RMC No. 47-2023 requires NGAs, LGUs, and GOCCs to remit withholding taxes based on payment, payable status, accrual, or book recording.
Government withholding agents cannot wait for actual cash disbursement before deducting and remitting withholding taxes when the expense has already been accrued or recorded in the books. RMC No. 47-2023 matters immediately to National Government Agencies, government instrumentalities, Local Government Units, Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations, and other government entities because it reiterates that the duty to withhold may arise before actual payment, and failure to observe the proper timing may expose the entity to corresponding penalties.
What RMC No. 47-2023 Changed or Reiterated
RMC No. 47-2023 reiterates the proper time for the remittance of withholding taxes by National Government Agencies and instrumentalities, Local Government Units, Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations, and other government entities. The central compliance point is simple but important: withholding tax obligations are not triggered only by the actual release of cash. The obligation to deduct and withhold tax arises at the time an income payment is paid or payable, or when the income payment is accrued or recorded as an expense or asset in the payor’s books, whichever comes first.
This is particularly important for government accounting and procurement processes because many expenditures may be recognized in the books before the supplier, contractor, consultant, professional, landlord, or other payee actually receives payment. Where the obligation has already been recorded, the government withholding agent should not defer the tax withholding and remittance merely because cash payment has not yet been made.
The circular addresses reports that certain National Government Agencies, Local Government Units, Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations, and other government entities continued the practice of deducting and remitting withholding taxes due from expenditures only when actually paid, even if the expenditures had already been recognized as accruals and recorded in their books of accounts. RMC No. 47-2023 makes clear that this practice is not consistent with the rule on the time of withholding.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 47-2023
The issuance directly affects National Government Agencies, government instrumentalities, Local Government Units, Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations, and other government entities acting as withholding agents. In practical terms, this includes government finance offices, accounting units, budget offices, procurement teams, disbursing officers, and officials responsible for tax compliance on government payments.
The ruling is also important for private sector counterparties dealing with government, including suppliers, contractors, consultants, professionals, lessors, service providers, and other payees whose income payments may be subject to withholding tax. While the government entity is the withholding agent, private counterparties should understand the timing rule because it affects withholding tax certificates, tax credit reconciliation, year-end income reporting, and the timing of tax documentation.
For CFOs, accountants, and tax managers searching for BIR rules on government withholding tax remittance, time of withholding tax, accrued expenses withholding tax, LGU withholding tax compliance, and GOCC withholding tax obligations, the key takeaway is that government payors must align their withholding procedures with accrual-based recognition, not merely cash release.
The Key Compliance Rule: Withhold When Paid, Payable, Accrued, or Recorded, Whichever Comes First
RMC No. 47-2023 refers to Revenue Regulations No. 12-2001, which amended Section 2.57.4 of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98. Under that rule, the obligation of the payor to deduct and withhold tax arises at the time the income payment is paid or payable, or when the income payment is accrued or recorded as an expense or asset in the payor’s books, whichever is applicable in the payor’s books, whichever comes first.
The word payable is also significant. It refers to the date when the obligation becomes due, demandable, or legally enforceable. Therefore, even without actual cash payment, the withholding obligation may arise once the liability has matured into an amount payable to the income recipient, or once the expense or asset has been recognized in the government entity’s books.
The rule also provides a specific treatment where income is not yet paid or payable but has already been recorded as an expense or asset. In that case, the obligation to withhold arises in the last month of the return period in which the same is claimed as an expense or amortized for tax purposes. This prevents government withholding agents from indefinitely postponing withholding on the theory that the payment has not yet been released.
Accrual Accounting Is the Basis for Government Withholding Compliance
RMC No. 47-2023 emphasizes that the accrual basis of accounting had already been prescribed by the Commission on Audit in the Government Accounting Manuals for National Government Agencies and Local Government Units since 2002. These standards are harmonized with International Public Sector Accounting Standards.
The practical implication is that a long-standing departure from the cash basis of accounting already exists for government accounting purposes. Accordingly, government entities should not ground their duty to deduct and withhold taxes on cash-basis accounting if their books have already recognized the obligation under accrual accounting.
This is the compliance gap that the circular seeks to correct: some government entities were treating the actual payment date as the trigger for withholding tax, even when the corresponding expense had already been accrued and recorded. RMC No. 47-2023 instructs them to follow the proper timing rule strictly.
Deadlines and Effective Date
RMC No. 47-2023 is dated May 3, 2023. The document does not create a new future compliance deadline or grace period. Instead, it reiterates a rule that the BIR states has been in place since Revenue Regulations No. 12-2001, particularly the rule on the time of withholding under Section 2.57.4 of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98.
Because the circular is a reiteration, affected government withholding agents should treat the matter as an immediate compliance concern. Finance and accounting units should review current withholding procedures, especially for accrued expenses, payables, and assets recorded in the books before actual disbursement. Waiting for actual payment may result in late withholding and late remittance if the obligation to withhold had already arisen earlier under the applicable rule.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 47-2023 does not list a new penalty table, rate, surcharge, interest computation, or compromise penalty schedule. However, it expressly requests all concerned National Government Agencies, Local Government Units, Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations, and other government entities to strictly comply with the proper time of remittance of withholding tax obligations to avoid payment of the corresponding penalties.
The compliance risk therefore lies in late or improper withholding and remittance. If a government entity treats the date of cash payment as the only withholding trigger, but the BIR considers the withholding obligation to have arisen earlier because the expense was already payable, accrued, or recorded, the remittance may be treated as delayed. The circular’s warning should be read as a directive to prevent exposure to the usual consequences of non-compliance with withholding tax obligations.
Practical Steps for Government Accounting and Finance Offices
First, government entities should map the point at which expenses, assets, and payables are recorded in the books. The tax team should not rely solely on the date of check release, fund transfer, or cash disbursement. The accounting entry may already trigger withholding tax obligations.
Second, accounting and disbursement workflows should be revised so that withholding tax is evaluated when an obligation becomes paid, payable, accrued, or recorded, whichever comes first. This may require coordination among procurement, accounting, budget, and treasury personnel so that tax withholding is not left until the final payment stage.
Third, government withholding agents should identify all recurring transactions that are commonly accrued before payment. These may include professional fees, service contracts, utilities, rentals, supplies, infrastructure-related obligations, and other government payables subject to withholding tax. The relevant contracts, billing documents, acceptance documents, and accounting entries should be checked against the applicable withholding tax rules.
Fourth, government entities should reconcile accrued expenses and recorded assets against withholding tax returns and remittance records. Where an expense has already been claimed, recorded, or amortized for tax purposes, the entity should confirm whether withholding was made in the proper return period.
Fifth, private suppliers and contractors dealing with government should also coordinate with the government payor regarding withholding tax certificates. Since withholding may be triggered before actual receipt of cash, payees should ensure that tax documentation, income recognition, and creditable withholding tax reconciliation are properly aligned.
Why This Matters for Businesses Dealing With Government
Although RMC No. 47-2023 is addressed to government entities, the business impact extends to private companies transacting with NGAs, LGUs, GOCCs, and government instrumentalities. A supplier may encounter withholding tax treatment based on accrual even before actual cash collection. This may affect accounting cut-offs, tax credit claims, receivables monitoring, and reconciliation of BIR Forms and certificates issued by the withholding agent.
Businesses that regularly contract with government should monitor whether the withholding tax certificates they receive correspond to the correct transaction period. If certificates are issued late or do not match the period in which the income or tax credit is reported, this can create avoidable tax compliance issues for both the government payor and private payee.
ASG Law Can Assist With BIR Withholding Tax Compliance
RMC No. 47-2023 is a reminder that withholding tax compliance depends not only on the correct rate, but also on the correct timing. For government entities, GOCCs, LGUs, and businesses dealing with the public sector, the critical question is whether withholding is being triggered when income payments are paid, payable, accrued, or recorded, whichever comes first.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, government counterparties, finance teams, and corporate taxpayers on BIR compliance, withholding tax exposure, tax documentation, and tax risk management. For assistance in reviewing withholding tax procedures, government contract tax clauses, BIR assessments, or tax compliance workflows, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.