CTA dismisses criminal charges for 2014 deficiency taxes due to prescription, highlighting the five-year period and finality of assessments for tax nonpayment.
Taxpayers and corporate officers should be aware that criminal actions for failure to pay deficiency taxes may be dismissed if filed beyond the statutory prescriptive period. In a recent decision, the Court of Tax Appeals recognized that the government’s right to institute a criminal action for willful failure to pay income and value-added taxes for the taxable year 2014 had already prescribed, resulting in the dismissal of the case.
Background
YES WE CAN INCORPORATED, along with Merle F. Cambay and Ma. Sandra C. Cacalda, faced criminal charges for allegedly refusing to pay deficiency income and VAT covering the 2014 taxable year (CTA Criminal Case No. O-1112). The accused moved to consolidate this case with another criminal action (CTA Criminal Case No. O-1111) and filed a Motion to Quash, arguing that the criminal liability had been extinguished by prescription. The accused contended that the Formal Assessment Notices (FANs) and demand letters were received on January 18, 2018, and no protest was filed, rendering the assessments final and executory on February 17, 2018.
CTA’s Ruling
The Court analyzed the applicable provisions of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) of 1997, as amended, specifically Section 281, which provides that violations of the Code prescribe after five years from the commission of the violation or from discovery thereof. Citing jurisprudence, the CTA emphasized that the offense of failure to pay deficiency taxes occurs only after the finality of the assessment and the taxpayer’s willful refusal to pay within the allotted period. In this case, the finality of the assessments occurred on February 20, 2018. Consequently, the government had until February 20, 2023, to initiate a criminal action. Since the Information was filed on April 3, 2023, it exceeded the five-year prescriptive period by 45 days.
Key Legal Principles
The Court applied Rule 117 of the Revised Rules of Criminal Procedure, which allows an accused to move to quash a complaint or information if criminal liability has been extinguished. The CTA confirmed that prescription is a valid defense that can be invoked before arraignment and prior to entering a plea. By evaluating the timelines of the FAN issuance, receipt, and the lapse of the protest period, the Court concluded that the statutory five-year period had lapsed before the Information was filed.
Practical Takeaways
This decision underscores the importance for tax authorities to act within the prescriptive period when filing criminal cases for non-payment of deficiency taxes. Corporate taxpayers and officers should diligently track the receipt and finality of tax assessments, noting that failure to contest a FAN within 30 days renders the assessment final. Moreover, legal counsel may raise prescription as an effective defense to dismiss cases filed after the statutory period.
For businesses facing potential criminal tax exposure, timely assessment and documentation are critical to safeguard rights. Monitoring the issuance and receipt dates of FANs, as well as the deadlines for filing protests, ensures that both taxpayers and authorities remain compliant with statutory periods and procedural requirements.
How We Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco provides comprehensive tax litigation services, including evaluation of criminal and civil tax exposures, filing motions to quash based on prescription, and strategic representation before the Court of Tax Appeals. To protect your corporate interests and ensure compliance with Philippine tax laws, contact our team of seasoned tax attorneys at