The Supreme Court voided SEC rules requiring separate accreditation for CPAs auditing regulated companies, holding that accountancy regulation belongs to the PRBA.
Certified public accountants may not be forced to secure a separate SEC accreditation before performing audit work when Congress has already placed the licensing and regulation of the accountancy profession under the Professional Regulatory Board of Accountancy. For CPAs, audit firms, corporations, and tax professionals, the ruling draws a clear line: the SEC may regulate corporations and securities filings, but it cannot create an additional professional licensing barrier for accountants without a specific statutory grant.
The Doctrine: Regulatory Power Over Companies Is Not Power Over Professionals
The central doctrine of the case is the profession-specific delegation rule. When Congress assigns regulation of a licensed profession to a specific professional board, another agency cannot impose its own licensing or accreditation requirement merely because that profession performs work connected with entities under the agency’s jurisdiction.
This matters beyond accountancy. Government agencies often receive broad powers to regulate an industry, supervise compliance, or prescribe documentary requirements. But broad regulatory language does not automatically authorize an agency to regulate the qualifications, discipline, or right to practice of licensed professionals who appear before it or whose work is submitted to it.
Background: Why CPAs Challenged the SEC Accreditation Requirement
The controversy arose from SEC issuances requiring external auditors of certain SEC-regulated entities, including corporations issuing registered securities and those holding secondary licenses, to be accredited by the SEC. The challenged rules included Paragraph 3, Rule 68 of the implementing rules of the Securities Regulation Code and SEC Memorandum Circular No. 13-2009. The case reached the Supreme Court after the Regional Trial Court declared the SEC measures invalid (G.R. No. 246027, June 21, 2022).
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISS…
1Accountants Party-List, Inc., together with several CPAs, argued that the SEC had no authority to regulate the accountancy profession. They contended that the Philippine Accountancy Act of 2004 gives that power to the Professional Regulatory Board of Accountancy. They also challenged the SEC requirement as an added burden on CPAs who were already licensed to practice their profession.
The SEC defended the issuances by invoking its authority under the Securities Regulation Code and the Corporation Code. It argued that it had jurisdiction over corporations, could regulate persons to ensure compliance, could issue accounting rules, and could require corporations to submit financial statements certified by independent CPAs. The SEC also relied on a memorandum of agreement involving other regulators and the accountancy board.
What the Supreme Court Held
The Supreme Court denied the SEC’s petition and affirmed the nullification of the questioned issuances. It held that the provisions relied upon by the SEC primarily concern corporations, partnerships, associations, securities issuers, and the securities market. They do not expressly authorize the SEC to regulate individual CPAs or to impose an additional accreditation requirement as a condition for practicing accountancy.
The Court emphasized that the SEC’s jurisdiction over corporations does not carry with it the power to restrict, even slightly, the practice of accountancy. A CPA’s statutory audit work is part of the practice of public accountancy. If the law already authorizes CPAs to perform such work under the supervision of the accountancy board, the SEC cannot add another gatekeeping requirement unless Congress clearly gives it that power.
The accreditation requirement was treated as a licensing burden. It was not merely an internal filing rule or a corporate reporting formality. CPAs who failed to comply could face fines, suspension, delisting, or practical exclusion from auditing covered entities. In substance, the requirement controlled who could practice a particular facet of accountancy.
Why the Accountancy Board’s Authority Prevailed
The Philippine Accountancy Act gives the Professional Regulatory Board of Accountancy the power to supervise the registration, licensure, and practice of accountancy in the Philippines. It also authorizes the Board to monitor audit quality, adopt rules, and implement registration requirements for CPAs, firms, and partnerships engaged in public accountancy.
For the Court, that statutory scheme was decisive. The SEC’s power to prescribe accounting rules for corporate disclosures did not include the power to decide which CPAs may perform external audit services. One power concerns the content and form of corporate financial reporting. The other concerns professional licensing. They are related in practice, but distinct in law.
The Court also rejected reliance on the memorandum of agreement. A government board cannot transfer a power delegated to it by Congress unless the law permits such further delegation. A private or inter-agency agreement cannot validate what the statute does not authorize. The legal maxim applied was that delegated power cannot be delegated.
Tax and Compliance Significance
Although the dispute centered on SEC accreditation, the ruling is important for tax professionals because the statutory definition of public accountancy includes work connected with financial statements, audit reports, accounting records, and the preparation of income tax returns when related to accounting procedures. Many businesses rely on CPAs not only for SEC filings, but also for tax compliance, tax reporting, audit support, and representations involving accounting-related tax matters.
The decision protects professionals and businesses from overlapping accreditation regimes that are not clearly authorized by law. A corporation may still be subject to SEC reporting rules. A CPA may still be subject to the accountancy law, professional standards, and disciplinary authority of the proper board. But the SEC cannot use its corporate supervision powers to create a separate licensing layer for CPAs.
Practical Impact for Corporations, CPAs, and Audit Firms
For corporations, the ruling clarifies that compliance duties remain, but the SEC cannot impose an invalid professional accreditation requirement on the external auditor as a condition for the auditor’s practice. Companies should still ensure that their financial statements are prepared, audited, and filed in accordance with applicable corporate, securities, accounting, and tax rules.
For CPAs and audit firms, the ruling is a strong protection against agency overreach. A licensed professional cannot be subjected to a second licensing regime simply because their work is submitted to or used by a regulator. Any agency that wishes to impose such a requirement must point to a clear legal basis, not merely a general power to regulate filings, supervise regulated entities, or ensure compliance.
For regulated businesses, the decision also encourages a more careful review of agency circulars, memorandum requirements, accreditation rules, penalties, and filing conditions. Not every administrative requirement is valid merely because it was issued by a regulator. The key questions are whether the agency has jurisdiction over the person being regulated, whether Congress granted the specific authority being exercised, and whether the rule imposes a licensing barrier beyond what the law allows.
How This Helps Clients Facing Regulatory Requirements
The broader lesson is that regulatory compliance should be taken seriously, but agency demands should also be tested against the statute. Businesses and professionals sometimes comply with circulars, accreditations, penalties, or administrative requirements because they appear official. This ruling shows that courts may strike down rules when an agency goes beyond the authority granted by Congress.
For tax, accounting, securities, and corporate compliance matters, the decision is especially relevant where multiple regulators appear to claim overlapping authority. A company may deal with the SEC, BIR, PRC, professional boards, and industry regulators at the same time. The legal question is not simply which agency is interested in the transaction, but which agency has been given the power to regulate the particular act, person, or profession involved.
Need Help With SEC, Tax, or Professional Regulation Issues?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, professionals, audit firms, and business owners in reviewing regulatory requirements, challenging ultra vires agency actions, and building practical compliance strategies for SEC, tax, corporate, and professional licensing matters. For legal guidance tailored to your business or professional practice, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.