State university employees must refund unauthorized year-end incentives despite good faith when COA finds no legal basis under Republic Act No. 8292.

Government employees who receive benefits later disallowed by the Commission on Audit may still be ordered to return the money, even if they acted in good faith and had no part in approving the payment. For state universities and colleges, savings and special trust funds cannot be treated as a general pool for employee bonuses: they may be used only for purposes tied to instruction, research, extension, or similar academic programs, and only through the proper governing board process.

Why This Ruling Matters to Public Employees and State Universities

The case arose from the payment of year-end incentives of up to P40,000.00 each to officials and employees of Cagayan State University. The payments were authorized by the university president through a special order and were sourced from unused appropriated income for fiscal year 2014. The special order itself stated that employees would refund the amount if the Commission on Audit later found the incentive not in order.

COA issued a Notice of Disallowance for P7,688,000.00, finding that the payment had legal infirmities because it was not in accordance with the Higher Education Modernization Act of 1997, or Republic Act No. 8292. Fr. Ranhilio Callangan Aquino and Dr. Pablo F. Narag challenged the disallowance for themselves and purportedly on behalf of permanent employees of Cagayan State University. The Supreme Court, in Fr. Aquino v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 227715, November 3, 2020), denied the petition and sustained COA’s disallowance.

The Core Doctrine: University Savings Are Not Bonus Funds

The central doctrine is that special trust funds and accumulated savings of state universities and colleges are purpose-limited public funds. They may not be used for employee incentives merely because funds remain unspent at the end of the year. Under Republic Act No. 8292, income generated by a state university or college may be retained and disbursed by the Board of Regents or Board of Trustees, but the allowable purposes are limited to instruction, research, extension, or other programs and projects of the university or college.

The Court rejected the argument that rewarding faculty and employees for loyalty, efficiency, or service automatically qualifies as a university purpose. While employee morale and institutional loyalty may be legitimate administrative concerns, they do not by themselves transform a general year-end cash incentive into an expense necessary for instruction, research, extension, or a comparable academic program.

The ruling is particularly important for public sector employees who search for answers to questions such as: Can COA make me refund benefits I received in good faith? Can a state university give bonuses from savings? Are employees personally liable for COA disallowances? The Court’s answer is sobering: if the payment has no legal basis, receipt in good faith will not always protect the payee from refund.

CHED Guidelines Did Not Override the Statute

The petitioners relied on CHED Memorandum Order No. 020-11, which referred to the possible use of unexpended amounts or accumulated savings for additional incentives. The Court held, however, that an administrative issuance must be read consistently with its enabling law. A memorandum order cannot enlarge the statutory authority granted by Republic Act No. 8292.

Thus, even if the CHED memorandum mentioned incentives, that reference could not be understood as blanket authority to distribute public funds as year-end bonuses without regard to statutory purpose. The governing board’s discretion is not absolute. It remains confined by the law creating and regulating state universities and colleges.

The Board of Regents Approval Requirement

The Court also found a separate procedural defect. Even assuming that incentives could be paid from accumulated savings under the CHED guidelines, the procedure required consultation with the Administrative Council, recommendation by the university president, and approval by the Board of Regents or Board of Trustees.

In Cagayan State University’s case, the special order showed that the incentive was agreed upon by Campus Executive Officers during an academic and administrative council meeting. The petitioners failed to show that the Board of Regents approved the payment, or that the university president had been properly delegated authority subject to board approval. Because the required board approval was not shown, the disbursement was considered illegal and irregular.

Good Faith Did Not Excuse Refund by the Payees

The most consequential part of the ruling for ordinary government employees is the refund rule. The petitioners argued that they should not be required to return the incentives because they received the amounts in good faith, relied on the apparent validity of the special order, and did not participate in approving the payment.

The Court applied the Madera guidelines and ruled that the payees were not excused from returning the disallowed year-end incentives. The personal liability of the payees was treated as a civil obligation based on solutio indebiti, which applies when something is received without legal basis and must be returned. Allowing the employees to keep the unauthorized incentive would result in unjust enrichment at the government’s expense.

This is a critical distinction. Good faith may matter in determining the liability of approving and certifying officers, especially where bad faith, malice, or gross negligence is alleged. But for payees who received money without legal entitlement, the obligation to return may still arise even without wrongdoing.

Approving and Certifying Officers May Face Solidary Liability

The Court also discussed the liability of officials who approved or certified the disbursement. Where approving and certifying officers fail to exercise the diligence of a good father of a family, they may be held solidarily liable to return the illegally disbursed funds to the extent of the net disallowed amount.

This matters for university presidents, accountants, finance officers, administrative officers, and board officials. Public funds cannot be disbursed based on broad institutional convenience or internal practice. The legal basis, fund source, statutory purpose, and approval procedure must all be established before payment is made.

Due Process in COA Disallowance Proceedings

The petitioners did obtain a partial procedural victory. The Court found that COA did not properly serve the Notice of Disallowance. Under COA rules, a notice must be served on each person held liable; where there are several payees, service to the accountant may constitute constructive service to all payees. In this case, the accountant was not properly served, and rumors or unconfirmed talk about a disallowance did not amount to constructive notice.

Because the lack of proper service prevented the petitioners from appealing or seeking reconsideration before the disallowance became final, the Court excused their direct resort to certiorari. However, this procedural defect did not save the incentives. The Court still denied the petition because COA did not gravely abuse its discretion in finding the payment illegal and irregular.

Representative Suits Require Real Authority and Proper Parties

The ruling also clarified an important procedural point: an unincorporated association without juridical personality cannot sue in its own name or be represented in court as if it were a legal entity. The petitioners claimed to represent the Permanent Employees of Cagayan State University, but failed to establish that this association legally existed or that they had proper authority to represent it.

The Court held that the real parties in interest should have been impleaded. The petitioners’ personal legal standing could not cure the association’s lack of juridical capacity. For employee groups, homeowners’ groups, and other informal associations, this is a practical warning: before filing suit, the identity, legal existence, and authority of the group or its representatives must be clearly established.

Practical Impact for Employees, Agencies, and Public Institutions

For public employees, the decision means that receiving a benefit through payroll or bank deposit does not guarantee that the money may be kept permanently. If COA later determines that the payment lacked statutory basis, the employee may still be required to refund the amount, even if the employee did not request the benefit or participate in its approval.

For state universities and colleges, the ruling is a warning against using accumulated savings, unused appropriated income, or special trust funds for broad-based personnel incentives without a clear statutory basis and board approval. The phrase


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *