The tax court denied the BIR’s bid to revive a prescribed CGT assessment, holding that internal lawyer reassignment was not excusable negligence.
Taxpayers facing old capital gains tax assessments gain an important procedural protection from this ruling: once the government’s right to assess has prescribed and the judgment cancelling the assessment has become final, the Bureau of Internal Revenue cannot reopen the case merely by pointing to reassignment of counsel, transition gaps, or internal case management problems.
Background of the Capital Gains Tax Dispute
The dispute arose from deficiency capital gains tax assessments issued against the taxpayer in connection with two deeds of absolute sale of shares of stock dated December 8, 2000 and January 20, 2001. The assessments involved an aggregate amount of Php355,479,878.19, inclusive of surcharges, interest, and compromise penalty.
The taxpayer filed a Petition for Review on December 3, 2020 seeking cancellation of the assessments (CTA Case No. 10414). After trial and submission of memoranda, the tax court rendered a decision dated February 14, 2025 granting the taxpayer’s petition. It cancelled and set aside the Preliminary Assessment Notice dated July 16, 2018, the Final Letter of Demand dated July 1, 2019, and the undated Final Decision on Disputed Assessment on the ground that the government’s right to assess had already prescribed.
No motion for reconsideration was filed for the Commissioner before the decision became final. The Commissioner later claimed that he learned of the decision only on September 17, 2025, when the court issued an order requiring him to comment on the taxpayer’s motion for entry of judgment. On November 17, 2025, the Commissioner filed a verified petition for relief from judgment under Rule 38 of the Rules of Court, arguing that the failure to seek reconsideration was due to excusable negligence caused by the transfer and reassignment of the previous handling lawyer.
The Petition Was Timely, But Timeliness Was Not Enough
The court first addressed whether the petition for relief was filed within the periods required by Rule 38. Under Section 3 of Rule 38, a petition for relief from judgment must be filed within sixty days from knowledge of the judgment or final order, and not more than six months from entry of judgment. Both periods must concur.
On the facts presented, the court found that the petition was filed on time. The Commissioner alleged actual knowledge on September 17, 2025. Sixty days from that date fell on November 16, 2025, a Sunday, making the next working day, November 17, 2025, the last day for filing. The six-month period was likewise satisfied because entry of judgment was made on December 4, 2025, and the petition was filed well before the six-month cut-off counted from that entry.
However, the court made clear that compliance with the filing period does not automatically justify relief from judgment. Rule 38 is an extraordinary remedy. It requires not only timely filing, but also a legally sufficient ground such as fraud, accident, mistake, or excusable negligence, together with a meritorious defense that could reasonably change the outcome if the case were reopened.
Internal BIR Reassignment Was Not Excusable Negligence
The Commissioner argued that the previous handling lawyer’s transfer to another office created a transition gap that caused the failure to file a motion for reconsideration. The court rejected this explanation.
For the court, reassignment of a government lawyer, transition issues, and case management difficulties are organizational matters within the BIR’s own institutional control. These are not extraordinary circumstances that ordinary diligence could not have prevented. They are precisely the types of administrative risks that a litigant, including the government, must anticipate and guard against.
The ruling is significant because it applies the ordinary consequences of counsel negligence to the government as a litigant. The court stressed that the negligence of government counsel binds the government in the same way that the negligence of private counsel generally binds a private party. Otherwise, taxpayers who obtain favorable final judgments would face an unfair asymmetry: private parties would be bound by finality, while the government could seek to reopen cases whenever internal transitions occur.
The Commissioner Also Failed to Show a Meritorious Defense
Even assuming the alleged negligence were excusable, the petition still failed because the Commissioner did not demonstrate a meritorious defense. The substantive theory advanced by the Commissioner was that the ordinary three-year prescriptive period under Section 203 of the National Internal Revenue Code should not apply to one-time transactions involving shares of stock not traded in the local stock exchange.
The Commissioner argued that, for these ONETT transactions, the period to assess should not begin until the taxpayer submits complete documentary requirements and the BIR processes the Certificate Authorizing Registration. The Commissioner also relied on revenue memorandum orders governing ONETT verification procedures to suggest that a distinct assessment regime applied.
The court rejected that position. Section 203 of the NIRC provides that internal revenue taxes must be assessed within three years after the last day prescribed by law for filing the return, or from the actual date of filing, whichever is later. Section 52(D) likewise provides that the capital gains tax return for each sale of shares not traded through a local or foreign stock exchange must be filed within thirty days after each transaction. The court found no statutory distinction between ONETT and non-ONETT transactions for purposes of the three-year prescriptive period.
The court also emphasized that revenue memorandum orders cannot override, expand, or modify the prescriptive period fixed by statute. Administrative issuances on verification procedures cannot create a new accrual rule that delays prescription until the BIR receives complete documents or processes the CAR.
Why the Assessment Remained Void for Prescription
The underlying assessment dates were decisive. The transactions occurred on December 8, 2000 and January 20, 2001. The capital gains tax returns should have been filed by January 8, 2001 and February 19, 2001, respectively. Amended returns were actually filed on March 14, 2001. Using the later date, the Commissioner had only until March 14, 2004 to issue valid assessments.
The Final Letter of Demand, however, was issued only on July 1, 2019, or more than fifteen years after the expiration of the three-year prescriptive period. The court found no clear and convincing evidence of deliberate or willful falsity that would justify resort to the extraordinary ten-year period under Section 222(a) of the NIRC. Accordingly, the prescription of the government’s right to assess was already fully established.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and CFOs
For companies involved in share transfers, ONETT processing, and capital gains tax compliance, this ruling reinforces a critical point: BIR processing delays or incomplete CAR-related documentary submissions do not automatically suspend or reset the statutory period for assessment. The starting point remains the filing deadline or actual filing date of the tax return, as provided by the NIRC.
For taxpayers already litigating assessments before the tax court, the ruling also underscores the value of finality. Once a favorable judgment becomes final, the government cannot lightly reopen the case by invoking internal administrative problems. A petition for relief from judgment is not a second motion for reconsideration, nor is it a device for relitigating arguments already considered and rejected.
For corporate counsel and finance teams, the case highlights the importance of preserving old tax returns, deeds of sale, proof of filing, assessment notices, and timelines. In prescription defenses, dates matter. The validity of an assessment may turn on whether the BIR acted within three years, whether fraud or willful falsity can be proven, and whether administrative issuances are being improperly used to extend a statutory deadline.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporations, importers, and individuals in tax assessment disputes, capital gains tax controversies, ONETT-related issues, administrative protests, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review assessment timelines, evaluate prescription defenses, prepare protests and petitions, and represent clients in proceedings involving the BIR and the tax court.
Businesses facing deficiency tax assessments should not wait until collection action begins. Early review of the assessment record, filing dates, and procedural history can determine whether the government’s claim is still enforceable or already void by prescription. For assistance with tax disputes and Court of Tax Appeals cases, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.