RMC No. 4-2023 clarifies that the 20% PERA early withdrawal penalty is based on gross income, without deducting losses from other sub-accounts.

PERA contributors, administrators, and tax teams must compute the 20% early withdrawal penalty on the gross income earned by the Personal Equity and Retirement Account, not on net income after losses. Under RMC No. 4-2023, a loss in one PERA sub-account cannot be used to reduce the income earned in another sub-account when determining the base amount for the 20% penalty on unqualified early withdrawals. This matters immediately for banks, trust entities, investment administrators, corporate finance teams, and individuals using PERA as a retirement and tax-planning vehicle because an incorrect computation can understate the amount to be withheld and remitted to the BIR.

What Changed Under RMC No. 4-2023

RMC No. 4-2023 clarifies the base amount for the imposition of the 20% penalty relative to the early withdrawal of PERA assets, accounts, and sub-accounts classified as unqualified. The key rule is that the 20% penalty is applied to the total gross income earned by the PERA, and not to a reduced or net amount after deducting losses from other sub-accounts.

The circular explains that the early withdrawal penalty is composed of the 20% of the gross income earned by the PERA for the entire duration and the 5% tax credit availed. This applies when the withdrawal is made under circumstances that are not among the qualified early withdrawal grounds allowed under the PERA rules. In practical terms, the BIR is making clear that a PERA investor cannot use a loss in one sub-account to lower the penalty base arising from income earned in other PERA investments.

This is particularly important for PERA accounts with multiple investment products or sub-accounts. A contributor may hold, for example, a money market fund, a bond fund, and an equity fund within a single PERA account. If one investment earns income and another suffers a loss, the loss does not reduce the gross income used to compute the 20% penalty.

Who Is Affected by the PERA Early Withdrawal Penalty Clarification

RMC No. 4-2023 affects PERA contributors who make early withdrawals, PERA Administrators, banks, trust companies, investment product providers, compliance officers, tax accountants, and financial institutions administering retirement accounts. It is also relevant to CFOs and corporate accountants advising executives or employees on the tax consequences of early PERA withdrawal.

The issuance is especially relevant where PERA assets are divided into accounts and sub-accounts. Under the circular, PERA assets refer to the aggregate assets in the PERA at any one time, including the cash funds and PERA investment products into which they are invested and reinvested, as well as all income earned from those assets. An account refers to the main account corresponding to one product category of PERA investment products as enumerated under Annex A of the PERA Rules. A sub-account refers to the specific PERA investment from different issuers under the same category.

Tax practitioners searching for PERA early withdrawal penalty, 20% PERA penalty, unqualified PERA withdrawal, PERA tax credit clawback, and RMC 4-2023 should focus on this point: the penalty base is gross income, and losses are not deducted from that base.

Qualified vs. Unqualified Early Withdrawal

RMC No. 4-2023 distinguishes between qualified early withdrawal and unqualified early withdrawal. A qualified early withdrawal is a withdrawal, whether in full or in part, that is not subject to the early withdrawal penalty because the reason for withdrawal falls under recognized exceptions.

The circular identifies three qualified early withdrawal grounds. First, the withdrawal may be made for payment of accident or illness-related hospitalization in excess of thirty days. Second, the withdrawal may be made due to the permanent or total disability of the contributor. Third, the withdrawal may involve the transfer of PERA assets to another qualified PERA investment product and/or another PERA Administrator within fifteen days from withdrawal.

For qualified early withdrawal, the specific sub-account withdrawn in case of partial withdrawal will not affect the contributor’s other existing sub-accounts. The circular further states that no automatic termination shall result to the whole PERA investments.

By contrast, an unqualified early withdrawal is a withdrawal, whether in full or in part, where the reason for withdrawal is not among the qualified grounds. This type of withdrawal is subject to the early withdrawal penalty.

How the 20% Penalty Is Computed

The most important compliance clarification is the computation of the early withdrawal penalty. Pursuant to Section 10(C) of Revenue Regulations No. 17-2011, the early withdrawal penalty is composed of 20% of the gross income earned by the PERA for the entire duration and the 5% tax credit availed. RMC No. 4-2023 expressly clarifies that any loss incurred on PERA sub-accounts shall not be deducted from the gross income earned.

The circular illustrates this using PERA assets with a unit investment trust fund account amounting to 100,000. The account contains three sub-accounts. The ABC Money Market Fund has a value of 20,000 and income earned of 5,000. The DEF Bond Fund has a value of 50,000 and income earned of 3,000. The GHI Equity Fund has a value of 30,000 and a loss of 2,000. Total income earned is 8,000, while the loss is 2,000.

The 20% penalty is computed on the 8,000 gross income earned, resulting in a 1,600 penalty. The 2,000 loss in the equity fund is not used to reduce the income base. The illustration also shows a total tax credit granted of 5,000, resulting in a total early withdrawal penalty of 6,600. With PERA assets of 100,000, income earned of 8,000, and loss of 2,000, the illustrated termination proceeds amount to 92,400 after applying the early withdrawal penalty.

This example is the core operational takeaway of RMC No. 4-2023. If a PERA account has both gains and losses, the penalty is still imposed on gross income earned from the income-generating sub-accounts. The loss is not a deduction against the penalty base.

Tax Credit Treatment and Administrator Responsibilities

The circular notes that, in the illustration, the tax credit granted has been utilized already. It further provides that if the tax credit granted has not been utilized, the same shall not form part of the early withdrawal penalty. However, the tax credit granted shall be tagged as invalid and can no longer be used as payment for tax liabilities.

For the collection of the penalty, RMC No. 4-2023 states that it is reiterated that the PERA Administrator shall be responsible for administering, overseeing, and maintaining the accounts and sub-accounts of the contributor’s PERA. The Administrator must compute and withhold the early withdrawal penalty from the proceeds due to the contributor. The Administrator must also handle reporting and remittance to the Bureau pursuant to RR No. 2-2022 and RMC No. 45-2022.

Deadlines and Effective Compliance Point

RMC No. 4-2023 is dated January 9, 2023. The circular does not provide a separate future compliance deadline. Instead, it clarifies how the base amount should be computed whenever an unqualified early withdrawal occurs. PERA Administrators and tax teams should therefore treat the computation rule as applicable to relevant early withdrawal processing after issuance and ensure that their systems, worksheets, and advisory templates reflect the gross-income rule.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 4-2023 focuses on clarifying the computation of the early withdrawal penalty rather than creating a separate penalty for administrators or contributors. The specific monetary consequence identified is the early withdrawal penalty itself, composed of 20% of the gross income earned by the PERA for the entire duration and the 5% tax credit availed, subject to the clarification on unused tax credits.

For unqualified withdrawals, the financial impact can be material. In the BIR’s example, the early withdrawal penalty totals 6,600, consisting of the 1,600 penalty on gross income earned and the 5,000 tax credit granted. The fact that a sub-account suffered a 2,000 loss does not reduce the 1,600 penalty.

Practical Steps for Businesses, PERA Administrators, and Taxpayers

PERA Administrators should review their early withdrawal computation templates to confirm that the 20% penalty is imposed on gross income earned and that losses from other sub-accounts are not netted against that amount. They should also verify whether the 5% tax credit was already utilized, because utilized tax credits form part of the early withdrawal penalty, while unused credits are instead tagged as invalid and can no longer be used as payment for tax liabilities.

Financial institutions should also update customer advisories and internal approval workflows so that contributors understand the tax cost of an unqualified PERA withdrawal before liquidation. Where a withdrawal is for hospitalization exceeding thirty days, permanent or total disability, or transfer to another qualified PERA investment product or PERA Administrator within fifteen days, the documentation should clearly support why the withdrawal qualifies for exclusion from the early withdrawal penalty.

Corporate accountants and CFOs advising employees, founders, or executives with PERA investments should not rely on net account performance alone. The correct question is whether the PERA earned gross income during the duration of the investment. If it did, and the withdrawal is unqualified, the 20% penalty applies to that gross income even if other sub-accounts generated losses.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 4-2023 is a reminder that BIR compliance often turns on computation details that can materially change the tax result. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, financial institutions, employers, investors, and tax teams on Philippine tax compliance, BIR issuances, retirement account tax consequences, withholding obligations, and audit-risk management.

If your company, finance team, or institution needs assistance reviewing PERA-related tax treatment, BIR compliance procedures, penalty computations, or tax advisory materials, our Makati-based tax and business law team can help. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance and Philippine tax law matters.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *