Protests and FDDA Appeals May Qualify for Tax Amnesty

RMC No. 11-2020 amends Q22 of RMC No. 57-2019 by confirming that tax liabilities covered by a FAN, FLD, or FDDA that were timely protested or disputed may be considered delinquent accounts qualified for tax amnesty if the protest or appeal was withdrawn at any time on or before April 23, 2020.

The clarification applies only if the withdrawal results in the tax liabilities reverting back to being delinquent on or before April 24, 2019, and if the delinquent account pertains to taxable year 2017 and prior years. In practical terms, a taxpayer cannot rely on withdrawal alone. The taxpayer must also check the taxable year involved and whether the assessment legally became delinquent by the relevant cut-off.

The circular also clarifies that the last day of the one-year availment period for tax amnesty on delinquencies under RR No. 4-2019 was April 23, 2020. That date is central to the treatment of withdrawn protests and appeals.

Effect of Withdrawing a Protest or Appeal

Upon withdrawal of a protest to the FAN or FLD, or withdrawal of an appeal to the FDDA, the effect is that it is as if no protest or appeal had been filed. The assessment contained in the FAN, FLD, or FDDA becomes final and executory, and therefore delinquent, upon the lapse of the 30-day period reckoned from receipt of the FAN, FLD, or FDDA.

RMC No. 11-2020 further states that, for this treatment to apply, the FAN, FLD, or FDDA whose protest or appeal was subsequently withdrawn should have been received, at the latest, on March 25, 2019, in order to be considered delinquent on or before April 24, 2019.

This March 25, 2019 date is a key compliance marker. Taxpayers reviewing old assessments should confirm the exact date of receipt of the FAN, FLD, or FDDA. A difference of even one day may affect whether the assessment became delinquent by the relevant cut-off date.

Payment Alone Is Not Full Compliance Without TAR Filing

RMC No. 11-2020 also amends Q29 of RMC No. 57-2019. It clarifies that a taxpayer is not considered to have fully complied with the requirements of RR No. 4-2019 merely because the tax amnesty amount was paid on the last day of the one-year availment period. The Tax Amnesty Return, together with complete documentary requirements, must also be filed or submitted to the concerned office within the one-year availment period.

However, the circular provides a limited relief for delinquent taxpayers who secured the Certificate of Tax Delinquencies or Tax Liabilities and the endorsement of the Acceptance Payment Form, and who paid the amnesty tax due on April 23, 2020, the last day of the availment period. These taxpayers are given an extended period of 30 days to submit the complete documentary requirements.

This means that taxpayers who paid on April 23, 2020 should not assume that payment alone completed the amnesty process. They must verify that the Tax Amnesty Return and all supporting documents were filed within the required period or, where applicable, within the extended 30-day period.

Invalid Protests and Appeals That Make Assessments Final and Delinquent

RMC No. 11-2020 adds Q40 to RMC No. 57-2019 and identifies specific instances where a protest to a FAN or FLD, or an appeal to an FDDA, will be considered invalid. An invalid protest or appeal makes the assessment final and executory and therefore delinquent after the lapse of the applicable 30-day period.

The circular identifies six instances of invalid protest or appeal. First, the protest to the FAN or FLD was filed beyond 30 days from receipt of the FAN or FLD. Second, the appeal to the FDDA was filed beyond 30 days from receipt of the FDDA. Third, the protest to the FAN or FLD was not filed with the duly authorized representative of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue who signed the FAN or FLD. Fourth, the appeal to the FDDA was not filed with the Office of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. Fifth, the protest or appeal failed to state the applicable law, rules and regulations, or jurisprudence on which it is based. Sixth, in a request for reinvestigation, the protest did not specify the newly discovered or additional evidence that the taxpayer intended to present.

The compliance consequence is severe. An invalid protest or appeal does not toll the running of the 30-day prescriptive period to file the protest or appeal. Accordingly, the assessment becomes final and executory after the lapse of that 30-day period, reckoned from receipt of the FAN, FLD, or FDDA.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 11-2020 does not create a new penalty rate. Its risk lies in the loss of the tax amnesty benefit or the finality of the assessment. If the taxpayer fails to properly withdraw a protest or appeal, fails to comply with the deadline, files an invalid protest or appeal, or fails to submit the Tax Amnesty Return and complete documentary requirements, the taxpayer may lose the ability to treat the account as covered by the amnesty program.

For businesses, the practical exposure is that the underlying assessment may remain collectible as a final and executory delinquent account, without the benefit of amnesty treatment. This can affect financial reporting, tax reserves, audit strategy, and settlement planning with the BIR.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Accounting Teams

Businesses should immediately review all BIR assessments for taxable year 2017 and prior years that involved a FAN, FLD, or FDDA. The review should identify the date of receipt, whether a protest or appeal was filed, whether it was validly filed within 30 days, and whether it was withdrawn on or before April 23, 2020.

Accounting teams should also verify whether the taxpayer secured the Certificate of Tax Delinquencies or Tax Liabilities, obtained endorsement of the Acceptance Payment Form, paid the amnesty tax due on April 23, 2020, and filed the Tax Amnesty Return with complete documentary requirements within the prescribed period or the limited 30-day extension.

In-house counsel and tax advisors should pay special attention to the technical validity of protests and appeals. A protest that does not state the applicable law, rules and regulations, or jurisprudence may be invalid. A request for reinvestigation that fails to specify newly discovered or additional evidence may also be invalid. These defects can cause the assessment to become final and executory despite the taxpayer’s belief that the case remained disputed.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 11-2020 shows that BIR tax amnesty compliance is not just about payment. It requires a careful legal review of assessment dates, protest validity, appeal status, withdrawal timing, and documentary filing. A missed deadline or defective filing can determine whether a taxpayer receives amnesty treatment or faces a final and executory delinquent assessment.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR assessments, preparing tax amnesty compliance documents, assessing the validity of protests and appeals, and managing tax controversy strategy. For assistance with tax amnesty on delinquencies, BIR assessments, FAN, FLD, FDDA, and related tax compliance issues, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *