RMC No. 99-2023 clarifies VAT, withholding tax, DST, invoicing, and deemed sale rules for real property classified as ordinary assets.

Real estate sellers must correctly classify property as capital asset or ordinary asset before issuing documents, computing VAT, withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax. RMC No. 99-2023 matters now because a sale, transfer, or even donation of real property used in business may trigger different tax consequences depending on whether the property forms part of the seller’s ordinary assets.

What RMC No. 99-2023 Changed for Real Property Sellers

RMC No. 99-2023 clarifies the applicable taxes due on the sale of real property considered as ordinary assets of the seller. The Circular is framed in a question-and-answer format to guide Revenue Officers and taxpayers processing electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration, commonly searched as eCAR for real property sale, BIR taxes on ordinary assets, VAT on real property sale, expanded withholding tax on real property, and DST on deed of sale.

The most important clarification is that real property classified as an ordinary asset is not treated like a simple capital asset sale. Instead, the seller may have to deal with sales invoicing, expanded withholding tax, documentary stamp tax, income tax reporting, and in many cases, 12% VAT.

Under the rules cited in the Circular, real properties considered ordinary assets include stock in trade or other real property of a kind properly included in inventory at the close of the taxable year; real property held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of trade or business; real property used in trade or business and subject to depreciation; real property used in trade or business; and, in the case of banks, real properties acquired through foreclosure sale.

Who Is Most Affected

The taxpayers most affected are real estate developers, dealers, lessors, VAT-registered businesses, banks holding foreclosed properties, corporations holding land used in operations, and business owners selling or transferring real property used in trade or business. The Circular is also important for corporate accountants and CFOs handling asset disposals, tax clearances, and eCAR processing.

RMC No. 99-2023 also clarifies that real properties seized by government in the exercise of regulatory functions and eventually sold through public auction are not considered ordinary assets. Although such property may be part of the government’s inventory held for sale, it is not considered stock in trade or inventory in the ordinary course of trade or business.

Sales Invoice Requirement for Ordinary Asset Real Property

A key compliance point is the invoicing rule. Only sellers of real properties classified as ordinary assets are required to issue a Sales Invoice pursuant to Section 237 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.

However, RMC No. 99-2023 gives practical relief for a VAT-registered taxpayer that is engaged solely in the sale of services and has only an Authority to Print for Official Receipts. In that case, the issuance of an Official Receipt covering the sale of real property used in trade or business is permitted, provided the sale is merely incidental to the taxpayer’s regular business operations.

This matters because many corporations that are not primarily real estate businesses may occasionally dispose of office space, land, warehouses, parking spaces, or other real properties used in operations. The Circular prevents a mechanical invoicing issue where the taxpayer’s regular registered receipts do not match the form normally used for sale of goods or properties.

Does the Sale Form Part of Gross Sales?

RMC No. 99-2023 distinguishes sellers whose registered business is real estate business from sellers whose real property sale is only incidental. If the seller’s registered business is real estate business, the sale forms part of gross sales.

Otherwise, the sale of real property covered by a Sales Invoice does not form part of gross sales. Instead, the gain on the sale is declared as other taxable income in the seller’s income tax return. The gain is computed by deducting the book value of the real property from the selling price indicated in the Sales Invoice. Any creditable tax withheld by the purchaser is claimed as tax credit.

For tax managers, this is a critical distinction. The invoicing of the sale does not automatically mean the full selling price becomes part of ordinary gross sales if the seller is not in the real estate business. The correct tax treatment depends on the seller’s registered business and the nature of the transaction.

Key Tax Returns and Documents Required

For a sale or transfer of real property considered an ordinary asset of the transferor or seller, RMC No. 99-2023 identifies two tax returns that must be filed. First, BIR Form No. 1606 must be filed for the remittance of expanded withholding tax on the purchase of real property. Second, BIR Form No. 2000-OT must be filed for the declaration and payment of documentary stamp tax due on the transfer or sale of real property.

Where the seller claims credit for tax withheld, the Circular states that the copy of BIR Form No. 1606, with proof of payment of the creditable withholding tax, must be attached to the income tax return where the sale was declared by the seller.

Businesses should therefore keep the deed of sale, Sales Invoice or Official Receipt where applicable, BIR Form No. 1606, proof of payment of creditable withholding tax, BIR Form No. 2000-OT, and working papers showing book value, selling price, gain, VAT treatment, and classification of the property as ordinary asset.

VAT on Sale of Real Property Classified as Ordinary Asset

RMC No. 99-2023 confirms the general rule that sales of real property classified as ordinary assets are subject to VAT. However, it also identifies instances when such sales are not subject to VAT.

First, VAT does not apply when the real property is used in business by a non-VAT registered person whose transactions are under Section 109(1)(A) to (BB) of the Tax Code, as amended. Second, VAT does not apply when the real property subject of sale or transfer falls under Section 109(P) of the Tax Code, as amended, such as sale of real property utilized for socialized housing, and sale of house and lot and other residential dwellings with selling price of not more than P3,199,200.

The Circular notes that the P3,199,200 threshold is subject to adjustment every three years to its present value using the Consumer Price Index as published by the Philippine Statistics Authority.

Where the sale is subject to VAT, RMC No. 99-2023 states that the applicable VAT rate is 12%. The VAT is based on the gross selling price or gross value in money of the goods or properties sold, bartered, or exchanged. For sale of real property subject to VAT, gross selling price means the consideration stated in the sales document or the fair market value, whichever is higher.

For this purpose, fair market value means the higher of the fair market value as determined by the Commissioner, commonly the zonal value, or the fair market value shown in the schedule of values of the Provincial or City Assessors, commonly the Real Property Tax Declaration value.

Donations and Deemed Sale of Business Real Property

The Circular also addresses donations of real property used in business. Donation by a VAT-registered person of property classified as an ordinary asset is considered a deemed sale subject to VAT under Section 106(B)(1) of the Tax Code, as amended, and Section 4.106-7 of Revenue Regulations No. 16-2005, as amended.

RMC No. 99-2023 gives the example of a taxpayer who inherited a lot where a bakeshop is established, did not change the tax declaration upon payment of donor’s tax, and continued operating the bakeshop under the name of the transferor. The Circular states that the donated lot is classified as an ordinary asset because it is used in the course of business of the donor-taxpayer. If the donor-taxpayer is VAT-registered, the donation is a deemed sale subject to VAT. If the donor-taxpayer is not VAT-registered, the donation is exempt from VAT.

The Circular further clarifies that the classification of the lot remains ordinary asset even after donation to the taxpayer’s daughter if the lot continues to be used in the taxpayer’s business operations.

In another example, where a VAT-registered taxpayer donated to his son real property used in business and originally intended for use in expanding his supermarket, the donation is considered a deemed sale transaction subject to VAT. The reason is that the property forms part of the taxpayer’s asset originally intended for use in business.

Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 99-2023 does not create a separate penalty provision. However, the compliance risk is practical and significant. If the seller misclassifies a real property sale as a capital asset transaction when it is actually an ordinary asset transaction, the taxpayer may underpay VAT, fail to remit expanded withholding tax, fail to pay the proper documentary stamp tax, issue the wrong document, or incorrectly report the gain in the income tax return.

For corporations and VAT-registered businesses, the greatest exposure is usually the 12% VAT computation, especially because the taxable base may be the higher of the consideration stated in the sales document or fair market value. This makes updated zonal values and assessor’s values essential before signing a deed of sale or finalizing the tax computation.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants

Before selling, transferring, or donating real property, businesses should first determine whether the property is a capital asset or ordinary asset in the hands of the seller. The classification should be supported by accounting records, tax declarations, fixed asset ledgers, depreciation records, inventory records, business registration documents, and actual business use.

Second, the seller should determine whether a Sales Invoice is required, or whether an Official Receipt may be used because the seller is VAT-registered, engaged solely in services, and the real property sale is merely incidental to regular business operations.

Third, the parties should compute the expanded withholding tax and documentary stamp tax and prepare BIR Form No. 1606 and BIR Form No. 2000-OT. The seller should secure the copy of BIR Form No. 1606 with proof of payment, because this must be attached to the income tax return where the sale is declared.

Fourth, VAT status must be reviewed carefully. If the transaction is VATable, the seller must compute 12% VAT based on the proper taxable base. If the transaction falls within a VAT exemption, such as certain socialized housing or residential dwellings within the applicable threshold stated in the Circular, the basis for exemption should be documented.

Finally, for donations of business real property, taxpayers should not assume that payment of donor’s tax ends the analysis. A VAT-registered donor may still have a deemed sale subject to VAT where the donated property is an ordinary asset used or intended for use in business.

ASG Law Can Help with BIR Compliance on Real Property Transactions

RMC No. 99-2023 reinforces that real property transactions require tax planning before execution, not after the deed is signed. The correct classification of the property, the proper invoice or receipt, the VAT treatment, the withholding tax return, the DST return, and the income tax reporting must all align.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, real estate businesses, SMEs, property owners, CFOs, and accountants on BIR compliance, tax documentation, eCAR processing, VAT exposure, withholding tax, DST, and structuring of real property transfers. For assistance with real property tax compliance and BIR documentation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *