RMC No. 11-2024 clarifies that PFRS 16 ROU depreciation and lease liability interest are not deductible; actual rent governs tax treatment.

Businesses applying PFRS 16 cannot automatically deduct right-of-use asset depreciation or interest on lease liabilities for income tax purposes. For lessees, RMC No. 11-2024 makes the tax rule clear: financial accounting treatment under PFRS 16 does not control the tax deduction. Only actual rentals paid or incurred under the lease contract, together with properly substantiated allowable expenses, may be claimed for tax purposes. This matters immediately to CFOs, accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel reviewing lease accounting, income tax deductions, input VAT, expanded withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax exposure.

What RMC No. 11-2024 Changed for Lease Accounting and Tax Deductions

RMC No. 11-2024 clarifies the tax treatment of lease accounting by lessees under Philippine Financial Reporting Standard 16 in relation to Sections 34(A), 34(K), 106, 108, 179, and 194 of the Tax Code, as amended, Revenue Regulations No. 19-86, as amended, and Revenue Regulations No. 02-98, as amended.

The central clarification is that the PFRS 16 recognition of a right-of-use asset, commonly called an ROU asset, and the related lease liability does not mean that the same accounting entries are deductible for tax purposes. Under PFRS 16, a lessee generally recognizes an ROU asset and a lease liability at the commencement date, measures the lease liability at the present value of future lease payments, and recognizes depreciation on the ROU asset and interest expense on the lease liability. For income tax purposes, however, the BIR states that depreciation expense on the ROU asset and interest expense on the lease liability shall not be treated as deductible expenses.

Instead, only the actual amount of rent paid or incurred, including any other payments to the lessor based on the lease agreement, shall be allowed as deductions in arriving at net taxable income under Section 34(A)(1)(a)(iii) of the Tax Code, as amended. This is the key practical adjustment for taxpayers searching for PFRS 16 tax treatment Philippines, right-of-use asset tax deduction, lease liability interest tax treatment, and BIR lease accounting rules.

Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 11-2024

The most affected taxpayers are corporate lessees that book leases under PFRS 16, especially businesses with office leases, warehouse leases, retail branch leases, equipment leases, vehicle leases, plant and machinery leases, and long-term operating arrangements that now result in ROU assets in the audited financial statements.

Large corporations and companies with audited financial statements should pay particular attention because the notes to financial statements may disclose lease-related accounting items that differ from the amounts claimed in the income tax return. SMEs are also affected if they apply PFRS 16 or if their accountants recognize ROU assets and lease liabilities in their books. Withholding agents are affected because the circular confirms that, for contracts considered leases, only the actual rental paid or accrued shall be subject to five percent expanded withholding tax, without regard to depreciation expense from the ROU asset.

Companies involved in lease-to-own structures, finance lease transactions, and arrangements that may be recharacterized as conditional sales must also review their contracts. The tax consequences differ depending on whether the transaction is treated as an operating lease, finance lease, or conditional sale.

Income Tax Treatment of Operating Leases, Finance Leases, and Conditional Sales

For income tax purposes, an operating lease is a contract where the asset is not wholly amortized during the primary period of the lease and where the lessor does not rely solely on rentals during that primary period for profit, but looks to recovery from the sale or re-lease of the returned asset.

A finance lease, also described as a full payout lease, involves payment over an obligatory period of specified rental amounts sufficient in total to amortize the capital outlay of the lessor and provide for borrowing costs and profit. The obligatory period refers to the primary or basic non-cancellable period of the lease, which must not be less than 730 days. The lessee, not the lessor, normally exercises the choice of asset and normally bears maintenance, insurance, and other expenses relating to use, preservation, and operation. The residual value must in no instance be less than five percent of the lessor’s acquisition cost of the leased asset.

However, a contract in lease form may still be treated as a conditional sale if the substance of the agreement and the intent of the parties show a sale. Compelling persuasive factors include an option to purchase the asset during the obligatory lease period at a price equivalent to or higher than the current fair market value, automatic ownership upon payment of the stated rentals, portions of periodic rentals being credited to the purchase price, or receipts indicating that payments are partial or full payments of the asset. Even without those factors, a transaction may indicate a purchase and sale if portions of payments are specifically applicable to equity to be acquired by the lessee, or if the property may be acquired under a purchase option at a price that is nominal in relation to the property value when the option may be exercised.

ROU Asset Depreciation and Lease Liability Interest Are Not Tax-Deductible

For tax compliance, the most important adjustment is the add-back of PFRS 16 depreciation and interest expense where these are not allowable deductions. Under the circular, depreciation on the ROU asset and the corresponding interest expense on the outstanding lease liability may appear in the income statement for financial reporting purposes, but they are not deductible for income tax purposes.

The deductible amount is the actual rent paid or incurred under the lease contract. This means accountants should reconcile audited financial statement lease expense, ROU asset depreciation, interest on lease liability, and the rent deduction claimed in the annual income tax return. The tax working papers should be able to show why the deductible amount is based on actual rentals rather than PFRS 16 accounting expense.

Short-Term Leases and Low-Value Assets

PFRS 16 allows recognition exemptions for short-term leases and leases of low-value items. A short-term lease is a lease term of 12 months or less, but it excludes leases with purchase or renewal options. A lease of low-value asset refers to an underlying asset of low value, with the circular referring to the standard equivalent of US$5,000 for a new similar asset.

For tax purposes, short-term leases and leases of low-value assets shall be accounted for as operating leases. Therefore, only actual rentals paid or accrued during the taxable year under the lease contracts shall be recognized by the lessee as deductible expenses.

Initial Direct Costs, Lessor-Account Expenses, Security Deposits, and Restoration Costs

Initial direct costs paid or incurred by the lessee in relation to a lease may be claimed as outright expenses in the year paid or incurred, provided they are directly related to the negotiation and execution of the lease agreement and subject to substantiation and withholding requirements under Section 34 of the Tax Code, as amended.

Amounts paid by the lessee for certain expenses that are properly for the account of the lessor under the contract may also be allowed as deductions during the year they are paid or accrued, provided the lessor issues invoices or receipts in the name of the lessee, such as realty tax or association dues.

Security deposits are treated differently. Advance payments made pursuant to a lease contract in the nature of a security deposit for faithful performance shall be recorded only as an asset in the year the advance payment is received. If the advance payment is a security deposit and the conditions make the security deposit the property of the lessor, the lessee becomes entitled to a deduction based on the amount of security deposit applied to the lease.

Estimated restoration costs for dismantling and removing an underlying asset, restoring the site, or restoring the underlying asset to the condition required by the lease are deductible only during the taxable year when actually paid or incurred under Section 34(A)(1)(a) of the Tax Code, as amended.

VAT, Expanded Withholding Tax, and Documentary Stamp Tax Rules

For VAT purposes, the input VAT is creditable to the lessee only upon payment of rentals and only when evidenced by a VAT official receipt pursuant to Section 110 in relation to Section 113 of the Tax Code, as amended.

For transactions considered leases, only the actual rental paid or accrued is subject to five percent expanded withholding tax under Section 2.57.2(B) of Revenue Regulations No. 02-98, as amended. The circular expressly states that only the actual rental paid or accrued shall be considered the tax base for EWT purposes, without regard to depreciation expense from the ROU asset.

For transactions considered conditional sales of personal property, the transaction is treated as a sale of goods to the extent the amounts do not represent interest and other charges. The applicable EWT rate on income payments made by Top Withholding Agents to their local or resident supplier of goods is one percent under Section 2.57.2(I) of Revenue Regulations No. 02-98, as amended. The related interest is subject to fifteen percent EWT on interest income on any debt instrument not within the coverage of deposit substitutes under Section 2.57.2(S) of Revenue Regulations No. 02-98, as amended. If the conditional sale involves real property, the withholding rules on the sale of real property under Section 2.57.2(F) of Revenue Regulations No. 02-98, as amended, shall apply.

For business tax purposes in conditional sales of real property, if the initial payment during the year of sale exceeds 25 percent of the gross selling price, the sale is considered a cash sale, making the entire selling price taxable in the year of sale. For installment sales where initial payments during the year of sale do not exceed 25 percent of the gross selling price, the corresponding VAT is recognized on installment payments, including interest and penalties, actually or constructively received by the seller. In all cases, the lessee or buyer may claim input tax only in the same period when the lessor or seller recognizes output tax.

For documentary stamp tax purposes, lease transactions that qualify as finance lease transactions under Republic Act No. 5980, as amended by Republic Act No. 8556, are subject to the applicable DST rates on debt instruments under Section 179 of the Tax Code, as amended. Otherwise, the transaction is considered an operating lease subject to DST on lease agreements under Section 194 of the Tax Code, as amended.

Financial Statement Disclosures Accountants Should Reconcile

For reporting purposes, taxpayers may disclose lease-related information in the notes to financial statements, including depreciation charge for right-of-use assets by class of underlying asset, interest expense on lease liabilities, expense relating to short-term leases, expense relating to leases of low-value assets, expense relating to variable lease payments not included in measurement of lease liabilities, income from subleasing right-of-use assets, total cash outflow for leases, additions to right-of-use assets, gains or losses arising from sale and leaseback transactions, and the carrying amount of right-of-use assets at the end of the reporting period by class of underlying asset.

These disclosures may create visible differences between accounting expense and tax deduction. Taxpayers should therefore maintain a clear reconciliation between the audited financial statements and tax returns, particularly where ROU depreciation and lease liability interest are added back and actual rent is claimed instead.

Effective Date and Compliance Deadline

RMC No. 11-2024 states that it takes effect immediately. The document is dated September 12, 2023, and bears the official citation RMC No. 11-2024. Businesses should apply the clarified treatment when preparing tax returns, withholding tax filings, VAT reconciliations, DST computations, and audited financial statement tax schedules affected by lease arrangements.

Penalties and Audit Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 11-2024 does not prescribe a special standalone penalty. However, the practical exposure is significant. A taxpayer that deducts PFRS 16 ROU depreciation or lease liability interest instead of actual rentals may face disallowance of deductions and resulting deficiency income tax. Incorrect withholding tax treatment may also create exposure for deficiency expanded withholding tax, especially where five percent EWT on rent or the conditional sale rates are misapplied. Incorrect VAT timing may affect input VAT claims, particularly because input VAT is creditable only upon payment of rentals and only when supported by a VAT official receipt. Incorrect DST classification between finance lease debt instruments and operating lease agreements may also result in DST assessment exposure.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants

Companies should first inventory all lease contracts and classify them for tax purposes as operating leases, finance leases, or conditional sales. The classification should not be based only on the title of the contract. The substance of the arrangement, payment mechanics, purchase option, transfer of ownership, rental credits, residual value, and obligatory period should be reviewed.

Second, accountants should prepare a PFRS 16 tax reconciliation. The reconciliation should identify ROU asset depreciation, interest on lease liability, actual rentals paid or accrued, short-term lease expenses, low-value asset leases, initial direct costs, restoration costs, security deposits, and expenses paid for the account of the lessor.

Third, withholding tax teams should confirm the applicable rate. Actual rent under lease contracts is subject to five percent EWT. Conditional sale of personal property may involve one percent EWT on goods payments by Top Withholding Agents and fifteen percent EWT on interest income on debt instruments not covered as deposit substitutes. Conditional sale of real property requires application of the withholding rules for sale of real property.

Fourth, VAT teams should claim input VAT only upon payment of rentals and only with a VAT official receipt. For conditional sales of real property, they should monitor whether initial payments exceed 25 percent of gross selling price because that affects whether the sale is treated as a cash sale or installment sale for VAT recognition.

Finally, businesses should review documentary stamp tax classification. Finance leases qualifying under Republic Act No. 5980, as amended by Republic Act No. 8556, are subject to DST on debt instruments under Section 179, while operating leases are subject to DST on lease agreements under Section 194.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists companies, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing lease contracts, preparing tax reconciliation positions, responding to BIR audits, and aligning accounting treatment with Philippine income tax, VAT, withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax rules. RMC No. 11-2024 requires more than a book entry adjustment; it requires contract review, tax classification, substantiation, and defensible compliance documentation.

For assistance with PFRS 16 lease tax treatment, BIR lease audits, withholding tax on rentals, VAT input tax timing, or DST classification of finance leases and operating leases, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *