RR No. 5-2024 sets new BIR refund rules: risk-based VAT verification, 90-day VAT action, 180-day refund processing, and strict CTA deadlines.
Businesses filing tax refund or tax credit claims from 1 July 2024 onward must prepare for a new refund system: VAT refund claims will now be processed using a risk-based verification approach, while most non-VAT refund claims must be acted upon within 180 days from submission of complete documents. For CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax managers, RR No. 5-2024 changes how refund files should be prepared, how quickly judicial remedies must be pursued, and when a taxpayer may lose the right to cash refund or tax credit certificate.
What RR No. 5-2024 Changed
RR No. 5-2024 implements the Ease of Paying Taxes Act amendments to Sections 76(C), 112(C), 112(D), 204(C), 229, and 269(J) of the Tax Code. Its central change is the modernization of tax refund processing. VAT refunds under Section 112 are now subject to risk-based verification, while tax credit and refund claims under Sections 204(C) and 229 are subject to a 180-day processing period. The rules also clarify how excess income tax credits under Section 76(C) may be refunded or carried over, how judicial claims must be filed, and what happens if the Commission on Audit later disallows an approved VAT refund.
The regulations apply to tax credit and refund claims filed starting 1 July 2024. Claims pursuant to final and executory court judgments are not covered. This makes the issuance highly relevant to companies with recurring VAT refund claims, exporters, zero-rated sellers, taxpayers with excess withholding taxes, corporations undergoing dissolution or cessation, and businesses relying on tax credit certificates for liquidity and tax settlement planning.
VAT Refund Claims Will Be Classified as Low, Medium, or High Risk
For VAT refund claims under Section 112(A), the BIR will classify claims into low-risk, medium-risk, and high-risk categories. All claims must still submit the complete documentary requirements prescribed by the BIR. The risk level determines the scope of verification, not whether the taxpayer may skip documents.
A low-risk claim requires submission of complete documentary requirements, but there will be no verification of sales and no verification of purchases. A medium-risk claim requires submission of complete documentary requirements and verification of at least 50% of the amount of sales and 50% of total purchases without tax claimed, including suppliers with prior issuance of Mission Orders for “Big-Ticket” purchases. A high-risk claim requires submission of complete documentary requirements and 100% verification of sales and 100% verification of purchases.
The risk-based approach is not purely discretionary. RR No. 5-2024 identifies risk factors such as the amount of the VAT refund claim, frequency of filing VAT refund claims, tax compliance history, and other risk factors that may be identified by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The BIR may expand the categories into sub-categories and assign weights to arrive at a more comprehensive risk classification.
Special Rules That Can Push VAT Refund Claims Into Higher Verification
First-time VAT refund claimants are automatically considered high-risk and will remain high-risk for the succeeding three VAT refund claims. If a claim is fully denied, the succeeding claim filed will be classified as high-risk. For medium-risk claims, verification will be adjusted to 100% if the assigned Revenue Officer finds at least 30% disallowance of the amount of VAT refund claimed. Low-risk claims for three consecutive VAT refund filings will also be subject to mandatory full verification on the fourth VAT refund claim regardless of the risk classification.
VAT credit or refund claims for unused input tax under Section 112(B) by VAT-registered persons whose registration has been cancelled due to retirement, cessation of business, changes in or cessation of status under Section 106(C), are classified as high-risk and require full verification. For taxpayers filing VAT refund claims quarterly, the risk classification will be made every filing.
The 90-Day VAT Refund Period and the 30-Day CTA Deadline
The 90-day period to process and decide a VAT refund claim starts from the filing of the claim or application with complete documentary requirements up to the release of payment for the approved VAT refund. The application is considered filed only upon submission of invoices or receipts, whichever is applicable, and other prescribed supporting documents.
If the BIR fully or partially denies the VAT refund claim, the taxpayer may appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals within 30 days from receipt of the decision. If the Commissioner does not act within the 90-day period, the taxpayer may either appeal to the CTA within 30 days after the expiration of the 90 days required by law, or forego the judicial remedy and await the final decision of the Commissioner. Once the taxpayer chooses the judicial remedy, the administrative claim is considered moot and will no longer be processed.
COA Disallowance: Taxpayer Liability After Approved VAT Refunds
RR No. 5-2024 clarifies that approved VAT refunds under Section 112 are subject to post-audit by the Commission on Audit following the risk-based classification. Refunds may be made on warrants drawn by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or a duly authorized representative without the need for countersignature by the COA Chairperson.
If COA later disallows the refund, only the taxpayer is liable for the disallowed amount, without prejudice to administrative liability of any BIR officer or employee found grossly negligent in the grant of the refund. Recovery of the disallowed amount will follow the procedures or guidelines prescribed by COA.
Excess Income Tax Credits Under Section 76(C)
For going concerns that choose in their Annual Income Tax Return to apply for tax credit or refund of excess income tax, RR No. 5-2024 restates key conditions. The claim for tax credit certificate or refund must be filed within two years from the date of filing of the AITR. The income on which taxes were withheld must be included in the gross income declared in the income tax return of the recipient. The withholding must be established by a withholding tax certificate duly issued by the payor or withholding agent, clearly identifying the income payment and the tax withheld.
If the taxpayer is entitled to tax credit or refund of excess income taxes paid during the year, the excess amount shown in the final adjustment return may be carried over and credited against estimated quarterly income tax liabilities for the taxable quarters of the succeeding taxable years. Once the option to carry over and credit excess income tax against income tax due for succeeding taxable years is made, the choice is irrevocable for that taxable period. No application for cash refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate will be allowed for that amount.
If a taxpayer chose to be issued a tax credit certificate or refund but carried forward the amount sought to be refunded or issued as TCC in the AITR filed for the succeeding year, that act is a ground for denial of the claim for tax credit or refund. The amount carried forward may instead be credited against future income tax liabilities of the taxpayer-claimant.
Dissolution or Cessation of Business: Refund Exception to Irrevocability
Taxpayers that chose the carry-over option may still claim a refund if they can no longer carry over the excess income tax credit because of dissolution or cessation of business. The BIR must decide and refund excess taxes within two years from the date of dissolution or cessation of business. For this purpose, the two-year period begins from submission of BIR Form No. 1905 for Application for Registration Information Update, Correction, or Cancellation, together with complete documentary requirements for closure of business and refund of excess income taxes due to cessation or dissolution.
Any approved refund will be released only after completion of the mandatory audit of all internal revenue tax liabilities covering the immediately preceding year and the short-period return, plus full settlement of all tax liabilities related to the cessation or dissolution and any existing tax liabilities before cessation or dissolution.
Processing Claims Under Sections 204(C) and 229
For tax credit or refund claims involving taxes erroneously or illegally received or penalties imposed without authority, the taxpayer must file a written claim within two years after payment of the tax or penalty. A return showing an overpayment is considered a written claim for credit or refund. For the 180-day processing period, counting begins upon submission of complete supporting documents prescribed by the BIR, and the submission must still be within the two-year prescriptive period.
Sections 204(C) and 229 require the BIR to process and decide the tax credit or refund within 180 days from submission of complete documents up to payment of the approved refund or receipt of the tax credit certificate. For income tax credit or refund claims under Section 76(C) by a going concern, the BIR must prioritize these claims and should not hold processing in abeyance pending completion of audit for all internal revenue tax liabilities.
Judicial Claims and the 30-Day Rule
No court action for recovery of tax alleged to have been erroneously or illegally assessed or collected may be maintained until a claim for refund or credit has been duly filed with the Commissioner. A judicial claim may be filed only after full or partial denial by the Commissioner, or upon failure of the Commissioner to act within the 180-day period under Section 204(C).
For judicial claims under Section 229, the taxpayer must file within 30 days from full or partial denial by the Commissioner or from the Commissioner’s failure to act within the 180-day period. For excess income tax refund claims of taxpayers undergoing cessation or dissolution of business under Section 76(C), the judicial claim must be filed within 30 days from full or partial denial by the Commissioner.
Penalties and Compliance Risks
RR No. 5-2024 expressly states that a BIR official, agent, or employee who deliberately causes delay in the processing of a VAT refund claim may be subject to penalties under Section 269(J) of the Tax Code. It also provides that deliberate failure by any BIR official, agent, or employee to process and decide an application within the prescribed 180-day period is punishable under Section 269(J).
For taxpayers, the larger risk is procedural loss. Missing the two-year period for filing refund claims, submitting incomplete documents, carrying over a refund amount in the next AITR after choosing refund or TCC, or missing the 30-day CTA deadline can defeat an otherwise valid claim. Tax credit certificates may be applied against any internal revenue tax liability, excluding withholding taxes for which the taxpayer is directly liable. A request to convert an unutilized TCC into a refund may be allowed subject to Section 230 of the Tax Code, but the original TCC showing a creditable balance must be surrendered to the proper revenue officer for verification and cancellation. No refund will be given for availment of incentives under special laws where no actual payment was made.
Practical Steps for Businesses Filing BIR Tax Refund Claims
Companies should immediately review all pending and planned BIR tax refund claims, especially VAT refund claims filed from 1 July 2024 onward. Exporters and zero-rated sellers should map their claims against the low-risk, medium-risk, and high-risk verification matrix and prepare for possible 100% verification if they are first-time claimants, have had a prior full denial, or trigger the 30% disallowance rule for medium-risk claims.
Tax departments should also build a documentary checklist around the exact start of the 90-day or 180-day period. For VAT refunds, the 90-day period does not meaningfully protect the taxpayer unless the claim is complete and supported by invoices, receipts, and other required documents. For non-VAT tax refund claims, the 180-day processing period starts only upon submission of complete documents, and that submission must be made within the two-year prescriptive period.
Corporate accountants should also coordinate AITR preparation with refund strategy. If the taxpayer chooses carry-over of excess income tax credit, that option becomes irrevocable for the taxable period. If the taxpayer intends to seek refund or TCC, the amount should not be carried forward in the succeeding year’s AITR, because doing so may cause denial of the refund or TCC claim.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 5-2024 makes BIR refund work more technical, more deadline-driven, and more dependent on documentary completeness from day one. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, exporters, withholding tax claimants, and businesses undergoing closure or restructuring in preparing refund claims, managing BIR audits, assessing CTA filing deadlines, and preserving claims for VAT refunds, excess income tax credits, TCCs, and erroneously paid taxes. For strategic guidance on BIR tax refund compliance and tax litigation risk, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.