When Court Evidence Disappears: Lost Drug Exhibits Can Cost Court Personnel Their Careers

Court personnel may be dismissed when lost drug evidence compromises pending criminal cases, with clerks liable for gross neglect of duty. Court personnel who mishandle evidence can be dismissed from government service when their negligence compromises pending criminal cases, especially where the missing exhibits are the very drugs needed to prove the offense. For litigants, […]

Congress Can Restructure GOCC Offices Without Violating Security of Tenure

Congress may validly shorten GOCC officials’ terms and centralize compensation reform when done in good faith for fiscal discipline and public accountability. Congress may shorten the terms, restructure the offices, and rationalize the compensation of government-owned or controlled corporation officials when the changes are made in good faith, supported by a clear public policy, and […]

State University Employees Must Refund Unauthorized Year-End Incentives Despite Good Faith

State university employees must refund unauthorized year-end incentives despite good faith when COA finds no legal basis under Republic Act No. 8292. Government employees who receive benefits later disallowed by the Commission on Audit may still be ordered to return the money, even if they acted in good faith and had no part in approving […]

Operative Fact Cutoff: When Void Tax Incentives Stop Binding LGUs

Void tax diversion laws bind only until finality; FDCP lost the right to collect cinema amusement taxes after October 15, 2019. Void tax diversion schemes may still be honored for past transactions, but only until the Supreme Court’s final cutoff date. Under the Operative Fact Cutoff Doctrine, cinema operators were no longer required to remit […]

Notarized Document Presumption: Winning Property Disputes in Court

Notarized deeds stand unless forgery is clearly proved; unnotarized land sales may still bind parties in Philippine property disputes. The Notarized Document Presumption can decide a family property dispute when heirs attack an old deed as forged but cannot present clear, convincing proof. For landowners, heirs, and buyers of inherited property, this ruling confirms a […]