A taxpayer won after the Court affirmed that an FLD must address PAN protest arguments in writing, or the BIR assessment may be void for due process violations.

Taxpayers who submit a protest to a Preliminary Assessment Notice should not be met with a bare repetition of the Bureau of Internal Revenue’s original findings in the Formal Letter of Demand. When the Commissioner fails to address the taxpayer’s arguments in writing, the resulting assessment may be void for violation of due process, even if the taxpayer was later able to protest the assessment.

Why This Assessment Dispute Matters

The dispute involved a taxpayer that challenged a tax assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals after the Commissioner issued a Formal Letter of Demand, or FLD. The taxpayer had earlier responded to the Preliminary Assessment Notice, or PAN, and raised arguments against the proposed assessment. In the earlier Decision dated November 26, 2025, the Court declared the assessment void because the FLD failed to consider in writing the arguments raised by the taxpayer in its PAN protest.

The Commissioner then sought reconsideration, arguing that no fatal defect occurred merely because specific language or terminology was not used to show that the taxpayer’s arguments were considered. The Commissioner also argued that further explanation may be unnecessary when the legal basis is supposedly clear and well-established, and that the taxpayer’s arguments were merely persuasive statements that did not rely on sound accounting and legal principles. The case arose from an assessment dispute before the Special Second Division (CTA Case No. 10465).

The Court Rejected Brevity as a Substitute for Due Process

The Court denied the Commissioner’s motion for reconsideration. It held that the Commissioner’s defense of brevity was untenable because the Supreme Court’s ruling in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Avon Products Manufacturing, Inc. requires the Commissioner to address the taxpayer’s points in writing. This written consideration is part of the taxpayer’s right to be informed of the factual and legal bases of the assessment.

The Court emphasized that the purpose of stating the factual and legal basis of an assessment is not merely to convey information concisely or avoid repetition. The purpose is to inform the taxpayer. If the FLD excludes specific details regarding the taxpayer’s protest, the taxpayer is not fully informed of why the protest was rejected. Without that explanation, the taxpayer is not fully informed of the assessment’s basis.

The Court also made clear that an FLD is not a literary exercise where unnecessary details may be omitted for style. It is a letter of demand. It is supposed to communicate the assessment in full. The Court observed that an FLD is usually accompanied by details of discrepancies that break down the assessment and its components. In that context, the priority is not brevity, but completeness.

The BIR May Reject a Taxpayer’s Protest, But It Must Explain Why

The ruling does not mean that the BIR is required to agree with every taxpayer argument. The Court expressly recognized that the Commissioner may retain previous findings when the taxpayer’s protest fails to convince the BIR. The Commissioner may reject incorrect arguments and, in proper cases, is even required to do so.

However, the key point is that rejection must be explained. The Commissioner must state why the taxpayer’s arguments were rejected. If the FLD merely carries forward the same findings without addressing the taxpayer’s protest, the assessment is vulnerable to being declared void. Following Avon, failure to explain the rejection of the taxpayer’s arguments is a due process violation.

Later Protest Rights Do Not Cure a Defective FLD

The Commissioner also argued substantial compliance because the taxpayer was later able to protest the assessment. The Court rejected this argument. Citing Supreme Court rulings such as Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Yumex Philippines Corporation and Prime Steel Mill, Incorporated v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the Court reiterated that a taxpayer’s ability to later protest does not cure due process violations already committed by the Commissioner.

This is important for businesses because the BIR cannot rely on the taxpayer’s subsequent remedies to excuse a defective assessment notice. Due process must be observed at the assessment stage itself. The right to file a protest after receiving the FLD does not erase the BIR’s prior failure to explain why the taxpayer’s PAN protest was rejected.

The Practical Lesson for Taxpayers Facing BIR Assessments

For corporate taxpayers, CFOs, tax managers, and in-house counsel, the ruling highlights the importance of carefully reviewing not only the amount assessed, but also the manner by which the assessment was issued. A taxpayer should examine whether the FLD and accompanying details of discrepancies actually address the factual and legal arguments raised in the PAN protest.

If the FLD merely repeats the BIR’s earlier position without engaging the taxpayer’s specific objections, the taxpayer may have a due process defense. This can be decisive because a void assessment cannot be enforced. However, the defense should be built on the actual contents of the PAN protest, the FLD, and the details of discrepancies. Taxpayers should preserve proof of their submissions and compare each argument against the BIR’s written response.

The ruling also shows why a PAN protest should be prepared strategically. A generic protest may give the BIR little to address. A detailed protest, supported by law, facts, accounting records, and documentary evidence, creates a clearer record. If the BIR ignores those arguments, the taxpayer is in a stronger position to argue that the FLD violated due process.

What Businesses Should Do After Receiving a PAN or FLD

Upon receipt of a PAN, taxpayers should immediately identify every factual and legal issue in the proposed assessment. They should respond with specific arguments and supporting documents, not merely general denials. When the FLD arrives, they should check whether the BIR discussed those arguments in writing. The question is not only whether the BIR disagreed, but whether it explained the reason for the disagreement.

For importers, regulated businesses, utilities, and companies with complex tax positions, this ruling is especially relevant. The more detailed the taxpayer’s position, the more important it becomes for the BIR to show that it considered and rejected the taxpayer’s points based on stated factual and legal grounds. A bare conclusion may not be enough.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in contesting BIR assessments, preparing PAN and FLD protests, evaluating due process defects, and litigating tax disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps businesses assess whether an assessment is enforceable, whether the BIR complied with the required notice procedures, and whether a due process defense can be raised alongside substantive tax arguments.

If your company has received a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, warrant, or collection notice, early review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team and protect your rights before deadlines expire.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *